Ever walked into a room and found yourself narrating exactly what you were doing? "Keys... where are the keys... oh, they’re on the counter." You probably looked around to see if anyone heard you. It feels a little weird. Society has basically spent centuries telling us that if you're thinking out loud, you might be losing your mind. We associate it with eccentricity or, worse, genuine cognitive decline.
But science actually says the opposite.
Talking to yourself isn't a sign of madness. It’s a sign of a high-functioning brain. It’s a cognitive tool used by some of the most successful people in history—from Albert Einstein to professional athletes. When you externalize your internal monologue, you aren't just making noise; you’re literally hacking your brain’s processing power.
It’s time we stop being embarrassed about it.
The Cognitive Science of the External Monologue
Why do we do it?
Psychologists call it external self-talk. It’s not just one thing. It’s a spectrum that ranges from "Where did I put my phone?" to complex problem-solving during a high-stakes surgery. Research published in the Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology by Gary Lupyan and Daniel Swingley found that talking to yourself can actually speed up your ability to find objects. In one of their famous experiments, they showed people pictures of common items. Those who said the name of the object out loud found it significantly faster than those who stayed silent.
Basically, the sound of the word "apple" primes your visual system to look for an apple. It makes the concept "real" in the physical world.
Think about how kids learn. A toddler doesn't think in silence. They narrate their entire life. "The block goes here. Now the red one." Around the age of seven, society starts shushing them. We tell them to use their "inside voice." This transition from external speech to inner speech is a developmental milestone identified by Lev Vygotsky, a titan in developmental psychology. But Vygotsky also argued that we never truly lose the need for that external voice. We just hide it because we don't want to look "crazy" at the grocery store.
When tasks get harder, we revert. Even the most stoic professional will start muttering under their breath when the Excel spreadsheet breaks or the IKEA instructions stop making sense. It's a natural reflex.
How Thinking Out Loud Changes the Way You Solve Problems
If you've ever worked in software engineering, you might know about "Rubber Ducking."
It’s a real thing.
The developer keeps a literal rubber duck on their desk. When they hit a bug they can’t fix, they explain the code, line by line, to the duck. Why? Because the act of translating a thought into spoken language forces the brain to organize information differently. To speak, you have to be linear. You have to be logical. Your brain can skip steps in silence; it can’t skip them when you’re talking.
- Linear Processing: Speech moves at a slower pace than thought. This "slow down" prevents your mind from racing past the actual error.
- Audio-Visual Loop: You aren't just "thinking" the idea; you are hearing it. This creates a feedback loop that engages more of the cerebral cortex.
- Emotional Regulation: Ever been incredibly angry and said, "Okay, calm down, just take a breath"? That's external self-talk acting as a governor for your amygdala.
Psychologist Ethan Kross, author of Chatter, has done extensive work on "distanced self-talk." He found that people who talk to themselves in the third person—using their own name or "you" instead of "I"—perform better under stress. If you say, "Okay, John, you can do this," rather than "I can do this," you create a psychological distance. You become your own coach.
🔗 Read more: Cable Machine for Rear Delts: The Setup You Are Probably Messing Up
Why Athletes and Surgeons Won’t Shut Up
Watch a professional tennis player after a missed serve. They aren't just grimacing. They are often having a full-blown conversation with themselves.
In sports psychology, this is known as instructional self-talk. A study on elite athletes showed that verbalizing specific movements—"Keep the elbow up" or "Follow through"—increases accuracy and muscle memory retention. It isn’t just "positive thinking" fluff. It’s a targeted cognitive intervention.
Surgeons do it too. In high-pressure operating rooms, "point and call" systems (popularized by Japanese railways as shinka-tenko) involve physically pointing at a gauge or a body part and stating its status out loud. "Clamp is secure." "Heart rate is 70." This externalization reduces human error by nearly 85% in some industries. When you hear yourself say it, your brain registers the action as "complete" or "verified" in a way that a silent thought simply doesn't.
The Social Stigma We Need to Kill
We really need to talk about the "crazy person" trope.
For a long time, talking to yourself was listed as a symptom of schizophrenia or other psychotic disorders. While it’s true that some mental health conditions involve auditory hallucinations or disorganized speech, that is fundamentally different from thinking out loud.
The difference is "agency."
If you are choosing to speak your thoughts to help yourself focus, that’s a tool. If you feel like you are responding to a voice you can't control, that’s a clinical matter. Confusing the two has made us all a bit more neurotic than we need to be. We suppress a perfectly healthy, high-performance habit because we’re afraid of what the person in the next cubicle thinks.
👉 See also: Signs of Early Heart Issues: What Most People Get Wrong
Honestly, the person in the next cubicle is probably struggling to focus because they aren't talking to themselves.
Real-World Benefits of Talking to Yourself
It's not just for finding your car keys. Here is how this habit actually manifests in daily life:
- Memory Retention: If you need to remember a grocery list or a phone number, say it out loud. The "production effect" suggests that words spoken aloud are better remembered than words read silently because they are more distinct to the brain.
- Decision Making: When you're torn between two choices, record yourself explaining both options on your phone. Play it back. Hearing your own voice argue a point makes the flaws in the logic much more obvious.
- Goal Setting: Stating your intentions out loud makes them feel like a commitment. It moves them from the "imagination" bucket to the "action" bucket.
- Anxiety Management: Externalizing your fears—"I am worried about this meeting because I don't feel prepared"—gives you a sense of control over the emotion. It’s no longer a vague cloud; it’s a sentence you can dissect.
The "How-To" of Productive Self-Talk
Not all talking is helpful. If you’re just standing there calling yourself an idiot for ten minutes, you’re not "thinking out loud"—you’re ruminating. That’s actually destructive.
To make this a "superpower," you have to change the syntax. Use "the third person" approach mentioned earlier. Instead of saying, "Why did I do that?" try, "[Your Name], why did you do that?" It sounds silly until you try it. It immediately shifts you from a state of "victim of my own thoughts" to "observer of my own behavior."
Keep it instructional. Focus on the "what" and "how," not just the "why."
"What is the next step?"
"The next step is to open the file."
This creates a momentum that silent thought often lacks. Silent thought is prone to "looping"—going over the same worry without ever reaching a conclusion. Speech is naturally progressive. It has to go somewhere.
Actionable Steps to Harness Your Internal Voice
Stop shushing yourself. If you want to actually use this to get better at life, work, or just not losing your wallet, here is how you start.
👉 See also: Why Do People Smoke Cigarettes After Sex? The Real Science and Psychology Behind the Post-Coital Puff
Narrate your high-stakes tasks.
When you are doing something where the margin for error is low—like setting an alarm for an early flight or double-checking a contract—say the actions out loud. "I am setting the alarm for 4:30 AM. I am checking that the AM is selected." It sounds repetitive, but it builds a mental "checkpoint" that prevents those "Did I actually do that?" moments of panic later.
Use the "Voice Memo" strategy for big problems.
Instead of staring at a blank page, walk around your room and explain the problem to an imaginary person. Or better yet, hit record on your phone. Most people find they can "talk out" a 1,000-word essay or a business strategy in ten minutes, whereas typing it might take two hours.
Practice "Distance Talking" during stress.
Next time you feel a panic attack or a wave of imposter syndrome coming on, go to a private space (the bathroom, your car) and talk to yourself by name. "Okay, Sarah, you've been here before. You know how to handle this." This isn't "manifesting"—it's a clinical technique to lower your heart rate and re-engage the prefrontal cortex.
Own the habit.
If someone catches you talking to yourself, don't turn red and apologize. Just say you’re "processing out loud." It’s a sign of a focused mind. The more you embrace the external monologue, the more you'll find your internal thoughts becoming clearer, sharper, and way more manageable.
The most important conversation you will ever have is the one you have with yourself. You might as well make sure you can hear it.
Next Steps for Mastery
- Identify your "muttering triggers": Notice when you naturally start talking to yourself. Is it when you're stressed? Happy? Lost? Understanding your triggers helps you use the tool more intentionally.
- The 30-Second Narrator: Tomorrow morning, try narrating your most complex task for just 30 seconds. Observe if you feel more "present" in the task.
- Audit your tone: If your external voice is meaner than you’d ever be to a friend, consciously pivot to "Coach Mode." You're the one listening, after all.