You’ve probably been scouring Spotify or digging through old vinyl crates looking for a specific track titled This Is My Song Elton John. It’s a common search. It feels like it should exist, right? Elton has a discography that spans over half a century, thousands of performances, and hundreds of songs that have become the literal soundtrack to our lives. But here is the weird thing: if you are looking for a song officially titled "This Is My Song" written or originally released by Elton John, you won't find it.
Music history is messy. It’s full of mislabeled Napster files from 2004, confusingly similar titles, and covers that people forget aren't originals. Honestly, the confusion around This Is My Song Elton John usually stems from a mix-up with a 1960s classic written by Charlie Chaplin (yes, that Charlie Chaplin) or a deep-seated mental overlap with Elton’s actual masterpiece, "Your Song."
Let's clear the air.
The "Your Song" Confusion
Most people searching for This Is My Song Elton John are actually thinking of "Your Song." It makes sense. The lyrics literally start with "It’s a little bit funny, this feeling inside." It’s a song about writing a song. Bernie Taupin, Elton’s lifelong lyricist, wrote the words at the breakfast table in 1969 while stained with coffee. Elton sat down at the piano and composed the melody in about twenty minutes.
It’s the definitive "my song" for millions of people.
But there is a technicality here. In the world of SEO and digital music databases, titles get mangled. If you ask a voice assistant to "play the Elton John song that goes 'this is my song'," it might get confused. "Your Song" was the breakthrough. It was the moment Elton stopped being a session musician and started being a superstar. Released in 1970 on his self-titled second album, it peaked at number eight in the US and number seven in the UK. It is a simple, earnest ballad. No fluff. No giant glasses or feathers yet. Just a guy and his piano.
🔗 Read more: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
Did He Cover a Song Called "This Is My Song"?
There is a very famous track called "This Is My Song." It was written by Charlie Chaplin for the 1967 film A Countess from Hong Kong. Petula Clark made it a global smash. It topped the charts in the UK, Ireland, Australia—everywhere.
Because Elton John started his career as a session musician at Dick James Music, he recorded dozens of "soundalike" covers for budget compilation albums. These were the Top of the Pops records where anonymous singers would mimic the hits of the day. It is entirely possible—though rarely documented in his official discography—that a young Reginald Dwight (Elton’s birth name) sang on a demo or a budget cover of the Petula Clark hit.
However, if you are looking for a studio-polished, Rocket Records-produced version of the Chaplin tune, it doesn't exist. Elton tends to stick to his own compositions or very specific, curated covers of his idols like Leon Russell, The Beatles, or Bernie’s lyrics.
The Semantic Shift: Why the Keywords Matter
We live in an era of "tip of my tongue" syndrome. You remember a lyric, you type it into Google, and you hope for the best.
When you search for this is my song elton john, the algorithm is trying to bridge the gap between what you typed and what you meant. Often, users are actually looking for "The One," "Rocket Man," or even "Tiny Dancer," but the phrase "this is my song" is a psychological placeholder for "the song I identify with."
💡 You might also like: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
Interestingly, Elton did have a song called "This Song Has No Title" from the 1973 juggernaut Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. It’s a meta-commentary on fame and creativity.
"Look at me now, I'm a man who's got everything / Except for a song that I can call my own."
The irony is thick. He has more songs than almost anyone in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, yet the lyrics play with the idea of ownership and identity. This might be where some of the linguistic confusion starts.
The Collaboration Factor
Another reason people get tripped up is Elton's propensity for massive collaborations. From "Don't Go Breaking My Heart" with Kiki Dee to "Cold Heart" with Dua Lipa, his name is attached to everything. In the late 90s and early 2000s, there were several tribute albums and "Divas Live" style performances.
Sometimes, people mistake songs by his contemporaries—like Billy Joel’s "Piano Man"—as an Elton track. It sounds crazy to a die-hard fan, but to a casual listener, the "piano man" archetype belongs to Elton. If someone says "This is my song" while "Piano Man" is playing, a digital search for this is my song elton john is the inevitable result.
📖 Related: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
How to Actually Find the Song You Are Looking For
If you’ve got a melody in your head and "This Is My Song" isn't pulling it up, you need to pivot your search strategy.
- Check the Lyrics: If the lyrics mention "the kids are all right" or "Saturday night," you’re looking for "Saturday Night's Alright for Fighting."
- The Era Matters: Is it a 70s ballad? Try "Daniel" or "Sorry Seems to Be the Hardest Word." Is it an 80s synth-pop track? Look at "I'm Still Standing."
- The Disney Link: A huge segment of the population knows Elton primarily through The Lion King. "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" or "Circle of Life" are often the songs people refer to as "their" song.
The truth is, Elton John doesn't have a track called "This Is My Song" because he has "Your Song." It was a genius move by Bernie Taupin. By titling it "Your Song," they gave the ownership to the listener immediately. It wasn't Elton's song anymore; it belonged to whoever was listening to it at that moment.
The "Lost" Tapes and Demos
There is a tiny, slim chance you are thinking of a deep cut from the Jewel Box collection. Released in 2020, this massive 8-CD box set featured 148 songs, many of which had never been heard. There are tracks like "I've Been Taught by Blood" and "The Tide Will Turn for Rebecca."
Even in that mountain of archival material, the specific title This Is My Song Elton John does not appear. What you will find is the evolution of a genius. You hear the rough edges. You hear a young man trying to find his voice before he became the "Rocket Man."
Actionable Steps for Music Collectors
If you are trying to verify a specific Elton John track or clear up a "phantom song" in your library, follow these steps to get the right data:
- Use Discogs: Search for Elton John’s master list. If it isn't on Discogs, it likely wasn't an official release.
- Verify the Lyrics: Use a site like Genius to input the specific phrases you remember. If "this is my song" is the only phrase you have, try adding words like "piano," "ballad," or "1972."
- Shazam the Melody: If you have a recording of the song, use Shazam or the Google Humming feature. It is surprisingly accurate at identifying Elton's specific vocal timbre, even on obscure live boots.
- Look for the "Dick James Demos": If the song sounds very old and acoustic, search the Dick James Demos era (1967–1969). This is where the most "hidden" Elton tracks live.
Ultimately, the hunt for this is my song elton john usually ends at the same place: a realization that "Your Song" is the track that’s been playing in your head. It’s the ultimate tribute to the listener, and perhaps the reason why, decades later, we’re still trying to claim a piece of Elton’s catalog as our own.
Stop searching for the wrong title and go put on Madman Across the Water. The song you're looking for is probably sitting right there, waiting to be rediscovered under its real name.