You’ve seen the cover. It’s everywhere—airports, subways, and probably your mom’s bedside table. The Women by Kristin Hannah has become a bit of a juggernaut since it dropped in early 2024. But here’s the thing: it’s not just another piece of historical fiction to cry over. It’s actually making people really angry, really sad, and really defensive all at once.
Honestly, the book is a gut punch. It follows Frankie McGrath, a twenty-year-old nursing student from a wealthy, conservative family on Coronado Island. It’s 1966. Her brother Finley goes to Vietnam, and Frankie, fueled by a sudden realization that "women can be heroes too," decides to join the Army Nurse Corps. She thinks she’s going to save the world. Instead, she lands in a meat grinder.
What Most People Get Wrong About the History
The biggest misconception? That Kristin Hannah is just "making up" the drama. While Frankie is a fictional character, the sheer volume of research Hannah did is intense. She worked with Diane Carlson Evans, a former Army nurse and the founder of the Vietnam Women’s Memorial.
A lot of readers—especially those who didn't live through the era—are shocked by the scenes where Frankie returns home. There’s a specific, recurring line that haunts the book: "There were no women in Vietnam." Frankie hears it from her parents, from strangers, and even from the VA when she tries to get help for her PTSD.
💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Some critics argue about the accuracy of the "spitting" scenes. You know the ones—where protesters at the airport treat veterans like garbage. There’s a huge historical debate here. Some scholars, like Jerry Lembke, argue these stories are more "urban legend" than widespread reality. Yet, if you look at the comment sections of any review for The Women, you’ll find actual veterans saying, "No, that really happened to me." It’s a messy, open wound in American history that this book refuses to let scab over.
The Character of Frankie McGrath: Hero or "Too Much"?
Frankie is... a lot.
She starts off incredibly naive. Like, "I’m going to find my brother and we’ll have lunch in Saigon" naive. The first half of the book is a relentless, bloody education. She ends up at the 36th Evacuation Hospital in Vung Tau and later in Pleiku. We’re talking MASCALs (mass casualty incidents) where nurses are literally knee-deep in blood.
📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
Why the Romance Plot Divides Readers
If you’re looking for a clean romance, look elsewhere. Frankie’s love life is a train wreck. She falls for Jamie Callahan, a surgeon who is married (though separated, supposedly). Then there’s Rye Walsh, her brother’s best friend.
The Rye Walsh situation is what makes people want to throw the book across the room. Without spoiling too much for the three people who haven't read it: the betrayal is deep. Some readers feel Frankie is too "self-involved" or that the book leans too hard into soap opera territory in the second half. But honestly? If you’d spent two years stitching together nineteen-year-olds while mortars shook the OR, your judgment probably wouldn't be great either.
The Real Power of Barb and Ethel
The "The Women" in the title refers to more than just Frankie. Her two best friends, Barb and Ethel, are the actual backbone of the story.
👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
- Barb Johnson: A Black surgical nurse who has to deal with the war and the systemic racism of the 1960s.
- Ethel Flint: A tough-as-nails ER nurse from the Midwest.
Their friendship is the only thing that doesn't break. When Frankie spirals into addiction and depression back in California—basically "trauma dumping" on the reader for 200 pages—it’s Barb and Ethel who fly across the country to pull her out of the dark. It’s a pretty raw look at how combat trauma doesn't care if you carried a gun or a scalpel.
The Controversy You Won't See on the Blurb
There’s a growing conversation about how the book handles the Vietnamese perspective. Some critics, particularly from the Vietnamese-American community, have pointed out that the local people are mostly background noise or "victims to be saved." It’s a valid critique. The book is very much an American story about an American tragedy. It focuses on the moral injury of the U.S. government lying to its soldiers and the internal collapse of the "Camelot" myth.
Actionable Insights for Readers
If you're planning to pick up The Women by Kristin Hannah, or if you've just finished it and feel like you need a drink, here’s how to actually process it:
- Fact-Check the VA History: If you're shocked by Frankie being turned away for mental health care, look up the history of the Vietnam Women’s Memorial. It took until 1993 for women to get that recognition on the Mall in D.C.
- Look for the Nuance: Don't take the "protester vs. veteran" scenes as the only truth. Read memoirs like Home Before Morning by Lynda Van Devanter (which heavily influenced Hannah) to see the range of experiences.
- Check the "Last Best Place": The ending involves Frankie creating a sanctuary for women veterans. This is a recurring theme in Hannah's work—finding healing in female-led communities rather than traditional institutions.
- Prepare for the "Second Half Slump": Most people love the Vietnam section and find the "homefront" section exhausting. That’s intentional. It’s meant to mirror the exhaustion and "slow drowning" of PTSD.
The book isn't perfect. It's melodramatic, sometimes repetitive, and the male leads are mostly terrible. But it has forced a massive audience to acknowledge that 10,000 military women served in Vietnam, and most of them were told for forty years that they didn't exist. That alone makes it more than just a beach read.