I remember watching those mid-2000s USC Trojans teams. They felt invincible. Matt Leinart, Reggie Bush, the Hollywood glitz—it was a factory of superstars. But the most insane story from that era didn't come from a five-star recruit or a future NFL Hall of Famer. It came from a kid who was literally just there to write a newspaper story.
If you haven't read Walk On by Ben Malcolmson, you’re missing out on one of the weirdest, most authentic sports stories ever told. Honestly, it’s not really a "sports book" in the traditional sense. It’s more of a bizarre social experiment that accidentally turned into a spiritual journey.
Ben was a student journalist. He was working for the Daily Trojan. He decided to do a "participatory" piece where he’d try out for the football team just to see how hard it was. He figured he'd get cut in the first hour, write about how scary the linebackers were, and go back to his keyboard.
Then Pete Carroll called his name.
The Reality of Making the Roster
People often think walk-ons are just guys who weren't quite good enough for a scholarship. At a powerhouse like USC in 2006, that wasn't the case. Most walk-ons were still All-State athletes who could have started at smaller Division I schools.
Ben Malcolmson? He hadn't played competitive football since the fifth grade.
When you read Walk On, you get this visceral sense of the physical toll. This isn't a Disney movie where there's a training montage and suddenly he's fast. He describes the absolute agony of "The Grind." He was a 160-pound kid getting hit by guys who would eventually be starting on Sundays in the NFL.
It was brutal.
But what makes the book actually work is the vulnerability. Ben doesn't pretend he was a secret prodigy. He was terrible. He was the "statue" in drills. Yet, Pete Carroll—who is a central figure in the book—saw something in the absurdity of the situation. Carroll's "Always Compete" philosophy wasn't just for the stars; it was for the guy at the very bottom of the depth chart who refused to quit even when his ribs were screaming.
Why Pete Carroll is the Antagonist and the Hero
Carroll is often portrayed as this high-energy, gum-chewing optimist. In Walk On, you see the complexity of that leadership. He’s the one who kept Ben on the team, but he's also the one who created an environment so competitive it bordered on Darwinian.
💡 You might also like: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
The book gives us a rare look at the 2006 Rose Bowl aftermath and the transition into the next season. It captures that specific USC culture: the celebrity visits, the Snoop Dogg appearances, and the sheer pressure of being #1.
Malcolmson writes about feeling like a ghost in the locker room. Imagine sitting next to future NFL stars while knowing you’re only there because of a journalism assignment that went off the rails. It’s awkward. It’s lonely. And then, it changes.
The Spiritual Pivot Most People Don't Expect
Here is where the Walk On book takes a turn that catches a lot of readers off guard. It’s not just about football. About halfway through, the narrative shifts heavily toward Malcolmson's faith.
He started a secret prayer group. He began leaving Bibles in lockers.
If you’re looking for a straight "X’s and O’s" football memoir, this might throw you. But if you want to understand the internal life of a team, it’s fascinating. He wasn't some loud, preachy guy. He was a guy struggling with his own purpose, wondering why on earth God—or fate, or Pete Carroll—had put a kid who couldn't tackle anyone on the best team in the country.
There’s a specific moment in the book involving a tragic event—the death of a teammate—that anchors the whole story. It strips away the glamor of the jerseys and the stadium lights. It forces the "walk-on" to become something of a chaplain or a shoulder to cry on for guys who seemed untouchable.
Breaking Down the Misconceptions
Some critics say the book is too focused on the religious aspect. Others think it leans too hard on the "miracle" narrative.
The truth? It’s a messier story than that.
- It wasn't a PR stunt. Some people at the time thought USC was just looking for a good story. Reading Ben’s account of the physical injuries and the mental isolation makes it clear: nobody would put themselves through that for a few headlines.
- He didn't "win" the game. Without spoiling the ending for those who haven't finished it, this isn't Rudy. He doesn't get the sack that wins the championship. His contribution is much quieter, and in many ways, more frustrating.
- The "Daily Trojan" article was just the beginning. The book covers years of aftermath, including Ben’s eventual career working directly with Pete Carroll in the NFL with the Seattle Seahawks.
The Seattle Connection
You can't really talk about the Walk On book without mentioning what happened next. Ben didn't just walk off the field and go back to being a reporter. He became Carroll’s right-hand man.
📖 Related: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
When Carroll moved to the Seahawks, Ben went with him.
This gives the book a layer of authority most sports memoirs lack. Ben wasn't just a visitor; he became an insider. He saw how the culture he experienced as a "scrub" at USC was exported to the professional level. He saw the "Always Compete" mantra lead to a Super Bowl ring.
It’s a weirdly full-circle moment. The kid who tried out for a joke ended up being one of the most influential non-coaches in an NFL front office for over a decade.
What You Can Actually Learn from Ben’s Experience
Most people read this book because they like USC or they like Pete Carroll. But the actual value is in the "imposter syndrome" Ben describes.
We’ve all been the person in the room who feels like they don't belong.
Malcolmson’s writing style is pretty straightforward—no flowery prose, just "this is what happened and it sucked, and then it was amazing." He captures the humidity of the locker room and the smell of the grass. He captures the fear of looking stupid in front of 90,000 people.
How to Apply the "Walk On" Mentality Today
If you’re stuck in a career rut or feeling like you’re punching above your weight class, there are a few things this story hammers home.
First off, showing up is 90% of the battle. Ben wasn't the best athlete, but he was the one who didn't quit when the journalism assignment ended. He stayed. He kept getting hit. He kept showing up to meetings.
Secondly, your "purpose" in a group might not be what you think it is. Ben thought he was there to write. Then he thought he was there to play. It turns out, he was there to be a specific type of support system that the "alphas" on the team didn't even know they needed.
👉 See also: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
Actionable Takeaways for Readers
If you're diving into the Walk On book or looking to apply its themes, keep these points in mind:
Audit your "Tryouts": What are you avoiding because you’re afraid of looking like an amateur? Malcolmson’s entire life changed because he was willing to be the worst person on the field. Sometimes, being the "worst" in a room of giants is the fastest way to grow.
Look for the "Pete Carrolls" in your life: Find mentors who value effort over initial talent. Carroll didn't keep Ben because he was a great receiver; he kept him because he added something to the culture of competition.
Document the struggle: Ben was a journalist first. He kept notes. He observed. Even if you’re in the middle of a hard season, keep track of what you’re learning. It’s the only way to make sense of the "hits" later on.
Embrace the pivot: Don't get so caught up in your original goal (like writing a one-off article) that you miss the bigger opportunity (like becoming a key part of a championship organization).
The book is a quick read, but it stays with you. It’s a reminder that the stars we see on TV are part of a much larger, much more human ecosystem. Sometimes, the most important person on the team is the one who isn't even supposed to be there.
Go find a copy. Read it not as a football fan, but as someone who wants to know what happens when you actually say "yes" to a crazy idea. It’s worth the time.
Key Reference Points:
- Walk On: From the Press Box to the Roster by Ben Malcolmson with Pete De Vere (2018).
- The 2006 USC Trojans Football Season.
- The "Always Compete" philosophy of Pete Carroll.