Let’s be real for a second. If you grew up watching Ian Somerhalder smirk his way through eight seasons of supernatural drama, you probably think you know exactly what happens in Fell’s Church. Or Mystic Falls. Wait—that’s the first big shift.
In The Vampire Diaries novel series books, the setting isn't that cozy Virginia town from the CW. It’s a place called Fell’s Church, and the Elena Gilbert you meet on page one is... well, she’s kind of a brat. Honestly, she’s the "Queen Bee" of her high school, a blonde, popular, and slightly selfish girl who decides she wants the mysterious new guy, Stefan Salvatore, simply because he’s the only one who won’t look at her. It's a far cry from the compassionate, brown-haired girl-next-door portrayed by Nina Dobrev.
L.J. Smith started this whole thing back in 1991. That’s years before Twilight made vampires sparkle and decades before TikTok revived the "Team Stefan vs. Team Damon" debate.
Reading these books now is a trip. It’s 90s gothic horror mixed with high school melodrama. It's weird. It’s supernatural in a way that feels almost psychedelic at times. If you’ve only seen the show, you are missing out on some of the most bizarre and creative choices in young adult fantasy history. We’re talking about cosmic "Power," celestial kitsune, and Elena basically becoming a literal angel.
The Vampire Diaries Novel Series Books and the 1990s Origins
The first four books—The Awakening, The Struggle, The Fury, and Dark Reunion—form the core "original" quartet. L.J. Smith wrote these in a flurry of activity between 1991 and 1992. Then, silence. For nearly two decades, the series sat on shelves as a completed relic of 90s YA.
When the show was greenlit in 2009, the hype exploded. Smith returned to write The Return trilogy (Nightfall, Shadow Souls, and Midnight). But this is where things get messy behind the scenes. See, Alloy Entertainment, the packager that owned the rights to the series, eventually fired L.J. Smith from her own franchise. They wanted the books to align more with the TV show's trajectory. Smith wanted to take the story in a wild, experimental direction involving different dimensions and Elena's evolving divinity.
Because she was a "writer for hire," she lost the legal battle. Ghostwriters took over for the The Hunters and The Salvation trilogies. If you notice a sudden shift in tone, vocabulary, and character motivation after the book Midnight, that’s why. It’s one of the biggest "what ifs" in the publishing world.
🔗 Read more: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
What the TV Show Changed (And Why It Matters)
The differences aren't just cosmetic. They change the entire DNA of the story.
In the books, Bonnie McCullough isn't the stoic, powerful Bonnie Bennett. She’s a tiny, red-headed girl of Celtic descent who is much more of a "psychic" than a traditional witch early on. She’s flighty, terrified, and honestly, a bit of a comic relief character until things get dark. And Meredith Sulez? She doesn't even exist in the show’s early seasons, though she eventually inspired the character of Meredith Fell. In the novels, Meredith is the "cool-headed" one of the group, a tall, striking girl who hides a family secret about vampire hunting.
Then there’s the Stefan and Damon dynamic.
In The Vampire Diaries novel series books, the brothers are much older. They aren't from 1864 Virginia; they are from Renaissance Italy. They speak Italian. They have memories of the 15th century. This adds a layer of "Old World" gothicism that the show traded for Civil War-era angst.
The "Power" and the Bizarre Mythology
L.J. Smith didn't just write about vampires. She wrote about a concept called "The Power." It’s an actual energy source that supernatural beings can tap into.
As the series progresses, the threats get way more "out there" than anything the CW budget could handle. We eventually get to the Shinichi and Misao—malicious fox spirits (kitsune) from Japanese folklore who use "star balls" to control people and spread chaos. They literally destroy the town with giant, sentient plants.
💡 You might also like: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
It sounds crazy because it is.
Elena’s transformation is the most striking part. In the books, her death isn't just a transition to vampirism. She dies multiple times, eventually returning as an "Old One" or a spirit with wings. She has "wings of light" that can literally destroy demons. It turns the series from a vampire romance into a high-stakes battle between heaven and hell.
Why You Should Actually Read Them Today
You might think the 90s prose would feel dated. Parts of it do. The fashion descriptions are peak 1991. But the emotional core? It’s surprisingly raw.
Smith has a way of writing about obsession that feels dangerous. Damon Salvatore in the books is truly terrifying. He isn't the "misunderstood bad boy" who saves the day by the end of the episode; he is a predatory, manipulative, and genuinely dark presence who wants to break Elena's will. The tension between his "black velvet" darkness and Stefan’s "pure" light feels more like a fairy tale than a soap opera.
Also, the books handle the concept of "The Other Side" and the afterlife with a much more poetic touch. When characters die in the novels, the grief feels heavy. There’s a sense that the world of Fell’s Church is thin—that the barrier between the living and the dead is just a veil that anyone could accidentally trip through.
The Ghostwriting Controversy and the Fan Response
When the ghostwriters took over, the fan base split. The Hunters trilogy felt like an attempt to "fix" the weirdness Smith had introduced. It brought the story back to basics. But many "purists" felt it lacked the soul and the specific, flowery descriptions that Smith was known for.
📖 Related: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
If you want the "true" ending as the creator intended, you actually have to look for L.J. Smith’s fanfiction. After being fired, she started writing her own version of how the series should have ended, titled Evensong. It’s a rare case where the author’s "headcanon" is actually the original canon that was legally stripped away.
Navigating the Reading Order
If you’re looking to dive into The Vampire Diaries novel series books, don’t just grab a random copy. Follow the trilogies in order to keep your sanity:
- The Original Quartet: The Awakening, The Struggle, The Fury, Dark Reunion. (Read these first. They are the classics.)
- The Return Trilogy: Nightfall, Shadow Souls, Midnight. (This is where things get weird and experimental.)
- The Hunters Trilogy: Phantom, Moonsong, Destiny Rising. (The first set of ghostwritten books.)
- The Salvation Trilogy: Unseen, Unspoken, Unmasked. (The final arc.)
There are also the Stefan’s Diaries books. Be careful here—those are actually tie-ins to the TV show, not the original novel series. They follow the show's timeline and "Mystic Falls" lore. Don't mix them up or you'll be very confused about why Stefan is in the Civil War instead of the Italian Renaissance.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
If you're a fan of the show but have never cracked the spine of the books, start with The Awakening. Don't expect the TV version. Expect a darker, more atmospheric, and significantly more "supernatural" experience.
- Look for original 90s covers: The 1991 paperback covers have a specific aesthetic that fits the vibe of the story much better than the "TV tie-in" covers with the actors' faces.
- Compare the characters: Make a mental note of book-Elena’s "ice queen" personality versus show-Elena’s "martyr" complex. It makes her eventual growth (and fall) much more interesting.
- Check out L.J. Smith's website: She still interacts with fans and provides context on the "Evensong" project, which gives you the closure the official books might lack for some.
The legacy of these books isn't just that they spawned a hit show. They were a bridge between the classic horror of the 80s and the YA explosion of the 2000s. They proved that teenagers wanted stories that were bloody, romantic, and didn't talk down to them. Whether you love the "kitsune" madness or prefer the simple drama of a girl torn between two brothers, the novels offer a complexity that the television screen just couldn't capture.
The story of Elena, Stefan, and Damon didn't start in a writers' room in Burbank. It started in the mind of a woman who wanted to see what happened when a "perfect" girl met a perfect monster. And honestly? It’s still worth the read.