You’re lying in bed at 2:00 AM. Suddenly, a memory from 2014 hits you. It’s that one time you said something incredibly awkward during a job interview, or maybe it’s the way you handled a breakup that still feels like a raw wound. Your brain starts looping. You’re thinking in the past tense, replaying the tape, trying to edit a script that has already been shot, edited, and released to the public.
It’s exhausting.
Most of us treat our memories like a courtroom where we are both the defendant and the hanging judge. We look back and think, I should have known better. But that’s the trick, isn't it? You didn’t know better then. You only know better now because you’re looking at it from the future. Psychology has a specific name for this kind of mental time travel: rumination. It’s not just "remembering." It’s a repetitive, passive focus on the causes and consequences of your past distress. And honestly, it’s one of the fastest ways to tank your mental health.
The Science of Why We Get Stuck in "Back Then"
Our brains aren't actually designed to make us happy. They’re designed to keep us alive. From an evolutionary standpoint, thinking in the past tense served a massive purpose. If a primitive human barely escaped a saber-toothed tiger by a specific watering hole, their brain would replay that event constantly. Why? To ensure it never, ever happened again.
But today? We don’t have many tigers. Instead, we have social rejection, career failures, and "the one who got away."
When you ruminate, you’re activating the Default Mode Network (DMN) in your brain. This is the part of the brain that’s active when you aren't focusing on the outside world. It’s where your "self" lives. Research from Harvard University, specifically studies led by psychologists Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert, suggests that a wandering mind is an unhappy mind. They found that people spend nearly 47% of their waking hours thinking about something other than what they’re doing. Often, that "something" is a past event we can't change.
The Hindsight Bias Trap
You’ve probably heard of hindsight bias. It’s the "I-knew-it-all-along" effect. When you’re thinking in the past tense, your brain tricks you into believing that an event was predictable, even if there was no way you could have seen it coming at the time.
Consider a stock market crash.
After the bubble bursts, everyone points to the "obvious" signs. But if it were actually obvious, the bubble wouldn't have formed in the first place. You do this to yourself, too. You blame yourself for staying in a bad relationship for three years because "the red flags were there." Sure, they’re visible now. But back then, they were just quirks or things you hoped would change. You’re judging your past self with your current self's data set. That’s not a fair fight.
🔗 Read more: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis
Depression vs. Reflection: There’s a Massive Difference
There is a fine line between healthy reflection and toxic rumination.
- Reflection is analytical. It asks, "What can I do differently next time?" It leads to a plan.
- Thinking in the past tense as rumination is circular. It asks, "Why did I do that?" and "What's wrong with me?" It leads to a hole.
Psychologist Susan Nolen-Hoeksema, a pioneer in the study of rumination, found that people who ruminate are more likely to develop clinical depression and anxiety. It’s because rumination interferes with problem-solving. It’s like spinning your tires in the mud. You’re burning a lot of energy, but you’re just getting deeper into the muck.
Honestly, it's kinda fascinating how we can be our own worst enemies. We think that by obsessing over the past, we’re "processing" it. We aren't. We're just reinforcing the neural pathways of the pain.
The Cultural Obsession with "What If"
We live in a culture that loves a good "what if" story. Multiverse movies are everywhere. We’re obsessed with the idea that one small change in the past could have led to a perfect present. This feeds into our personal thinking in the past tense.
We look at our lives and see a series of forks in the road. We ignore the fact that at every one of those forks, we made the best decision we could with the information, emotional maturity, and energy we had at the time.
Nostalgia Isn't Always Your Friend
Not all past-tense thinking is negative, but even the "good" kind—nostalgia—can be a trap.
The term "nostalgia" was actually coined by a Swiss medical student in 1688 as a literal disease. He thought it was a physical ailment suffered by soldiers longing for home. While we now view it as a bittersweet, fuzzy feeling, it can prevent us from engaging with the present. If you’re constantly thinking that your "glory days" are behind you, you stop looking for glory in the here and now. You start living like a ghost in your own life.
How to Break the Loop
So, how do you stop? How do you move out of the past tense and back into the present?
💡 You might also like: Dr. Sharon Vila Wright: What You Should Know About the Houston OB-GYN
It’s not about "just stopping." You can’t tell a brain to stop thinking any more than you can tell a heart to stop beating. You have to redirect it.
1. The Two-Minute Rule
If you find yourself starting to loop on a past event, give yourself two minutes. If you haven't found a solution or a new way of looking at it that makes you feel better within two minutes, you have to move. Physically move. Stand up, do ten jumping jacks, or go wash a dish. Changing your physical environment can sometimes "break" the neural loop of thinking in the past tense.
2. Third-Person Perspective
Research published in the journal Psychological Science suggests that "self-distancing" helps. Instead of saying "Why did I say that?", ask "Why did [Your Name] say that?" It sounds weird. It feels a bit like you’re a character in a book. But that’s the point. It creates a bit of space between your ego and the memory. It lowers the emotional heat.
3. Radical Acceptance
This is a concept from Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), developed by Marsha Linehan. It’s basically the practice of accepting reality as it is, without judgment or attempts to change it. It doesn't mean you like what happened. It just means you stop fighting it. You say, "That happened. It sucked. It is over."
Real-World Consequences of the Past-Tense Mindset
If you spend your life thinking in the past tense, your relationships suffer.
You’re never fully "there" with the person in front of you. You’re comparing them to an ex, or you’re distracted by a grudge you’re holding from five years ago.
In business, it’s just as deadly. Founders who can’t move past a failed product launch often miss the pivot that would save their company. They’re so busy mourning the "past-tense" version of their dream that they can't see the "present-tense" opportunity.
The Role of Forgiveness (For Yourself)
Forgiveness is often misunderstood as letting someone else off the hook. But the hardest person to forgive is usually yourself. When you’re stuck thinking in the past tense, you’re essentially refusing to forgive a version of you that no longer exists.
📖 Related: Why Meditation for Emotional Numbness is Harder (and Better) Than You Think
Think about who you were five or ten years ago. You’ve replaced almost every cell in your body since then. You have different perspectives. You’ve learned things. Why are you still punishing the current "you" for the mistakes of a "you" that’s basically a different person?
Shifting the Narrative
You can’t change the past, but you can change the story you tell about the past.
Instead of a story of failure, can it be a story of endurance?
Instead of a story of "what I lost," can it be a story of "what I survived"?
Psychologists call this narrative identity. We are the stories we tell ourselves. If your story is written entirely in the past tense, you’re a finished book. If you start writing in the present tense, you’re a work in progress.
Actionable Steps to Reclaim Your Brain
Stop the scroll. Not just on your phone, but the mental scroll of your old mistakes.
- Write it out, then burn it. It's a cliché for a reason. Getting the thoughts out of your head and onto paper externalizes them. When you burn or shred the paper, you’re giving your brain a physical signal that the "processing" session is over.
- The "So What?" Method. When a cringey memory pops up, challenge it. So what? So you tripped on stage in 2012. So what? Does it affect your mortgage? Your current friendships? Your ability to eat a sandwich? Usually, the answer is a resounding "no."
- Focus on Sensory Input. When the past starts feeling more real than the present, use the 5-4-3-2-1 technique. Find five things you can see, four you can touch, three you can hear, two you can smell, and one you can taste. It forces your brain to re-engage with the "now."
The past is a great place to visit for lessons, but it’s a terrible place to live. Thinking in the past tense keeps you tethered to a version of reality that doesn't exist anymore.
Start looking at your past like a rearview mirror in a car. It’s useful to glance at it so you don't get hit, but if you stare at it while you’re driving forward, you’re definitely going to crash. Focus on the windshield instead. There's a lot more to see out there.
Final Practical Insight
Next time you catch yourself spiraling, ask: "Is this thought helping me solve a problem right now?" If the answer is no, acknowledge the thought, label it as "past-tense thinking," and consciously choose one task—no matter how small—to complete in the next five minutes. Redirect that energy into something tangible.