The US Women’s Soccer Team: Why Winning Isn't as Easy as It Used to Be

It’s easy to look at the history of the US women’s soccer team and think they just show up and collect trophies. Four World Cups. Five Olympic gold medals. For decades, the narrative was basically "USA vs. the rest of the world," and the USA usually won. But if you’ve been watching lately—really watching—you know that the "gap" everyone talked about for years hasn't just closed. It’s been slammed shut.

The 2023 World Cup was a massive wake-up call. Honestly, it was a gut punch. Getting knocked out in the Round of 16 by Sweden wasn't just a bad day at the office; it was the earliest exit in the program's history. It felt like the end of an era because it was the end of an era. We saw the departure of legends like Megan Rapinoe and the transition of Alex Morgan into a different phase of her career.

What’s happening now is a complete identity shift. It’s messy. It’s exciting. And frankly, it's about time.

Emma Hayes and the New Blueprint

You can't talk about the current state of the US women’s soccer team without talking about Emma Hayes. Coming over from Chelsea, she didn't just bring a resume; she brought a philosophy that the US had been lacking for a while: tactical flexibility. For years, the US relied on being bigger, faster, and stronger. We out-athleted people. But when everyone else caught up in the gym, the US struggled to out-think them on the pitch.

Hayes is changing that. She’s not married to one specific formation. You might see a 4-3-3 that shifts into a 3-4-3 depending on where the wingbacks are positioned. It’s a lot more fluid than the rigid systems of the past.

Take the 2024 Olympics as an example. The world saw a front three of Sophia Smith, Trinity Rodman, and Mallory Swanson—the "Triple Espresso," as people started calling them. It wasn't just about their speed. It was about their chemistry. They weren't just running past defenders; they were playing off each other in tight spaces, something that previous iterations of the team struggled with against low-block defenses.

The Midfield Problem (And the Solution)

The midfield has been the biggest question mark. For a long time, the US women’s soccer team lacked a true "number 6" who could control the tempo like Spain’s Aitana Bonmatí or Keira Walsh. We had "destroyers"—players who could break up play—but we needed architects.

Enter Naomi Girma. Wait, she's a center-back? Exactly.

One of the most interesting tactical shifts is how much of the playmaking now starts from the back. Girma is arguably the best ball-distributing defender in the world right now. She doesn't just clear the ball; she finds gaps. Because the US has someone like Girma who can bypass the first line of pressure, the midfielders like Rose Lavelle or Lindsey Horan can stay higher up the field where they are actually dangerous.

💡 You might also like: Why Baseball Players of the 1920s Still Own the Record Books

Reality Check: The World Has Caught Up

Let’s be real for a second. The dominance of the 90s and 2010s happened because the US had a massive head start thanks to Title IX. While European clubs were still banning women from playing on their pitches, American girls were getting scholarships and professional-grade coaching.

That advantage is gone.

Look at the Women's Super League (WSL) in England or Liga F in Spain. These clubs are pumping millions into their academies. When a kid joins the Barcelona academy at 10 years old, she is learning the same tactical DNA as the men’s team. By the time she’s 18, her "soccer IQ" is often higher than an American player who spent those years playing high school and club ball where the focus is often on winning tournaments through sheer physical output.

This is why you see the US women’s soccer team struggling more against teams like Spain or even emerging powers like Colombia. It's not that the Americans got worse. It's that the rest of the world finally started trying.

The Youth Movement is Different This Time

In the past, a young player joined the national team and sat on the bench for three years behind a veteran. Not anymore. Look at Jaedyn Shaw. Or Korbin Albert. These players are being thrown into the fire early because the game is faster now. You can't wait until a player is 26 to see if they can handle international pressure.

The "old guard" mentality is being replaced by a "form-first" mentality. It doesn't matter if you have 150 caps; if a 19-year-old is outperforming you in training and fits the tactical profile Emma Hayes wants, the 19-year-old is going to play. This has created a healthy, if slightly cutthroat, environment that the team desperately needed to move past the complacency that arguably crept in after 2019.

Why the Equal Pay Win Changed Everything

It’s impossible to discuss the US women’s soccer team without mentioning the 2022 collective bargaining agreement. This wasn't just about money—though the $24 million settlement and equalized prize money were huge. It was about the psychological burden.

For years, these players were essentially working two jobs:

1. Being the best soccer players in the world.
2. Being the lead plaintiffs in a massive federal lawsuit against their own employer.

Think about the mental energy that takes. You’re at a World Cup, and instead of just watching film of your next opponent, you’re meeting with lawyers and doing interviews about gender discrimination. Since the settlement, there’s been a noticeable shift. The players can just be athletes. They have the same charter flights, the same support staff, and the same focus as the men. Ironically, this has put more pressure on them to perform, because the "distraction" excuse is officially off the table.

The "Triple Espresso" and the Future of the Attack

The most exciting part of the US women’s soccer team right now is the sheer unpredictability of the forwards.

• Sophia Smith: She’s a clinical finisher who can also play as a winger. Her ability to turn a defender in the box is world-class.
• Trinity Rodman: She brings a defensive work rate that is rare for a superstar forward. She tracks back, she wins tackles, and then she sprints 60 yards to provide an assist.
• Mallory Swanson: Her comeback from a devastating knee injury is nothing short of miraculous. She is the "glue" of the attack, often the one making the pass before the assist.

These three represent a shift away from the "target man" style of play. They are fluid. They swap positions constantly. It’s a nightmare for traditional center-backs who prefer to mark a static player.

How to Follow the Team Like an Expert

If you want to actually understand where the US women’s soccer team is headed, you have to look beyond the highlights. Soccer is a game of spaces, not just goals.

Watch the "Rest Defense"

Next time you watch a match, don't just follow the ball. Look at what the defenders are doing when the US is attacking. Under previous coaches, the US was often caught on the counter-attack because they committed too many players forward without a plan. Under Emma Hayes, you'll see a much more disciplined "rest defense." They are positioning themselves to stop the counter before it even starts.

Follow the Individual Club Journeys

The NWSL (National Women's Soccer League) is more competitive than ever, but more Americans are also looking at Europe. Watching how players like Lindsey Horan perform at Lyon gives you a window into how the US is integrating European tactical styles.

Ignore the "Downfall" Narrative

People love to say the US women’s soccer team is "finished" every time they lose a friendly. Ignore it. The team is in a rebuilding phase, and rebuilding takes friction. Losing a game because you're trying a new tactical system is better than winning a game using an outdated one that will fail you in a tournament.

Pay Attention to the Fullback Evolution

The role of the fullback (the outside defenders) is changing. Watch players like Jenna Nighswonger. They aren't just there to defend; they are essentially extra midfielders. Their ability to "invert" or move into the center of the pitch is the next step in the team's evolution.

The US women’s soccer team is no longer the undisputed heavyweight champion that wins by knockout in the first round. They are now a technical, evolving squad that has to fight for every inch. That might be scarier for fans, but it’s a lot more interesting to watch. The era of winning because of "who we are" is over. The era of winning because of "how we play" has begun.