Bethesda Game Studios has a weird obsession with your morality. For decades, they’ve built these massive digital playgrounds—from the irradiated ruins of D.C. to the sterile reaches of the Settled Systems—where the player is basically a god in training. You get to decide if you’re the savior of the wasteland or the monster under the bed. It’s the Villain and Saint Bethesda dichotomy. Most RPGs give you a binary choice, but Bethesda tries to make those choices feel lived-in, even when the mechanics get a bit janky.
Honestly, we’ve all been there. You start a new Fallout 3 save intending to be the ultimate Boy Scout. You’re going to find your dad, fix the water, and be a literal saint. Then you hit Megaton. You see that unexploded nuke sitting in the mud. Suddenly, the caps offered by Mr. Burke look a lot more enticing than some "good karma" points.
That’s the core of the experience. It isn't just about being good or bad; it's about how the world reacts to your specific brand of chaos.
The Karma System: Where the Saint and Villain Began
Back in the Fallout 3 days, Bethesda used a rigid Karma system. It was simple. Steal a spoon? Negative karma. Save a captive from Super Mutants? Positive karma. It felt like a cosmic scoreboard was watching your every move. This was the peak of the Villain and Saint Bethesda era because the consequences were tangible. If you were too much of a saint, Talon Company mercenaries would hunt you down just to balance the scales. If you were a total villain, the Regulators would show up to collect the bounty on your head.
It was binary, sure, but it gave the world a moral weight that many modern games lack. You couldn't just play both sides forever.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Rusty Cryptic Vessel in Lies of P and Why You Actually Need It
In Fallout: New Vegas (which, yeah, was Obsidian, but it used Bethesda’s engine and framework), they iterated on this with Reputation. It wasn't just "are you a good person?" anymore. It was "do the people in this specific town think you're a jerk?" This added nuance. You could be a saint to the NCR and a terrifying villain to the Legion. This shift moved the needle away from a global "Saint" status toward a more complex, political reality. Bethesda took notes on this, even if they didn't always implement it perfectly in later titles.
Why We Love Being the Bad Guy (And Why It’s Hard)
Being a villain in a Bethesda game is actually kind of exhausting. Think about the Dark Brotherhood in Skyrim. You aren't just a "bad guy"—you're a professional assassin serving a void-god and a mummified corpse. It’s dark. It’s gritty. And for many players, it’s the best content in the game.
Why? Because Bethesda writes villains with more flair than they write saints.
Being a saint is often the "default" path. You follow the quest markers, you help the NPCs, and you get the standard reward. But choosing the villainous path—like joining the Crimson Fleet in Starfield or becoming a Raider Overboss in Fallout 4’s Nuka-World—usually requires a conscious rejection of the game’s primary narrative. You have to decide to be a problem.
🔗 Read more: Finding every Hollow Knight mask shard without losing your mind
In Nuka-World, Bethesda actually received a lot of criticism because players felt forced into being a villain to enjoy the DLC. If you wanted to be a saint, your only real option was to kill all the quest-givers in "Open Season" and turn the park into a ghost town. It was a rare moment where the Villain and Saint Bethesda balance tipped too far in one direction, leaving "good" players with nothing to do.
The Evolution of Choice in Starfield
Then came Starfield. Bethesda moved away from the explicit "Karma" meter. There is no bar in your menu telling you if you’re a saint or a sinner. Instead, the morality is reflected through your companions. Sarah Morgan and Sam Coe are the ultimate moral compasses. If you do something remotely villainous, they will let you know. Immediately. "Sarah Morgan disliked that" has become a meme for a reason.
This is a more "human" way of handling the Villain and Saint Bethesda dynamic, but it’s polarizing. Some players miss the old Karma points. They want the game to acknowledge their evilness with more than just a stern talking-to from a companion.
- The Saint Path: Usually involves joining Constellation, being diplomatic, and siding with the UC SysDef.
- The Villain Path: Joining the Crimson Fleet, smuggling contraband, and choosing the "Amsel" option in various dialogue trees.
- The Grey Area: Ryujin Industries. This questline is arguably the most "Bethesda" thing in years. You aren't necessarily a saint or a villain; you’re a corporate tool. It’s about efficiency, not morality.
Real Talk: Does Being a Saint Even Pay Well?
Usually, no. In Skyrim, being a saint means you get a "Thank you" and maybe a leveled piece of enchanted armor that you’ll sell five minutes later. Being a villain means you get the Ebony Blade or the Mace of Molag Bal. Bethesda has a long-standing habit of giving the best loot to the worst people.
💡 You might also like: Animal Crossing for PC: Why It Doesn’t Exist and the Real Ways People Play Anyway
If you want the most powerful gear, you usually have to stain your soul a little bit. This creates a genuine conflict for the player. Is your digital morality worth more than a sword that absorbs the life force of your enemies? For most of us, the answer is "No, pass me the soul gems."
The Narratives We Forget
We often talk about the big choices, like whether to blow up Megaton or side with the Railroad. But the Villain and Saint Bethesda experience is found in the small stuff. It’s the decision to pickpocket a shopkeeper who was rude to you. It’s choosing to give a beggar a gold coin even though it does literally nothing for your stats.
In Fallout 4, the morality became tied to the factions. The Brotherhood of Steel thinks they're the saints, but to the Synths and the Railroad, they're the ultimate villains. This was Bethesda's attempt at "grey morality." While it didn't always land—mostly because the Institute's motivations were a bit muddy—it showed a desire to move past the simple Saint/Villain binary of the 2000s.
How to Master Your Next Playthrough
If you're looking to actually roleplay these extremes, you have to lean into the mechanics. Don't just play the game—play the character.
- Commit to the Bit: If you’re playing a villain, don't take the "nice" dialogue options just because they're easier. Use the "Intimidate" perk. Take the "Black Widow" or "Lady Killer" traits.
- Use Your Home Base: In Starfield, your ship reflects your morality. A saint's ship is clean, full of research stations. A villain's ship has shielded cargo holds for smuggling organ stimulants to Neon.
- Ignore the Main Quest: Often, the "Saint" narrative is baked into the main story. If you want to be a true villain, go off the beaten path. Find the weird cults, the pirate dens, and the shady back-alley deals.
Bethesda games are at their best when they let you fail. Not "Game Over" fail, but moral failure. When you realize you've accidentally become the villain of someone else's story because you wanted a specific achievement or a shiny new gun, that's when the game becomes real.
The Villain and Saint Bethesda dynamic isn't about a score at the end of the game. It’s about the stories you tell your friends later. It's about that time you tried to be a saint in Skyrim but ended up as the Listener of the Dark Brotherhood because the loot was just too good to pass up.
Actionable Next Steps for Players
- Audit Your Save: Look at your "General Stats" page in Fallout or Skyrim. Look at "Murders," "Thefts," and "Assaults." Does your character’s actual behavior match the "Saint" you think you are?
- The "No-Reload" Challenge: Next time you make a "villainous" mistake (like accidentally hitting a guard), don't reload your quicksave. Live with the consequences. Become the outlaw the game wants you to be.
- Flipped Playthrough: If you always play a Saint, start a new character today specifically to be a Villain. Choose the meanest dialogue options. It changes the entire tone of the game world in a way you probably haven't experienced yet.