Most people only know Hackettstown as the place that smells like chocolate when the wind hits the Mars Wrigley factory just right. If you’ve ever been stuck at the light on Mountain Avenue and caught a whiff of artificial nougat, you know exactly what I mean. But honestly, if you just drive through and keep going toward the Poconos, you’re missing the actual soul of the Skyland Region.
It isn’t a cookie-cutter suburb. It’s got this weird, gritty-but-charming Victorian vibe mixed with a serious craft beer obsession.
📖 Related: The Temperature at Myrtle Beach: Why Most People Get It Wrong
The Brewery Crawl You Didn’t Know You Needed
There are three—yes, three—distinct breweries within walking distance of each other in the downtown area. It’s kinda wild for a town this size.
You’ve got Czig Meister Brewing Company over on Valentine St. It’s in this massive, airy old carriage house. They do these incredibly complex stouts and IPAs, but the vibe is totally unpretentious. You’ll see people there with their dogs, just chilling at the long wooden tables.
Then there’s Man Skirt Brewing. Pete, the owner, is almost always there, and yes, he’s usually wearing a skirt (it’s a brand thing, but also just a "him" thing). Their Better Than British ESB is basically a local legend at this point.
If you want something a bit more tucked away, Jersey Girl Brewing is right on the edge of town. They have a massive taproom and usually a food truck parked outside. It’s the kind of place where you end up talking to a stranger about hiking trails for forty-five minutes.
💡 You might also like: Why the Walmart Museum in Bentonville Actually Matters for the Future of Retail
Eating Your Way Down Main Street
Forget the chain restaurants for a second. If you’re looking for things to do in Hackettstown NJ that involve actually tasting the local culture, you have to hit Marley’s Gotham Grill. They claim to have 300 wing flavors. I haven't counted, but the menu is basically a novella. Try the "Embalming Fluid" wings if you’re feeling brave, but don't say I didn't warn you about the heat.
For something a bit more "I want to feel like a sophisticated adult," James on Main is the spot. It’s Wood-Fired New American. It’s small. It’s intimate. The menu changes based on what’s actually growing in the Garden State at that moment. You definitely need a reservation here unless you enjoy standing on the sidewalk looking hopeful.
Quick bites and local staples:
- Stella G’s: The go-to for breakfast. Their lemon ricotta pancakes are life-changing.
- Pandan Room: Incredible Thai and Indonesian food. It’s BYOB, so grab a six-pack from one of the breweries first.
- Mama’s Cafe Baci: It looks like a standard Italian joint from the outside, but they have one of the most extensive gluten-free and vegan menus in Northern Jersey.
Getting Outside (Without Driving to Pennsylvania)
Stephens State Park is literally right there. The Musconetcong River runs through it, and it's one of the best trout fishing spots in the state. Even if you don't fish, the hiking trails are solid. They aren't "climb a mountain and see three states" difficult, but they’re perfect for a Saturday morning when you just need to see some green.
Keep an eye out for the remains of the Morris Canal. You can still see the old lock remnants at Saxton Falls. It’s a bit eerie and cool to think about how this was the high-tech shipping lane of the 1800s.
If you’re into "organized" nature, Donaldson Farms is just up the road. In the summer, the sunflower fields are a magnet for every Instagram influencer in a fifty-mile radius, but the corn maze in the fall is legit. They also do "Friday Nights on the Farm" with live music and hayrides, which is surprisingly fun even if you don't have kids.
Culture and the "M&M" Factor
Centenary University sits right in the middle of town, and it gives the place a bit of a "college town lite" feel. The Centenary Stage Company is actually a professional theater group. They put on equity shows that are way better than you’d expect for a small-town theater.
👉 See also: How Long Is the New York to London Flight? What Nobody Tells You About the Actual Time
And look, we have to talk about the history. The Hackettstown Historical Society museum on Church Street is only open a few days a week (usually Wednesday and Sunday afternoons), but it’s worth the twenty-minute stop. You’ll learn about the "Hackettstown Ghost" and the town's industrial roots.
Basically, Hackettstown is the antithesis of a strip mall. It’s a place where people actually walk the streets, the shop owners know your name, and you can spend a whole day just wandering without ever needing to check your GPS.
Things to keep in mind for your visit:
- Parking: Main Street can be a pain. There are public lots behind the shops on both sides—use them.
- The Train: The NJ Transit Morris & Essex line ends here. You can literally take a train from NYC and walk to all the breweries.
- Events: Keep an eye out for the Oktoberfest and the St. Patrick's Day Parade. This town takes parades very, very seriously.
- Farm Markets: If it's growing season, stop at a roadside stand. The sweet corn in this part of Warren County is unbeatable.
If you’re planning a trip, start by checking the Centenary Stage Company’s performance schedule for the weekend. Grab a late breakfast at Stella G’s, spend the afternoon hiking the Waterloo South trail at Stephens State Park, and finish with a flight of beer at Czig Meister before dinner at the Pandan Room.