It's the ultimate lunch-break equalizer. You grab a scrap of paper, scribble two vertical lines and two horizontal ones, and suddenly you're locked in a high-stakes psychological battle with a coworker or a bored eight-year-old. We've all been there. But honestly, most tic tac toe play is just mindless clicking or scratching. People treat it like a game of luck. It isn't.
Tic tac toe is what mathematicians call a "zero-sum game of perfect information." That sounds fancy, but it basically means there are no secrets. Both players see everything. There's no hidden hand of cards, no fog of war, and—crucially—no way to win if both people actually know what they’re doing. It’s a solved game. If you and your opponent play optimally, you will draw every single time. Forever.
So why do we keep losing?
Usually, it’s because we’re playing on autopilot. We’ve been conditioned to think the center square is the only thing that matters. While the center is great, it’s also the most obvious trap in the world. If you want to actually dominate your next match, you have to stop playing for three-in-a-row and start playing for the "fork."
The Cold Math of the Grid
There are 255,168 possible games of tic tac toe. That sounds like a lot until you realize a modern computer can crunch those permutations in less time than it takes you to blink. When you strip away the mirrored versions and rotations, there are only 765 essentially different positions.
Out of those, the first player (X) has a massive mathematical advantage, but only if they’re aggressive. If X plays perfectly, they win or draw. They can never lose. If you’re playing O and you win, it’s not because you were brilliant; it’s because X messed up. That’s the hard truth.
James Grime, a mathematician often featured on the Numberphile YouTube channel, has broken this down extensively. He points out that while the center is the most common starting move, starting in a corner is actually more "dangerous" for a novice opponent. Why? Because the center only gives you four ways to win. A corner also gives you three, but it sets up diagonal traps that people frequently overlook when they’re distracted by the horizontal and vertical lines.
How to Execute the Perfect Fork
If you’re looking to improve your tic tac toe play, you need to memorize one word: Forking.
A fork is when you create two ways to win at the same time. Since your opponent can only block one square per turn, the other one stays open. Game over.
Starting as X
If you go first, take a corner. Don't think about it. Just do it. Most people will instinctively take the center to "block" you. This is their first mistake. If they take the center, you take the opposite corner. Now you have a diagonal started. If they take an edge square next, you’ve got them. You can place your third X in a way that creates two winning lines.
If they don’t take the center? If they take another corner or an edge? They’ve already lost. You can force a win in about four moves. It’s brutal. It feels like magic to them, but to you, it’s just basic geometry.
The Defensive Masterclass (Playing O)
Playing second is about survival. Your only goal is a draw. If X starts in a corner, you must take the center. If you don't take the center, you lose. Period. There is no other viable move.
If X starts in the center, you take a corner. This is the safest way to limit their options. Playing O is basically just being a professional annoyer. You’re just there to get in the way until the grid is full and you both walk away with a "Cat’s Game."
✨ Don't miss: Solving the Jumble 11 26 24: Why This Tuesday Puzzle Tripped Everyone Up
Why Children Love It and Computers Hate It
We teach kids this game because it’s a gateway drug to logic. It teaches spatial awareness and turn-taking. But for a computer, tic tac toe is a nightmare of boredom.
In the 1950s, a researcher named Christopher Strachey wrote one of the first game-playing programs for the Ferranti Mark 1 computer at the University of Manchester. One of the games was tic tac toe. The computer played so perfectly that no human could ever beat it. It sucked the fun out of the room. This led to the development of more complex AI for games like Checkers and eventually Chess, where the "state space" (the number of possible moves) is too big for simple memorization.
In the 1983 movie WarGames, the supercomputer WOPR eventually realizes that tic tac toe—and by extension, nuclear war—is a "strange game" where "the only winning move is not to play." It’s a bit dramatic for a grid of nine squares, but the logic holds up.
Variations That Actually Require Brainpower
If you’re bored of the standard 3x3 grid, you aren't alone. Serious gamers have moved on to variations that actually allow for strategy beyond the first two moves.
- Ultimate Tic Tac Toe: This is a 9x9 grid made of nine smaller tic tac toe boards. Where you play in a small board determines which small board your opponent has to play in next. It’s chaotic. It’s brilliant. It requires you to think three or four "meta-moves" ahead.
- 3D Tic Tac Toe (Qubic): Usually played on a 4x4x4 cube. There are 76 possible winning lines. Unlike the 3x3 version, the first player in a 4x4x4 game has been mathematically proven to have a winning strategy, but it’s so complex that humans can’t easily memorize it.
- Notakto: This is a "misere" version where both players use X. The person who completes a three-in-a-row loses. It turns your spatial instincts upside down.
Common Myths and Mistakes
People think the "Cat" in "Cat’s Game" comes from some ancient Egyptian lore. Kinda wish it did. In reality, it likely comes from the old saying that a cat can’t catch its own tail—just like a player can’t catch a win in a draw. It's just a stalemate.
💡 You might also like: Why Most Strategy Fans Still Love the Castles and Kingdoms Game Experience
Another mistake? Thinking that playing fast intimidates people. In tic tac toe play, speed is the enemy of accuracy. Because the game is so short, one "slip of the pen" is unrecoverable. If you’re playing O and you accidentally place your mark on an edge instead of a corner when the center is taken, you’ve handed the game to X.
The Psychology of the Draw
There is a weird social element to this. When two adults play tic tac toe, there’s an unspoken agreement that we’re checking each other’s pulse. If I win, I’m basically telling you that you aren’t paying attention. If we draw, we acknowledge that we’re both competent.
It becomes a game of chicken. You play the same opening three times in a row, hoping your opponent gets bored and tries something risky. That’s where the wins happen. You don't win by being smarter; you win by being more patient. You wait for the other person to try to "force" a win where one doesn't exist, which invariably opens up a hole in their defense.
How to Win Your Next Match
If you want to walk away from the paper-and-pencil grid as the undisputed champion, stop trying to be creative. Stick to the script.
💡 You might also like: 2xko closed beta announcement: Why the Riot Fighter is Finally Here
- Always choose X if you can. The statistical advantage is real.
- Aim for the corners first. It creates more complex "blocking" requirements for your opponent than the center does.
- Watch for the L-shape. If you have two marks in corners that aren't opposite each other, and your opponent hasn't taken the edge between them, you’re one move away from a fork.
- Force their hand. Every move you make should be a threat that requires a block. If they’re busy blocking you, they can’t build their own line.
- Accept the draw. If you’re playing a savvy opponent, don't tilt. A draw is a successful defensive play.
The next time you find yourself staring at those four lines, remember that you’re looking at a puzzle that was solved centuries ago. You aren't playing against the person across from you; you’re playing against the math. Don't let the math win. Take the corner, hunt for the fork, and keep your eyes on the diagonals.