It stood there for years. A giant, multicolored box of mismatched panels staring at drivers on the New Jersey Turnpike. People called it a "Lego set gone wrong." Some called it an eyesore that defined a decade of bad planning. Most knew it as the Xanadu project New Jersey, a massive gamble on the future of retail that almost didn't make it. Honestly, if you lived in North Jersey between 2004 and 2019, that building was basically a monument to stalled dreams and corporate bankruptcy. It was weird. It was bright. And it was empty.
The story isn't just about a mall. It’s about the death of the "megamall" concept and its strange, expensive resurrection.
What Was the Xanadu Project New Jersey Supposed to Be?
The original vision for the Xanadu project New Jersey was actually pretty wild. It wasn't just going to be a place to buy jeans. The Mills Corporation, the original developers, wanted an "entertainment destination." We're talking about an indoor ski slope—in the middle of the Jersey swamplands—an indoor skydiving tunnel, a massive Ferris wheel, and a movie theater that would make everything else in the Meadowlands look tiny.
It was ambitious. Maybe too ambitious.
The site sat right next to MetLife Stadium, formerly Giants Stadium, making it prime real estate. But the timing was terrible. Construction started, stopped, and started again. Then the money ran out. Then the lead developer changed. Then the Great Recession hit in 2008, and the whole thing turned into a ghost town. For a long time, the only thing the Xanadu project New Jersey produced was a lot of punchlines on local news.
✨ Don't miss: Getting a Mortgage on a 300k Home Without Overpaying
The Problem With the "Lego" Aesthetic
You can't talk about Xanadu without talking about those panels. The exterior was a mosaic of orange, teal, and blue. It was supposed to look modern and vibrant. Instead, it looked like a shipping container graveyard. Former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie famously called it "the ugliest building in New Jersey, and maybe America." He wasn't exaggerating by much. The visual failure of the building became a symbol of the project's internal dysfunction.
Why the Xanadu Project Kept Failing
Money is the obvious answer, but the reality is more nuanced. The retail landscape was shifting. People started buying everything on Amazon. The idea of driving to a giant complex just to shop felt... old.
- The Credit Crunch: When the 2008 financial crisis hit, the original lenders, including Lehman Brothers (yes, that Lehman Brothers), collapsed. Funding for a multi-billion dollar mall dried up overnight.
- The Blue Laws: Bergen County has some of the strictest Sunday closing laws in the country. You can't sell "blue law" items like clothes or electronics on Sundays. For a massive retail hub, losing 52 of the most profitable shopping days of the year is a death sentence.
- The Design Flaws: The layout was confusing. The "entertainment" portions weren't integrated well with the retail sections. It felt like a maze designed by someone who had never actually walked through a mall.
By 2011, the project was basically a corpse. That's when Triple Five Group stepped in. These are the folks behind the Mall of America in Minnesota and West Edmonton Mall in Canada. They know how to do "big." They looked at the Xanadu project New Jersey and decided it didn't need to be a mall. It needed to be a theme park that happened to have stores.
The Transformation into American Dream
Triple Five didn't just finish the building; they gutted the concept. They rebranded it as "American Dream." They also, thankfully, started painting over those hideous orange panels with a sleek, clean white.
🔗 Read more: Class A Berkshire Hathaway Stock Price: Why $740,000 Is Only Half the Story
The transition from the Xanadu project New Jersey to American Dream involved billions in new investment. We aren't talking about a small renovation. They added a Nickelodeon Universe theme park, a DreamWorks Water Park, and Big SNOW—the first indoor ski resort in North America. They leaned into the "destination" aspect. If you can't beat the internet at selling socks, you beat the internet by offering a 122-foot drop on a roller coaster.
The Big SNOW Success Story
Surprisingly, the part people laughed at most during the Xanadu phase—the indoor skiing—became one of the most successful parts of the revamped project. Big SNOW uses 5,500 tons of real snow. It stays 28 degrees Fahrenheit year-round. It turns out, people in New Jersey really like skiing in July. It’s one of the few pieces of the original Xanadu DNA that actually worked when executed properly.
Is the Project Actually Successful Now?
It’s complicated.
If you walk into American Dream today, it’s stunning. It’s bright, high-end, and full of luxury brands like Hermès and Saks Fifth Avenue. But the debt is still there. Triple Five has struggled with massive loan payments, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic forced the complex to shut down just months after it finally opened its main attractions in late 2019.
💡 You might also like: Getting a music business degree online: What most people get wrong about the industry
The Xanadu project New Jersey legacy is one of survival. It survived three developers, two recessions, a global pandemic, and a decade of being the state's biggest joke. Today, it sees millions of visitors. Is it profitable? That’s a question for the accountants and the bondholders who are constantly renegotiating the terms. But is it a ghost town? Absolutely not.
What This Means for the Future of Retail
The evolution of the Xanadu project New Jersey tells us exactly where shopping is going. Pure retail is dying. If you want people to show up, you have to entertain them. You need "Instagrammable" moments. You need a 300-foot observation wheel. You need a candy store that spans three floors.
American Dream isn't a mall. It’s a physical manifestation of "the experience economy." It proves that while people don't need to go to a store to buy a pair of Nikes, they want to go to a place where they can ski, swim, and eat fancy ramen all in the same afternoon.
Real-World Takeaways for Your Next Visit
If you’re heading out to the site of the old Xanadu project, here is the ground truth:
- Plan for the Blue Laws: If you go on a Sunday, the theme parks and restaurants are open, but the retail stores are closed. Don't show up expecting to buy a new outfit on a Sunday afternoon.
- Parking is Not Free: Unlike almost every other mall in Jersey, you’re going to pay for parking here. It’s tiered, so check the rates before you go.
- The "Secret" Food Court: Most people stick to the main dining areas, but there are incredible, smaller food vendors tucked away near the ice rink that are often less crowded.
- Transportation Matters: Don't just drive. There are dedicated bus lines from Port Authority in NYC that drop you right at the door. It’s often faster than fighting Turnpike traffic.
The Xanadu project New Jersey didn't fail because the idea was bad; it failed because it was ahead of its time and behind on its budget. The transformation into American Dream shows that with enough capital and a complete shift in strategy, even the most hated building in the state can find a second life. It’s a weird, massive, snowy, loud, and shiny piece of Jersey history that you kind of have to see to believe.
To get the most out of a visit, check the MetLife Stadium schedule first. If there is a Giants game or a major concert, the traffic around the complex becomes a nightmare. Aim for a Tuesday or Wednesday morning if you want to experience the parks without the crushing crowds of the weekend. If you are a local, keep an eye on the New Jersey Transit schedules, as they occasionally run "American Dream" specials that include discounted park tickets.