Rome was different in 1954. It was quieter, dustier, and—thanks to a massive CinemaScope lens—vibrant enough to make your eyes ache. At the center of it all was the three coins in the fountain cast, a group of actors who weren't just making a movie; they were essentially creating the blueprint for the "American girl abroad" subgenre that we still see in everything from Emily in Paris to Under the Tuscan Sun. People forget how huge this was. It wasn't just a flick. It was a cultural event that made every secretary in Des Moines want to hurl her life savings into a fountain in Italy.
The plot is basic. Three American women working in Rome wish for love at the Trevi Fountain. But the casting is where things get interesting. You had the veteran, the rising star, and the dependable ingenue.
The Power Trio of Dorothy McGuire, Jean Peters, and Maggie McNamara
Honestly, the chemistry worked because the women were at such different stages of their real-world careers. Dorothy McGuire played Miss Frances, the "old pro" who had been in Rome for fifteen years working for a grumpy writer. McGuire was already a heavyweight. She’d done A Tree Grows in Brooklyn and Gentleman's Agreement. She brought this weary, intelligent dignity to the role that grounded the whole movie. Without her, it might have floated away into pure fluff.
Then you’ve got Jean Peters as Anita. Peters is a fascinating figure in Hollywood history, mostly because she eventually dropped off the map to marry Howard Hughes. In this film, she’s the one breaking the rules. She's dating an Italian colleague, which was a "no-no" according to their office regulations. Peters had this earthy, approachable energy. She didn't look like a porcelain doll; she looked like someone you’d actually meet at a bus stop, which made the romance feel surprisingly grounded for a 1950s Technicolor dream.
And the third? Maggie McNamara. She played Maria, the newcomer. McNamara was the "it girl" of the moment, fresh off an Oscar nomination for The Moon Is Blue. She had this wide-eyed, almost Audrey Hepburn-ish quality, but with a sharper, more calculating edge. Her character literally studies a Prince to figure out how to catch him. It’s kinda cynical if you really think about it, but McNamara plays it with such charm that you root for her anyway.
The Men Who Played the Targets
It’s funny. Even though the movie is titled after the women’s wishes, the three coins in the fountain cast wouldn’t work without the men they were chasing. Or, in some cases, the men chasing them.
🔗 Read more: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
Clifton Webb played John Frederick Shadwell. Webb was a specialized actor. He did "fussy, intellectual, and slightly arrogant" better than anyone else in history. He was the writer Dorothy McGuire’s character was secretly in love with. Their subplot is actually the most moving part of the film because it deals with illness and late-stage regret rather than just "first sight" sparks.
Then there was Louis Jourdan. If you needed a European Prince in the 50s, you called Jourdan. He played Prince Dino di Cessi. He’s the quintessential suave pursuer. Opposite him, you had Rossano Brazzi playing Giorgio, the soulful Italian working at the agency. Brazzi became a massive star after this, basically becoming the face of the "Italian Lover" trope for a decade.
The Uncredited Star: Rome in CinemaScope
We have to talk about the cinematography because the cast was often competing with the background. This was the first time a film had been shot on location in Italy using the new wide-screen CinemaScope process. Director Jean Negulesco basically treated the city as a lead actor.
The Trevi Fountain? It wasn't the tourist trap it is today. In the film, it looks like a private sanctuary. When the three coins in the fountain cast stood in front of those cascades, it was a technical nightmare to light and record sound, but it looked like magic on screen. The film actually won the Oscar for Best Cinematography because of it.
Why the Casting Choices Were Risky for 1954
Hollywood was changing. The studio system was starting to crack. Casting Jean Peters—a woman known for more rugged roles—as a romantic lead in a glamorous travelogue was a bit of a pivot. And McNamara? She was a stage actress who didn't quite fit the "bombshell" mold of the era.
💡 You might also like: Despicable Me 2 Edith: Why the Middle Child is Secretly the Best Part of the Movie
But that's why it holds up.
If they had cast three identical blondes, the movie would be forgotten. Instead, they chose three women with distinct voices and distinct motivations. You have the career woman (McGuire), the rule-breaker (Peters), and the social climber (McNamara). Most modern audiences find themselves identifying with McGuire’s Miss Frances. There's something relatable about her quiet devotion to a man who barely notices her until it’s almost too late.
Misconceptions About the Production
People often think this was a small romantic comedy. It wasn't. It was a massive financial gamble for 20th Century Fox. They spent a fortune on location shooting.
There's also a common mistake where people confuse this movie with the 1964 remake, The Pleasure Seekers, or the 2010 movie When in Rome. While those films use similar setups, they lack the specific gravitas that the original three coins in the fountain cast brought. The 1954 version has a certain melancholy beneath the surface. It’s about loneliness as much as it is about love.
The title song, performed by an uncredited Frank Sinatra, also adds a layer of longing that the later versions couldn't replicate. It’s one of the few times a theme song and a cast are so perfectly in sync that they become inseparable in the public consciousness.
📖 Related: Death Wish II: Why This Sleazy Sequel Still Triggers People Today
The Legacy of the Performers
Looking back, the trajectories of the cast members were wildly different.
- Dorothy McGuire continued to be the "conscience" of Hollywood movies, moving into matriarchal roles in films like Swiss Family Robinson.
- Jean Peters vanished into the strange world of Howard Hughes’ seclusion, rarely appearing in public again.
- Maggie McNamara had a tragic path. Her career cooled off quickly, and she struggled with mental health issues before her untimely death in the 70s.
- Louis Jourdan and Rossano Brazzi stayed the course as international icons, Jourdan eventually playing a Bond villain in Octopussy.
Key Actionable Insights for Classic Film Fans
If you're planning to revisit the film or see it for the first time, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience:
- Watch the background. Since this was one of the first CinemaScope films shot in Rome, look at the street scenes. You're seeing a version of Italy that was still recovering from the war but was on the cusp of the "Dolce Vita" explosion.
- Listen to the dialogue pacing. Notice how McGuire and Webb interact. It’s much faster and more "theatrical" than modern acting, but it conveys a lot of subtext regarding their social status.
- Contrast the three romances. The film is structured to show three different "types" of love: the young and impulsive, the forbidden and practical, and the mature and sacrificial.
To really appreciate the three coins in the fountain cast, try to find a restored 4K version. The original Technicolor dyes were incredibly saturated, and most low-quality streams wash out the nuances of the costume design—which was also Oscar-nominated. Pay attention to how the color of each woman's dress often reflects her emotional state or her "wish" at the fountain.
The movie serves as a time capsule. It’s not just about finding a husband in a foreign country; it’s about the mid-century American obsession with European sophistication. The cast didn't just play characters; they played archetypes of an era that was looking for beauty after a very dark decade.
For the best viewing experience, pair the movie with a bit of research on the Trevi Fountain's restoration history. It gives you a deeper appreciation for the "stage" these actors were performing on. You’ll realize that while the actors are gone, the stone and water remain exactly as they were when Dorothy McGuire first made her wish.
Next Steps for Enthusiasts:
Search for the "CinemaScope 55" documentary shorts to see how the camera technology used in this film changed cinematography forever. Additionally, check the American Film Institute (AFI) archives for production notes on the location scouting in Rome—it was notoriously difficult to film at the fountain due to the crowds, even in the 50s. If you're interested in the fashion, look up Dorothy Jeakins' sketches for the film; her work here influenced travel wardrobes for American women for years.