You’re digging through a box in your grandfather's garage. Your hands are covered in that specific kind of grey, sticky dust that only accumulates over decades. Then, you see it. A flash of thick, greenish glass. A script logo that looks almost like Coca-Cola but isn't. It’s Pepsi-Cola.
Most people just see trash. They see a vessel for a drink that's been flat since the Truman administration. But the value of old Pepsi cola bottles is a market that’s actually surprisingly volatile and, if you hit the right era, incredibly lucrative.
It’s not just about age. A bottle from 1950 might be worth five bucks, while a bottle from 1906 could pay for your next vacation. Collectors aren't just buying glass; they’re buying a piece of a corporate war that has lasted over a century.
The Early Days: Why the "S" Matters
Let’s get into the weeds. Caleb Bradham, a pharmacist from New Bern, North Carolina, created "Brad's Drink" in 1893. By 1898, it became Pepsi-Cola. If you find a bottle from this era, you’ve basically hit the jackpot.
Early Pepsi bottles didn't look like the modern ones. They were often "straight-side" bottles. No curves. No fancy ergonomics. Just thick glass, usually amber or clear.
One of the biggest tells for the value of old Pepsi cola bottles from the early 1900s is the logo style. Look at the word "Pepsi." Does the "P" have a long tail that loops under the rest of the word? Does the "C" in Cola do the same? This is what collectors call the "double dot" or the "long tail" script.
Actually, the "double dot" refers to the colon between the words Pepsi and Cola (Pepsi:Cola). These were used until 1951. If your bottle has two dots instead of one dash, you’re already looking at something with a baseline of collector interest.
The Hutchinson Top
The holy grail for many is the Hutchinson bottle. These were used in the very late 1800s and early 1900s. They have a specific wire stopper. If you find a Hutchinson Pepsi bottle, don't clean it with harsh chemicals. Seriously. You could ruin the patina or accidentally chip the glass, which tanks the price.
💡 You might also like: Dutch Bros Menu Food: What Most People Get Wrong About the Snacks
A Hutchinson Pepsi bottle in good condition can fetch thousands. We aren't talking "lunch money" thousands. We're talking "down payment on a car" thousands. They are rare because the design was flawed—the stoppers were hard to clean and could harbor bacteria, leading to their phase-out.
Color and Rarity: The Amber vs. Green Debate
Most people associate Pepsi with clear or light green glass. But the early stuff? Sometimes it's amber.
Amber glass was used to protect the syrup from light, which could alter the taste. Because Pepsi was a smaller player compared to the giant in Atlanta (Coke) during the early 20th century, their production runs were smaller. Smaller runs mean fewer surviving bottles.
- Amber Straight-Sides: These can range from $200 to over $1,000 depending on the bottling city.
- Clear Script Bottles: Common, but still worth $40–$100 if the glass is crisp.
- Light Green (Aqua): This is the classic look. Most mid-century bottles fall here.
Location is a weirdly huge factor. Pepsi was bottled by various local franchisees. A bottle embossed with "New Bern, N.C." is cool because that’s the birthplace. But a bottle from a tiny town in Kansas that only had a bottling plant for three years? That’s where the collectors start sweating. They want the "hometown" bottles that nobody else has.
The Great Depression and the 12-Ounce Revolution
In the 1930s, Pepsi did something gutsy. They started selling 12-ounce bottles for a nickel.
At the time, Coke was selling 6.5-ounce bottles for the same price. Pepsi’s jingle—“Twice as much for a nickel, too”—became a national sensation. This era gave us the "ACL" bottles.
ACL stands for Applied Color Label. Instead of the logo being embossed (raised) in the glass, it was "painted" on using a baked-on enamel. These are the bright red, white, and blue labels we recognize today.
📖 Related: Draft House Las Vegas: Why Locals Still Flock to This Old School Sports Bar
When determining the value of old Pepsi cola bottles with ACL labels, condition is everything. If the paint is flaking, the value drops by 80%. If the white is still "pop" bright and the red hasn't faded to a dull orange, you might have a $50 bill sitting on your shelf.
Spotting the Fakes and the "Fantasy" Bottles
You have to be careful. The market is flooded with "fantasy" bottles. These are items made to look old but never actually existed in the past.
Sometimes companies release "anniversary" editions. They look vintage. They have the old script. But if you look at the bottom, you’ll see a modern date code or a recycling symbol. Genuine pre-1950 bottles won't have a "Please Recycle" logo. Obviously.
Another tip: look for the "seam." Very old bottles were hand-blown into molds. The seam might stop at the shoulder or just below the rim. Modern, machine-made bottles have a seam that goes all the way over the top of the lip.
What’s It Actually Worth? Real Numbers
I know you want a price list. But it doesn't work like that. The market breathes.
- Common 1950s/60s Swirl Bottles: These are the ones with the spiral ribs. You see them at antique malls for $5 to $10. They are everywhere. Don't expect to retire on these.
- 1940s War-Era Bottles: These sometimes used different glass colors due to wartime shortages. A bottle with a "Buy War Bonds" slogan can hit $30 to $75.
- 1900-1910 Straight Sides: This is the "Gold Zone." $200 is a starting point. If it’s a rare color or rare city, $1,500+.
- Prototype or Error Bottles: Mistakes happen. Labels get printed upside down. Bottles get blown in weird shapes. These "freaks" are highly prized by niche collectors.
How to Sell Without Getting Ripped Off
If you think you have something special, don't go to a pawn shop. They’ll give you 10% of the value because they need to turn a profit and most of them don't know glass.
Go to an auction site and filter by "Sold" listings. Not "Asking" price. I can ask $10,000 for a half-eaten sandwich; it doesn't mean it’s worth that. Look at what people actually paid in the last 90 days.
👉 See also: Dr Dennis Gross C+ Collagen Brighten Firm Vitamin C Serum Explained (Simply)
Also, check out the Federation of Historical Bottle Collectors (FOHBC). These people are the real deal. They have shows, journals, and experts who can tell you if your bottle is a gem or a paperweight.
Actionable Steps for New Collectors
If you're looking to turn this into a hobby or a side hustle, here is how you actually start.
First, get a loupe or a good magnifying glass. You need to inspect the "pontil" mark on the bottom. A pontil mark is a scar where the glassblower’s rod was broken off. If you see that, you're holding something very old.
Second, learn the glass codes. Most bottle manufacturers (like Owens-Illinois) stamped the bottom with a series of numbers. Usually, there’s a date code. A "42" might mean 1942. Learning to read these codes is like having a cheat code for the value of old Pepsi cola bottles.
Third, watch the "case" value. Sometimes a single bottle isn't worth much, but a full wooden crate of 24 original bottles with the carrier? That's a "display piece." Interior designers buy those for way more than a solo collector would.
Lastly, check the "lip." Is it a "crown top" (the standard bottle cap we know) or a "blob top" (thick, rounded glass for a cork)? Blob tops are almost always older and more valuable.
Collecting isn't just about the money, though it's a nice perk. It’s about the fact that Pepsi survived the Depression, two World Wars, and the "New Coke" era. Every scratch on that glass tells a story of a delivery truck driver in 1944 or a kid in a soda shop in 1912. That's the real value.
To get started, clean your finds with warm water and mild dish soap only—never use a dishwasher, as the high heat and abrasive detergents can etch the glass or destroy an ACL label. Once clean, photograph the base, the logo, and the neck in natural light. This provides the documentation needed for any serious appraisal or online listing. Reach out to local bottle-collecting clubs or attend an antique glass show to get a feel for the physical weight and texture of authentic pieces versus modern reproductions.