Honestly, if you’re like me, you probably spent the better part of the first season of The Way Home yelling at your TV screen. Between the pond physics and the absolute heartbreak of the Landry family history, there was a lot to process. But when we hit the second season, things shifted. The scale got bigger. The stakes went from "fix my family" to "survive the 1800s."
The the way home cast season 2 didn't just return; they expanded into a version of Port Haven that felt both alien and deeply familiar. It wasn't just about the three generations of women anymore. It became a sprawling mystery involving ancestors, hidden agendas, and a version of Jacob we finally got to see in the flesh.
The Core Trio and the Emotional Heavy Lifting
The heart of the show is still the Landry women. You’ve got Chyler Leigh as Kat, Andie MacDowell as Del, and Sadie Laflamme-Snow as Alice. It’s a powerhouse group. But in season 2, their roles felt... heavier.
Kat spent most of her time soaking wet and stressed out. Chyler Leigh really leaned into the desperation of a woman who finally has a lead on her missing brother. It’s a lot of running through the woods and trying to convince people in 1814 that she isn’t a witch or a spy.
Then there's Del.
Andie MacDowell plays the "stoic farm owner" role so well, but this season we saw the cracks. She’s dealing with the potential loss of the farm, a new neighbor named Sam Bishop (played by Rob Stewart), and the ghost of her husband Colton constantly hovering over the property. Del’s journey is less about time travel and more about the brutal reality of aging and legacy. She's basically the anchor that keeps the show from floating off into pure sci-fi territory.
📖 Related: Donna Summer Endless Summer Greatest Hits: What Most People Get Wrong
Alice, played by Sadie Laflamme-Snow, had a tricky tightrope to walk this year. She’s no longer just the "new girl" in town. She’s a seasoned traveler now, but she’s also realizing that her presence in the past has consequences. Her friendship with teen Elliot (David Webster) gets messy, mostly because she knows how his life turns out. It’s kind of a "don't meet your heroes" situation, except the hero is your high school science teacher from twenty years in the future.
The Big Reveal: Who is Adult Jacob?
The question that haunted the entire first season was: where is Jacob?
We finally got the answer, and it brought a massive addition to the the way home cast season 2. Spencer MacPherson joined the crew as the adult Jacob Landry.
Imagine being an eight-year-old kid who falls into a pond and ends up in the early 19th century. Spencer plays Jacob with this incredible sense of "displaced soul." He’s a Landry, but he’s also a man of the 1800s. He has a life there. He has a family (not biological, but the people who raised him). Seeing him interact with Kat—who he remembers as his big sister but who is now essentially a stranger from another world—was easily the emotional peak of the season.
A lot of fans were worried that finding Jacob would "solve" the show. Instead, it just opened up a hundred new questions about the pond’s rules.
👉 See also: Do You Believe in Love: The Song That Almost Ended Huey Lewis and the News
New Faces in Old Times
Season 2 took us back to the 1800s, which meant a whole new ensemble of characters who had to feel authentic to the period without being caricatures.
- Thomas Coyle (Kris Holden-Ried): He’s the quintessential "rogue with a heart of gold" but with a darker edge. He’s a smuggler, he’s mysterious, and he has a complicated dynamic with Kat.
- Susanna Augustine (Watson Rose): This was a fascinating addition. Finding out that the Augustines have been "watchers" or helpers for the Landrys for centuries adds so much weight to Elliot’s burden in the present. Susanna is a healer, a scientist ahead of her time, and someone who actually understands Kat’s secret.
- Elijah Landry (Stuart Hughes): The patriarch of the 1814 Landrys. He’s the one who took Jacob in. Stuart Hughes brings a rugged, grounded authority to the role that makes you understand why Jacob stayed.
The Two Elliots Problem
We have to talk about Evan Williams and David Webster. Playing the same character at different ages is hard enough, but when that character is as neurotic and burdened as Elliot Augustine, it’s a massive task.
Evan Williams (Adult Elliot) spent much of season 2 in a state of existential crisis. He’s trying to reclaim his own life after spending years being the keeper of the Landry secrets. It’s a bit of a "nice guy" deconstruction. He’s tired of being the sidekick in someone else’s time-traveling adventure.
Meanwhile, David Webster (Teen Elliot) has to portray the version of the character that Alice is falling for—or at least, the version she feels closest to. The synchronicity between the two actors is uncanny. They’ve clearly spent time matching their mannerisms, especially that specific way Elliot looks like he’s overthinking everything he’s about to say.
Why the Season 2 Cast Works So Well
The magic of this ensemble is the lack of "villains." Sure, there are antagonists. There are people who make things difficult. But almost every character is driven by grief, love, or a desperate need for answers.
✨ Don't miss: Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Light Trail: Is the New York Botanical Garden Event Worth Your Money?
Take Al Mukadam as Brady, Kat's ex-husband. He could easily be the "annoying ex" who gets in the way. But he’s written with enough empathy that you see why he’s worried about his daughter hanging out at a creepy pond all day. Even the "frenemy" Monica Hill (Samora Smallwood) feels like a real person with a real history in Port Haven.
What to Look for Moving Forward
If you’ve finished the season, you know the cliffhangers are brutal. We’ve got new questions about Colton. We’ve got the Goodwin family mystery—shoutout to Vaughan Murrae as KC Goodwin, who added a great modern spark to the Herald office scenes this year.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Rewatch the 1814 Scenes: There are tons of visual cues in the background of Elijah’s house that hint at future plot points.
- Pay Attention to the Augustine Journal: The names mentioned in the past often pop up in the present-day Port Haven cemetery or town records.
- Check the Credits: Sometimes the "younger" versions of characters appear in the background of episodes before they are officially introduced.
The the way home cast season 2 didn't just tell a story about time travel; they told a story about how trauma ripples through generations. Whether they’re wearing 1800s wool or 90s flannels, these actors make you believe that a magic pond is the least interesting thing about the Landry family. It's the secrets they keep that really matter.