Everyone likes to talk about the "Holy Grail" Playoff Contenders ticket. You know the one—the card where a skinny, almost-unrecognizable Tom Brady is wearing a blue New England Patriots practice jersey and some baggy gray sweatpants. It sells for millions. But honestly, if you’re a real collector or just a Michigan fan, that’s not where the soul of the hobby is. The tom brady michigan card is a completely different animal. It captures the "before." Before the seven rings, before the "GOAT" debates, and before he was even a lock to start in the NFL.
We are talking about a guy who was the 199th pick. Because of that low draft status, card companies in late 1999 and early 2000 weren't exactly tripping over themselves to put him in NFL jerseys. This led to a bunch of early releases featuring him in his iconic winged helmet and Wolverines maize and blue.
The 2000 Press Pass: The People's Rookie
If you’ve spent any time on eBay lately, you’ve seen the 2000 Press Pass #37. It’s basically the gateway drug for Brady collectors. It isn't particularly rare, but it's important. Why? Because it’s one of the few cards that feels "attainable" for a normal person who doesn't have a spare $50k sitting in a high-yield savings account.
Prices for an ungraded base version of this card usually hover around $70 to $100. However, don’t let that low entry point fool you. If you find one in a PSA 10 slab, you’re looking at a jump to over $1,000. People often overlook the "Silver" and "Gold" parallels. The Gold Zone versions are much tougher to find in the wild, and the autograph versions—which are actually on-card—regularly fetch $3,000 to $5,000 depending on the grade.
Why the 2000 Pacific Crown Royale #2 is Secretly the Best Looking
Collectors have a love-hate relationship with Pacific. They were flashy, maybe a little gaudy, and their die-cut designs are a nightmare to grade. The 2000 Crown Royale #2 features Brady in his Michigan uniform, and the card is shaped like a literal crown. It’s peak 2000s aesthetic.
📖 Related: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
These are surprisingly scarce in high grades because those little crown points on the top of the card chip if you even breathe on them. While an ungraded copy might only set you back $25, finding a "Gem Mint" copy is a legitimate hunt. It’s one of those cards that proves value isn't always about the serial number on the back; it's about the difficulty of the "survivorship" of the card's physical condition.
The Confusion Over "Rookie" Years
Here is something that trips up a lot of people: the difference between 1999 and 2000 cards. Technically, Brady's rookie year in the NFL was 2000. But since he was a college star, some "pre-rookie" or "draft" products hit the shelves using his Michigan likeness.
Take the 1999 Upper Deck Encore, for example. You’ll often see these listed with "Michigan" in the title because collectors want to differentiate the college jersey from the NFL jersey. There is also the 2000 Score Rookie Roll Call Autograph. That card is limited to just 50 copies. It shows him dropping back in his Michigan gear. Last time I checked, those were clearing $2,500 easily, and that was for mid-grade copies. If you ever see one of those at a card show for under a grand, you buy it. No questions asked.
Pricing Reality Check (As of early 2026)
The market has settled a bit since the insane peaks of 2021, but the GOAT tax is very real. Even "common" Michigan-era cards are seeing a steady climb as people realize he’s never coming back to the field (for real this time).
👉 See also: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
- 2000 Press Pass #37 (Base): $75 (Raw) / $1,100 (PSA 10)
- 2000 Press Pass Autograph: $3,500+
- 2000 Pacific Aurora #84: $20 - $40 (Raw)
- 2000 Score #316 (Patriots jersey but Michigan pedigree): $150 - $250 (Raw)
Don't ignore the modern "throwback" cards either. Panini loves to put out "Prizm Draft Picks" or "Contenders Draft Picks" sets every year. These aren't rookie cards. They were printed long after he retired. However, the "snakeskin" or "gold" parallels of Brady in a Michigan jersey from these sets still have a massive following among Wolverines alumni.
Identifying a Fake
Because the tom brady michigan card market is so lucrative, the scammers are out in force. The most common fakes are the Press Pass autographs. Genuine 2000 Press Pass autos have a specific texture to the ink and usually a holographic sticker or a very specific "congratulations" text on the back. If the signature looks too perfect—like it was printed on with a laser jet—run away.
Also, look at the "blue" in the Michigan jersey. On many reprints, the navy looks more like a washed-out royal blue. Real 2000-era cardboard has a specific smell and feel. It’s slightly glossier but less "plastic" than the Chrome cards we see today.
What to do if you find one in your attic
First off, don't touch the corners. Second, don't put it in a tight plastic sleeve without a "penny sleeve" first.
✨ Don't miss: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
The best move right now is to check for centering. If the image is shifted to one side, the value drops by 50% immediately. If it looks perfectly centered, it's worth the $25 to $50 to send it to PSA or SGC for grading. A graded "9" or "10" is basically a currency at this point. It's much easier to sell a slabbed Brady than a raw one because the buyer has the peace of mind that they aren't getting a high-quality laser-printed fake from 2024.
Keep an eye on the auction houses like Heritage or Lelands. While they handle the multi-million dollar sales, they also provide the best "sold" data to help you price your own collection. The Michigan cards might not be the highest-priced in his catalog, but they are arguably the most iconic for fans who remember him before the Tuck Rule and the dynasty.
Check the back of your 2000 Fleer Tradition cards too. There’s a "Rookies to Watch" card (#352) that features Brady alongside Dave Stachelski. It’s a dual rookie card. Most people threw those in the commons bin back in the day because they only recognized the other guy. Now? That "worthless" card is a three-figure find in decent shape.
Next Steps for Your Collection:
Go through your old binders and look specifically for the 2000 Press Pass #37 or the 2000 Upper Deck Victory #326. If you find them, use a high-resolution magnifying glass to inspect the four corners for "white" spots where the ink has chipped. If the corners are sharp, your next move is to compare the centering against a known "PSA 10" image online to decide if it's worth the investment of professional grading.