June 10, 1912. It’s a date that basically froze a small Iowa town in time. If you walk down East 2nd Street in Villisca today, the white frame house at the end of the block looks almost aggressively normal. It’s got that classic Midwestern porch, a sharp roofline, and a quiet yard. But inside those walls, six children and two adults were bludgeoned to death while they slept. Nobody was ever convicted.
The Villisca axe murder house isn't just a haunt for ghost hunters or a stop on a macabre road trip. It’s a cold case that refuses to stay cold. People flock there because they want to feel something—chills, dread, maybe a connection to a past that feels impossibly violent for such a sleepy place. Honestly, most of the "facts" you hear on paranormal TV shows are slightly skewed. To really understand why this house still matters, you have to look at the mess of the original investigation and the sheer brutality that the Moore family and the Stillinger girls faced.
The Night Everything Changed in Villisca
Josiah Moore was a successful businessman. He was doing well, maybe too well, which created some friction with other local power players. On that Sunday night, Josiah and his wife, Sarah, took their four kids—Herman, Katherine, Boyd, and Paul—to a Children's Day service at the Presbyterian church. Two neighborhood friends, Lena and Ina Stillinger, came along and ended up staying the night at the Moore house.
They walked home in the dark. It was a short trip. They locked the doors.
Somewhere between midnight and 5:00 AM, someone picked up Josiah’s own axe from the backyard. The killer started in the parents' room. They used the blunt side of the axe, not the blade, which is a detail that still makes people's skin crawl. It wasn't a quick "slasher movie" death. It was methodical. After Josiah and Sarah were gone, the killer moved to the children's rooms.
The scene the next morning was beyond grizzly. A neighbor, Mary Peckham, noticed the house was eerily quiet. Usually, the Moores were up and moving early. When the brother of Josiah, Ross Moore, arrived and let himself in with a key, he found the first victims. He didn't stay long. He ran out yelling that something terrible had happened.
The tragedy wasn't just the loss of life; it was the immediate destruction of evidence. Villisca didn't have a professional forensic team. In 1912, "crime scene preservation" barely existed. Over 100 people allegedly traipsed through the house that morning, touching things, peering at the bodies, and inadvertently wiping away any chance of finding a fingerprint or a stray hair that could have solved the case.
Why the Villisca Axe Murder House Case Went Cold
The investigation was a disaster. It’s that simple.
Frank Jones is the name that usually comes up first when locals talk about suspects. He was an Iowa State Senator and a powerful man. He and Josiah Moore had a major falling out over a business deal involving farm equipment. The theory? Jones hired a hitman named William "Blackie" Mansfield to do the job. Detective James Newton Wilkerson spent years trying to prove this. He was obsessed. He even dug up Mansfield’s past, finding that his wife and child had been murdered in a similar fashion. But there was a problem. Mansfield had a solid alibi. He was allegedly working in Illinois when the Villisca murders happened.
Then there’s Reverend George Kelly.
Kelly was a traveling preacher who had been at the church service that night. He left town early the next morning. He was a "disturbed" individual, to put it lightly. He actually confessed to the murders in 1917, claiming God told him to "slay the Philistines." He was tried twice. The first ended in a hung jury, and the second ended in an acquittal. He later recanted the confession, saying it was coerced by police.
It’s frustrating. You have a powerful politician with a motive on one side and a mentally unstable preacher on the other. Neither stuck.
The Strange Details No One Can Explain
- The Curtains: The killer covered all the mirrors and windows with clothes and cloths belonging to the Moores.
- The Slab of Bacon: A two-pound piece of bacon was found wrapped in a towel near the axe in the downstairs bedroom. No one knows why.
- The Water: A bowl of bloody water was found on the kitchen table, suggesting the killer washed their hands before leaving.
- The Attic: Evidence suggested someone had been waiting in the attic for the family to get home, potentially for hours.
Visiting the House Today: What to Expect
If you’re planning to visit the Villisca axe murder house, you need to leave the "Hollywood horror" expectations at the door. It’s a somber place. Martha Linn bought the house in 1994 and restored it to its 1912 condition. There’s no electricity. There’s no running water.
When you do a daylight tour, you see the cramped quarters. You see the steep stairs. It makes the crime feel much more intimate and claustrophobic. You realize the killer had to pass through one room to get to another. They were inches away from their victims while they were still alive.
Day tours are fairly standard. You hear the history, you see the rooms, you leave. But the overnight stays? That’s where the legends grow. People report hearing children’s voices, seeing doors move, or feeling a heavy weight on their chest. Whether you believe in ghosts or just the power of suggestion in a dark, creepy house, the psychological impact of being in that space at 3:00 AM is undeniable.
The Ethics of True Crime Tourism
There’s always a debate about whether places like this should even be open. Is it disrespectful to the Moores and the Stillingers? Some think so. Others argue that keeping the house standing is the only way to ensure the victims aren't forgotten. Without the museum, the house would have likely been torn down decades ago, and the story would have faded into a footnote in a dusty ledger.
The current owners and the community generally try to maintain a level of respect. It’s not a "haunted house" attraction with jump scares and actors in masks. It’s a historic site. If you go, the best approach is one of quiet observation. You’re stepping into the site of a tragedy that destroyed a family and scarred a town for over a century.
📖 Related: Cheap homemade gift basket ideas that actually look expensive
Fact-Checking the Folklore
Don't believe everything you see on YouTube.
One common myth is that the killer stayed in the house and ate a meal after the murders. While there was bread on the counter, there’s no concrete forensic evidence that the killer had a "feast." The bacon found in the room was likely ritualistic or related to some specific obsession of the killer, not a snack.
Another misconception is that the house is "evil." Locals will tell you that Villisca itself is a great place to live. The house is an anomaly, a dark spot on an otherwise clean record. The town isn't defined by the axe, even if the rest of the world only knows them for it.
Actionable Advice for Your Visit
- Book Way Ahead: If you want an overnight stay, you’re looking at a waiting list that can stretch for months, especially around October.
- Bring a Flashlight: The house is dark. Really dark. Even during the day, some corners stay in shadow.
- Respect the Neighbors: The house is in a residential neighborhood. People live next door. Don’t be that person screaming in the yard at midnight.
- Read the Trial Transcripts: Before you go, look up the 1917 trial of George Kelly. It provides a much clearer picture of the evidence than any ghost hunting show ever will.
- Check the Weather: Iowa winters are brutal, and the house isn't heated. If you go in December, dress like you’re going on a polar expedition.
The Villisca axe murder house remains one of the greatest unsolved mysteries in American history. It’s a puzzle with pieces that don't quite fit, no matter how hard you press them together. Whether the killer was a hired hand, a wandering preacher, or someone the town never even suspected, the result remains a haunting reminder of how quickly a peaceful life can be shattered.
If you're looking for more details on the legal side of the case, the Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs holds significant records on the Moore family and the subsequent investigations. Digging into the primary sources is the only way to separate the history from the hype.
To get the most out of a trip to Villisca, start by visiting the local cemetery first. Seeing the names on the headstones—especially the children—puts the gravity of the house in perspective before you ever step foot on the porch. Afterward, head to the Montgomery County Historical Society to see artifacts from the era that provide context for what life was actually like in 1912. This approach turns a "spooky" visit into a meaningful historical exploration.