You know that feeling when you step off the 1 train at 72nd Street and the air just... changes? It’s quieter. Leafier. There’s this specific "old New York" energy that hits you, a mix of expensive strollers and people who have lived in the same rent-controlled apartment since 1974. Most people think the list of things to do in the Upper West Side starts and ends with a quick walk through the American Museum of Natural History or a bagel from Zabar’s. Honestly? They’re barely scratching the surface of what makes this neighborhood actually tick.
I’ve spent years wandering these blocks. The UWS isn't just a museum district; it’s a living, breathing village tucked between two of the best parks in the world. If you’re just hitting the TripAdvisor highlights, you’re missing the jazz basements, the secret community gardens, and the best smoked fish that’s ever graced a piece of rye bread.
The Museum Scene Is Great, But You're Doing It Wrong
Look, the American Museum of Natural History is a titan. It’s 2.5 million square feet of "holy crap, that’s a big dinosaur." But the mistake everyone makes is trying to see the whole thing in one afternoon. You can't. You’ll just end up with "museum leg" and a headache.
Instead of fighting the crowds at the T. Rex, head straight for the Gilder Center. It opened fairly recently (2023) and the architecture looks like a prehistoric cave carved out of canyon walls. It’s stunning. While everyone else is staring at the big whale, you should be in the Davis Family Butterfly Vivarium. It’s humid, it’s surreal, and if you wear bright colors, a butterfly might actually land on your nose.
Then there’s the New-York Historical Society right across the street. People walk past it all the time to get to the dinosaurs, which is a tragedy. This is the oldest museum in the city. They have this massive collection of Tiffany Lamps that glows in a dark room like a psychedelic forest. It’s quiet. It’s meditative. It’s the perfect palate cleanser after the chaos of Central Park.
Beyond the Big Names
If you want something weirder, check out the Nicholas Roerich Museum on 107th Street. It’s inside a quiet townhouse and dedicated entirely to the works of a Russian painter who was obsessed with the Himalayas. It’s free. It’s haunting. It feels like you’ve stumbled into someone’s private sanctuary rather than a public institution.
Central Park vs. Riverside Park: The Great Debate
When people look for things to do in the Upper West Side, they naturally gravitate toward Central Park. I get it. Strawberry Fields is iconic, and the Sheep Meadow is the city's backyard. But if you want to see how actual Upper West Siders live, you go west.
💡 You might also like: Why Every Map of Trans Siberian Railway is Kinda Wrong (And What You Need to Know Instead)
Riverside Park is the locals' secret. It was designed by Frederick Law Olmsted too, but it’s tiered, rugged, and runs right along the Hudson River.
- Walk down to the 79th Street Boat Basin.
- Find the Joan of Arc Memorial.
- Check out the "Eleanor Roosevelt" statue at 72nd Street where people leave flowers in her hand.
There’s a stretch of Riverside Park between 100th and 110th Street that feels like a forest. You forget the city exists. In the summer, the Pier i Cafe at 70th Street is the best place to grab a beer and watch the sunset over New Jersey. Is New Jersey pretty? From here, yeah, kinda.
Where to Eat Without Looking Like a Tourist
If you wait in the hour-long line at Levain Bakery on 74th Street, you’ve succumbed to the hype. Don’t get me wrong, the cookies are massive and gooey, but you can get the exact same cookie at their 77th Street location or the one up on 117th with half the wait.
The real soul of the neighborhood is Zabar’s. It’s not a grocery store; it’s a contact sport. You’ll get pushed by an octogenarian in a Chanel suit while reaching for the lox, and that’s part of the charm. Go to the cafe next door for a "Zabar’s Blend" coffee and a bagel with schmear. It’s cheap, it’s fast, and it’s authentic.
For a real sit-down meal, Barney Greengrass is the "Sturgeon King." It hasn't changed its decor since 1908. Seriously. The wallpaper is peeling, the waiters are grumpy, and the Nova Scotia salmon is legendary. Anthony Bourdain used to rave about this place. If it was good enough for him, it’s good enough for your Saturday brunch.
The New Classics
- Jacob’s Pickles: Always loud, always crowded, always worth it for the biscuit sandwiches.
- Sala Thai: Excellent, spicy, and tucked away on 71st.
- The Mermaid Inn: Their happy hour oysters are a neighborhood staple.
The Cultural Heart: Lincoln Center and Beyond
You don't need to spend $300 on an Opera ticket to enjoy Lincoln Center. In the summer, they do "Summer for the City" with outdoor dancing and silent discos. Even in the winter, just sitting by the Revson Fountain at night when the Metropolitan Opera House is lit up... it’s pure magic.
But if you want something grit-ier, go to Smoke Jazz & Supper Club up on 106th. It’s intimate. The acoustics are incredible. You’re three feet away from world-class musicians. It feels like the New York you see in the movies—dark, moody, and sophisticated.
Shopping That Isn't a Mall
Skip the shops at Columbus Circle. They’re fine, but they’re the same stores you find in suburban Dallas. Instead, walk up Columbus Avenue between 68th and 86th.
Westsider Rare & Used Books is a dream for bibliophiles. It’s cramped. Books are piled to the ceiling. It smells like old paper and history. You could spend three hours in there and only see one corner of the shop.
Then there’s Grand Bazaar NYC on Sundays. It’s the city's oldest and largest curated weekly market. It’s held in a school parking lot at 77th and Columbus. You can find vintage watches, handmade jewelry, and antique furniture. Plus, the money goes to supporting the local public schools. Shopping for a cause? Easy sell.
Hidden Gems Most People Miss
Have you ever heard of the Pomander Walk? Most people haven't. It’s a tiny, private street between 94th and 95th that looks like an English village. You can’t walk through it (it’s gated), but you can peek through the fence. It’s a bizarre architectural anomaly in the middle of Manhattan’s grid.
Another one: The Cathedral of St. John the Divine. Technically, it’s in Morningside Heights, but most locals count it as the northern tip of the UWS. It’s one of the largest Christian churches in the world. They have "Vertical Tours" where you can climb to the roof and see the city. Also, keep an eye out for the resident peacocks that roam the grounds. Yes, actual peacocks.
The Best Way to Spend 24 Hours on the Upper West Side
If I were planning your day, we’d start early.
- 8:00 AM: Coffee at Daily Provisions. Get the cruller. Trust me.
- 9:30 AM: Walk through Central Park to the Shakespeare Garden. It’s designed to look like the English countryside and features plants mentioned in Shakespeare’s plays.
- 11:30 AM: Head to the Beacon Theatre. Even if you aren't seeing a show, the lobby is a masterpiece of Art Deco design.
- 1:00 PM: Lunch at Viand Cafe. It's a classic diner. Get the turkey—they roast it fresh every day.
- 3:00 PM: Explore the Museum of Natural History, but specifically the Hall of Gems and Minerals. It was recently renovated and looks like a jewelry box.
- 6:00 PM: Drinks at The Dead Poet. It’s a narrow pub where every drink is named after a famous author.
- 8:00 PM: Dinner at Red Farm for some of the most creative dim sum in the city (the Pac-Man shrimp dumplings are a must).
Practical Realities of the UWS
It's expensive. Let's not sugarcoat it. But a lot of the best things to do in the Upper West Side are actually free or very cheap. Walking the parks costs nothing. Browsing Zabar’s is free (until you smell the babka). Many museums have "pay what you wish" hours for locals or specific discount days.
The subway is your friend here. The 1, 2, and 3 trains run up Broadway, and the A, B, and C run up Central Park West. If you’re trying to get from one side of the neighborhood to the other, take the M79 or M86 crosstown buses. Walking across the park is beautiful until you realize it’s 20 minutes of uphill trekking.
Is it Safe?
Generally, yes. It’s one of the safest residential areas in Manhattan. You’ll see people walking dogs and jogging well past midnight. Like any city, stay aware, but the UWS is famously family-friendly and relaxed.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
- Download the Central Park App: It’s surprisingly easy to get lost in the Ramble. The app uses GPS to show you exactly which winding path you’re on.
- Book Jacob’s Pickles in Advance: If you show up at 7 PM on a Friday without a reservation, you’re looking at a two-hour wait. Use Resy.
- Check the Beacon Theatre Calendar: Sometimes big names like Jerry Seinfeld or Bob Dylan do residency runs here. You might get lucky.
- Wear Comfortable Shoes: You’ll easily clock 20,000 steps. The sidewalks are old and sometimes uneven, so leave the heels at home.
- Visit Zabar’s Late: If you want to avoid the heaviest crowds, go on a Tuesday or Wednesday evening. Avoid Sunday mornings unless you enjoy being elbowed by hungry New Yorkers.
The Upper West Side isn't about checking boxes off a tourist list. It’s about the "vibe." It’s about grabbing a bagel, sitting on a green bench in the park, and watching the world go by. It’s a neighborhood that rewards the slow traveler. Take your time. Look up at the gargoyles on the pre-war buildings. That’s where the real New York lives.