Summer is basically the only time of year where we all collectively agree to act like different people. One minute you're a high-functioning professional, and the next, you're arguing with a stranger on TikTok about whether a pool day beats a beach day. It's wild. But honestly, the this or that summer edition phenomenon isn't just a silly social media trend anymore. It’s actually a peek into how we’re all trying to curate the "perfect" version of ourselves when the sun finally stays out past 8:00 PM.
People get it wrong, though. They think these choices are just surface-level. They’re not.
The Psychology Behind the Choice
Most folks assume picking "Sunrise Hike" over "Sunset BBQ" is just about the schedule. Dr. Harville Hendrix and other relationship experts have pointed out that these "would you rather" structures actually lower our defenses. It’s a low-stakes way to show vulnerability. By the time 2026 rolled around, we saw a massive shift in how these games are played. We aren't just choosing between ice cream and popsicles. We're choosing between "Digital Detox in the Woods" or "Luxury Resort with 5G."
That’s a big leap.
You see, the this or that summer edition has become a sort of social shorthand. If you pick "Sandals" over "Sneakers" in 2026, you’re likely leaning into that neo-bourgeois aesthetic that’s been all over the runways at Dior and Chanel this season. It’s about the vibe you’re projecting to the world.
💡 You might also like: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
What’s Actually Trending This Year?
Forget the old "Hot Girl Summer" tropes. We've moved on.
- The Yellow Wave: If your choices don't involve "Vanilla Yellow" or "Popcorn Yellow," are you even in 2026? These shades are up over 22% in fashion forecasts.
- Raw Authenticity: There’s a huge push for "Brut Denim" and "Natural Tones." This means choosing a "Lived-in Hair Look" over "Platinum Perfection."
- Tech vs. Nature: This is the big one. With cloud gaming platforms like AirGPU making it possible to play AAA titles on a phone at the beach, the "Gaming vs. Swimming" debate is getting blurry.
The Ultimate This or That Summer Edition List (2026 Style)
I’ve spent way too much time looking at engagement data from platforms like Roblox and Instagram to see what actually gets people talking. If you want to run your own version of this game for your friends or your brand, you’ve gotta mix the classics with the weird stuff.
1. The Classic Vibe Check
- Pool or Beach? (The eternal struggle.)
- Iced Coffee or Frozen Lemonade?
- Sunrise Yoga or Sunset Meditation?
- Road Trip or Direct Flight?
2. The 2026 Aesthetic Test
📖 Related: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
- Vanilla Yellow or Muted Berry?
- Birkin Bangs or Sleek Bun?
- Lace Maxi Skirts or Oversized Brut Denim?
- Thong Sandals or Retro Moccasins?
3. The Deep Summer Questions
- No Phone for a Week or No AC for a Week? (Ouch.)
- Private Backyard BBQ or Crowded Music Festival?
- Sleeping Under the Stars or 5-Star Hotel?
- Reading a Physical Book or Bingeing a New Series?
Why We Can’t Stop Choosing
Humans love categories. We love to belong. When you post your this or that summer edition answers, you’re basically sending out a bat-signal for your tribe. If you choose "Bonfire" and "Acoustic Guitar," you’re looking for the cozy, indie-folk crowd. If you’re choosing "Rooftop Bar" and "Espresso Martini," you’re signaling something else entirely.
There's also the "choice fatigue" factor. Life is heavy. Deciding between a "Bikini" or "One-Piece" (which, by the way, is seeing a massive resurgence in 2026 thanks to brands like Zimmermann) feels manageable. It’s a tiny bit of control in a chaotic world.
How to Use This for Your Brand or Squad
If you're trying to actually do something with this, stop being boring. Don't just list the items. Give people a reason to argue.
👉 See also: Curtain Bangs on Fine Hair: Why Yours Probably Look Flat and How to Fix It
Instead of asking "Burger or Hot Dog," ask "Is a Hot Dog a Sandwich or a Summer Taco?" That's how you get 400 comments and an accidental feature on Google Discover. Use "this or that" as a way to build community. In the workplace, HR teams are using these as "Employee Engagement Holidays" to break the ice in remote teams. It works because it’s fast.
Nobody wants a three-hour "get to know you" seminar. They want to know if you're a "Fan On" or "Fan Off" person when you sleep.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Summer
Don't just read about the trends—live them. Here is how you can actually apply this logic to have a better season:
- Identify Your Non-Negotiables: Pick three "This" items that define your summer (e.g., "Saturday Markets," "Early Morning Runs," "Iced Matcha"). Protect those appointments in your calendar.
- Audit Your Wardrobe: If you're leaning toward the 2026 "Romantic Fabrics" trend, look for lace and sheer textures. If you're "Team Adventure," invest in high-durability gear before the July price hikes.
- Host a Comparison Night: Invite friends over and have them vote on summer staples—blind taste-test three different ice cream brands or two different sparkling waters. It sounds nerdy, but it’s the best way to spark a 2-hour debate that doesn't involve politics.
- Digital Boundaries: Decide now if you are "Post Every Moment" or "Ghost for the Summer." Setting that "This or That" boundary for your mental health is more important than any outfit choice.
Summer is short. Spend it on the side of the choice that actually makes you happy, not the one that looks better on a grid.