You know that feeling when you drive past the Tanger Outlets and wonder if there's anywhere left to find a real deal without the "tourist" markups? Honestly, most people heading out to the East End just stick to the main drag. They miss the best stuff.
If you're hunting for the actual heartbeat of discount shopping in town, you have to look at the TJ Maxx in Riverhead NY. This isn't just another cookie-cutter retail box. It's a 34,000-square-foot beast that took over the old Christmas Tree Shops spot at 1791 Old Country Road.
The Riverhead Pivot: More Than Just a Move
Back in late 2024, the buzz around town was all about the Christmas Tree Shops closing. It felt like the end of an era for the County Center Plaza area. But then TJ Maxx swooped in. They didn't just move; they leveled up.
Most shoppers don't realize that this specific location is part of a strategic "power hub." You've got HomeGoods and Homesense right nearby. It’s basically a Bermuda Triangle for your paycheck. You go in for a pack of socks and come out with a mid-century modern accent chair and a hand-poured candle that smells like a rainy day in Seattle.
The layout here is significantly more expansive than the older, cramped locations you might find further west on the island. Because it's a newer "Runway" inclusive store, the inventory leans a bit higher-end. We're talking about the purple tag items.
Why the "Runway" Section Matters
Have you ever seen those purple labels at TJ Maxx? That’s the Runway. It’s where the high-fashion stuff lives—European designers that usually sit behind glass at Saks or Neiman Marcus.
At the TJ Maxx in Riverhead NY, the Runway section is surprisingly robust. It’s likely because of the proximity to the Hamptons. Corporate knows that the demographic driving through Riverhead on a Friday afternoon has a different budget than your average Tuesday morning shopper. You might find a $1,200 Italian leather handbag for $400. Still a lot of money? Sure. But for the right person, it’s a steal.
🔗 Read more: Blue Tabby Maine Coon: What Most People Get Wrong About This Striking Coat
Strategy for the Local Maxxinista
If you show up at noon on a Saturday, you’re gonna have a bad time. The parking lot at 1791 Old Country Road gets chaotic. People are trying to navigate between the Starbucks and the Buffalo Wild Wings nearby, and tempers get short.
The real pros? They’re there at 9:30 AM on a Wednesday.
Markdown cycles usually hit mid-week. If you want the yellow tags—which is the absolute final price—you have to beat the weekend rush.
- Monday: Recovery day. The staff is basically putting the store back together after the weekend "hurricane."
- Wednesday/Thursday: The sweet spot for new shipments and fresh markdowns.
- Friday Evening: Pure chaos. Avoid unless you enjoy standing in a line that wraps around the beauty department.
The beauty section at this location is actually one of its strongest suits. They carry a lot of Korean skincare brands and high-end hair tools that usually sell out instantly in the city stores.
Dealing with the Disarray
Let’s be real for a second. Shopping here can be a workout. Sometimes the shoe aisle looks like a toddler had a tantrum with a bunch of size 8 pumps.
Reddit is full of stories from employees explaining why. These stores are getting massive amounts of stock with limited payroll to put it all away. If you see a mess, it’s usually because a customer decided they didn't want a shirt and just chucked it over a rack. Be a decent human and put the hanger back. It helps everyone.
💡 You might also like: Blue Bathroom Wall Tiles: What Most People Get Wrong About Color and Mood
Beyond the Clothes: The Home Secret
Since there is a HomeGoods nearby, you’d think the home section at TJ Maxx in Riverhead NY would be lackluster. Actually, it’s the opposite.
They often stock "crossover" items. I’ve seen high-end gourmet snacks, imported olive oils, and weirdly specific kitchen gadgets that aren't over at HomeGoods. It’s worth the 5-minute walk between the two to compare.
Also, the stationery aisle here is a hidden gem. If you need a birthday card that doesn't cost $8 at a pharmacy, they have the $1.99 ones that actually look expensive.
Location and Access
Finding the place is easy, but exiting is the tricky part.
1791 Old Country Road is right in the thick of it. You’re across from the Tanger Outlets, which means during peak summer season, traffic on Route 58 is a nightmare.
Pro Tip: Use the back exits of the shopping centers to get to the side roads like Roanoke Ave or Harrison Ave. Staying on 58 during a holiday weekend is a trap.
📖 Related: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Superstition Springs Menu: What to Order Right Now
The store is open 9:30 AM to 9:30 PM most days. Sunday is the same. That 9:30 PM closing time is a lifesaver if you realize at the last minute you need a gift or a specific outfit for a Monday morning meeting.
The Verdict on Quality
Is it better than the Tanger Outlets? It depends on what you’re looking for.
Outlets are often "made for outlet" goods. That means the quality might be lower than the main brand's line. TJ Maxx, however, buys overstock from the actual main lines. You’re getting the "real" version of the brand, just from last season or because a department store ordered too many.
For people living in Riverhead or just passing through to the wineries, this TJ Maxx is the most reliable spot for high-low fashion. It’s predictable in its unpredictability.
Actionable Shopping Steps
- Check the labels: Look for the purple "Runway" tags for designer goods and the yellow tags for the lowest possible price.
- Time your visit: Arrive on a Tuesday or Wednesday morning to see the new inventory before the "Hamptons crowd" picks it over on the weekend.
- Download the app: You can scan items in-store to see if they're available online or at other locations like the one in Bridgehampton.
- Inspect everything: Since it’s a high-volume store, check for missing buttons or makeup stains on the collars of white shirts before you head to the register.
- Park strategically: Park closer to the Buffalo Wild Wings side if the main entrance area is packed; it’s a shorter walk than you think and much easier to pull out of.
Stop settling for the picked-over racks at the outlet malls. The real treasure is usually hiding in plain sight at the County Center Plaza.