It’s one of the most famous photos in American history. You know the one. Three firefighters—Thomas Eisland, George Johnson, and Dan McWilliams—straining to hoist a usa flag 9 11 was happening right in the middle of a literal hellscape. It was late afternoon on September 11, 2001. The North and South Towers had collapsed. The air was thick with pulverized concrete, asbestos, and the smell of jet fuel. People were looking for hope. They found it in a 3-by-5-foot piece of polyester.
But here is the thing that honestly trips people up: that flag disappeared.
It didn't just go into a museum right away. It vanished for over a decade. Most people assume the flag hanging in the National September 11 Memorial & Museum is the one they saw in the news that day, and technically, it is. But the journey it took to get there is weirder and more complicated than the history books usually let on. It involves a yacht, a mysterious man named "Brian," and a 14-year-long search.
The Flag That Wasn’t Actually From the Towers
We often talk about the "World Trade Center flag," but the usa flag 9 11 responders raised didn't actually belong to the Port Authority or the FDNY. It was stolen. Sorta.
Dan McWilliams saw the flagpole on a yacht called the Star of America. The boat was docked at North Cove on the Hudson River. It belonged to Shirley Dreifus and her late husband. McWilliams basically just grabbed it because the area was a graveyard of gray dust and he needed something—anything—to show that the site hadn't been defeated. He and his colleagues found a flagpole near the wreckage of WTC Building 7.
Thomas E. Franklin, a photographer for The Record, captured the moment. The photo went viral before "going viral" was even a term. It was on every front page. It was compared to the Iwo Jima flag-raising. It became a symbol of national resilience.
But then, things got messy.
By 2002, a flag was being flown at Yankee Stadium and during the Super Bowl. It was signed by Governor George Pataki and Mayors Rudolph Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg. Everyone thought this was the original flag. Except, when Shirley Dreifus went to look at it, she realized it wasn't her flag. The one being used in ceremonies was way too big. The original was 3 by 5 feet. The "official" one was 5 by 8 feet.
The real usa flag 9 11 was gone.
📖 Related: Trump New Gun Laws: What Most People Get Wrong
A Cold Case and a Mystery Man Named Brian
For years, the mystery of the missing flag was a niche obsession for historians and investigators. How do you lose the most important textile in modern American history? It basically became a cold case until 2014.
That’s when a guy walking into a fire station in Everett, Washington, changed everything.
He called himself "Brian." He had a plastic bag. Inside that bag was a flag. He claimed he had seen a show on the History Channel—Brad Meltzer's Lost History—which had an episode about the missing flag. Brian told the firefighters that he had been given the flag by an anonymous worker from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), who had purportedly been given it by a 9/11 widow.
It sounded like a tall tale. Honestly, the Everett police were skeptical.
Detectives Jim Massucco and Adam Scott didn't just take his word for it. They went full CSI. They looked at the dust. They looked at the hardware. They looked at the photos taken by Franklin on the day of the attacks.
How They Proved It Was Real
You can't just look at a flag and know. You need science. The Everett Police Department spent months on this. They didn't have a massive budget, but they had a weirdly specific set of clues.
- The Dust Analysis: Forensic scientists analyzed the particulates embedded in the fibers. They found a match for the specific "signature" of Ground Zero dust—a mix of concrete, glass fibers, and other materials unique to the collapse of the towers.
- The Hardware: This was the "smoking gun." The flag from the Star of America had very specific gold-toned clips. In the high-resolution photos from 9/11, you can see those exact clips.
- The Thread Count: Experts compared the stitching and the material to the manufacturing records of the brand of flag Shirley Dreifus had purchased.
After two years of investigation, they were sure. This was it. The mystery of the missing usa flag 9 11 was solved. Brian, the man who dropped it off, disappeared and has never been seen since. He didn't want a reward. He didn't want fame. He just wanted the flag back where it belonged.
Why We Care So Much About a Piece of Fabric
It’s just cloth. Right? Well, no.
👉 See also: Why Every Tornado Warning MN Now Live Alert Demands Your Immediate Attention
Symbols matter because humans are wired for narrative. On September 11, the narrative was one of total destruction. When those three men raised that flag, they were reframing the story. They weren't just clearing rubble; they were reclaiming territory.
There's a reason the usa flag 9 11 remains such a potent image. It represents the "boots on the ground" perspective. It wasn't a PR move choreographed by the government. It was three tired, grieving men acting on instinct.
The Cultural Impact
The image changed lives. Thomas E. Franklin, the photographer, found his life forever linked to that single second. The firefighters became reluctant celebrities. But more importantly, the flag became a tool for mourning.
- It provided a visual anchor for a country that felt like it was drifting.
- It honored the nearly 3,000 lives lost by asserting that the ground they died on was still "ours."
- It bridged the gap between the horror of the morning and the resolve of the afternoon.
Where the Flag Lives Now
If you want to see it, you have to go to Lower Manhattan.
The original flag was officially returned to New York in 2016. It was a somber ceremony. It now resides in the National September 11 Memorial & Museum. It’s encased in glass, protected from the elements, but still bearing the scars of that day.
It looks surprisingly small in person. That’s usually what people say when they see it. It’s not a giant garrison flag. It’s a boat flag. It’s modest. And maybe that's why it works. It represents the individual efforts—the small acts of courage—that defined the response to the attacks.
Common Misconceptions About the 9/11 Flag
People get the facts mixed up all the time. It’s been over two decades, so the "Mandela Effect" is real here.
One big myth is that the flag was recovered from the top of one of the towers. It wasn't. As mentioned, it came from a boat. Another is that it was destroyed in the collapse. Clearly, that’s false, though it was certainly damaged by the fallout.
✨ Don't miss: Brian Walshe Trial Date: What Really Happened with the Verdict
There is also the "Two Flags" confusion. Because a different, larger flag was used at the 2002 World Series and the Super Bowl, many people still believe that flag is the one from the photo. If you see a photo of a flag signed by politicians from that era, that is the "proxy" flag, not the original. The original was never signed; it was lost while the proxy was being paraded around.
How to Honor the Legacy Today
Understanding the history of the usa flag 9 11 is about more than just trivia. It’s about understanding the weight of national symbols. If you're looking for ways to engage with this history beyond just reading an article, there are a few concrete things you can do.
Visit the Memorial
There is no substitute for standing at Ground Zero. The museum is heavy—emotionally speaking—but seeing the flag in the context of the "slurry wall" and the remaining steel "tridents" from the towers is powerful. It puts the scale of the event into perspective.
Support the Foundations
The families of the victims and the first responders who are still getting sick from the dust need ongoing support.
- The Tuesday’s Children organization helps families affected by terrorism and military loss.
- The FealGood Foundation focuses specifically on 9/11 first responders and their health needs.
Preserve Your Own History
History isn't just about big flags and famous photos. It’s about your story too. Many libraries and local archives are still looking for personal accounts of how people experienced that day from afar. Writing down where you were and what you felt helps future generations understand that this wasn't just a movie or a textbook chapter—it was a lived reality.
The usa flag 9 11 isn't just a relic. It's a reminder that even in the middle of a disaster, humans will always look for a way to stand back up. It took fourteen years to find it, but the fact that people never stopped looking says everything you need to know about what it represents.
Next Steps for Readers:
- Check the Authenticity: If you own 9/11 memorabilia, research the provenance through the 9/11 Memorial & Museum’s digital archives to ensure you have accurate historical context.
- Watch the Documentary: Look for The Flag, a documentary that details the forensic search and the "Brian" mystery in much deeper detail.
- Plan a Visit: If you are in New York, the flag is located in the museum's foundation hall. It is best viewed during the morning hours when the museum is less crowded, allowing for a quieter moment of reflection.