The US Coat of Arms: What People Get Wrong About the Great Seal

The US Coat of Arms: What People Get Wrong About the Great Seal

You’ve seen it a thousand times. It’s on the back of your one-dollar bill, embossed on every passport, and hanging behind the President during every major televised address. Most people just call it the "eagle" or the "seal," but what we are actually looking at is the US coat of arms. Except, technically, the United States doesn't have a coat of arms in the traditional, European, "Lord Grantham of Sussex" kind of way. We have a Great Seal.

The distinction matters.

America was born out of a violent rejection of monarchy and hereditary titles. So, when the Founding Fathers sat down to design a visual identity for the new nation, they were in a bit of a bind. They needed the gravitas of a European power to be taken seriously on the global stage, but they hated the idea of "heraldry" because it smelled like kingly entitlement. It took them six years. Three separate committees. Dozens of rejected doodles. What they landed on wasn't just a cool bird; it was a carefully coded manifesto of what they hoped the country would become.

Why the US coat of arms isn't like a family crest

In England or France, a coat of arms belongs to a person. It’s a piece of property. If you’re the Duke of Marlborough, you own that specific shield. You pass it to your son. In the U.S., the "arms" belong to the office and the people. It’s a sovereign symbol.

Basically, the US coat of arms is the central part of the Great Seal. Specifically, it’s the eagle with the shield on its chest. If you look closely at the shield, you’ll notice something weird: there are no stars on it. This was a deliberate choice by Charles Thomson, the Secretary of the Continental Congress, who actually finalized the design in 1782. He took ideas from people like William Barton and Pierre Eugene du Simitiere—the latter being a guy who actually knew a thing or two about heraldry—and smashed them together.

The shield has thirteen vertical stripes. White represents purity. Red represents hardiness and valor. The blue top part, known as the "chief" in heraldry speak, represents vigilance, perseverance, and justice. By leaving the stars off the shield itself and putting them in a "glory" above the eagle’s head, the designers were saying that the states (the stripes) support the federal government (the blue chief), but the "divine" light of the union (the stars) is a separate, higher thing altogether.

The Eagle wasn't everyone's first choice

Everyone knows the Benjamin Franklin story. He supposedly wanted a turkey. Well, that’s not quite true. Franklin didn't suggest a turkey during the official committee meetings; he just complained about the eagle in a letter to his daughter, Sarah Bache, in 1784. He thought the bald eagle was a bird of "bad moral character" because it steals fish from hawks. He called the turkey a "much more respectable bird."

But before the eagle won out, the suggestions were honestly wild.

The first committee—which included heavy hitters like Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, and Franklin—wanted something biblical or classical. Jefferson proposed a scene of the Children of Israel in the wilderness. Franklin wanted Moses parting the Red Sea. They were leaning hard into the "New Exodus" vibe. It was too complex. You can't engrave a whole Bible scene onto a small wax seal and expect it to look like anything other than a blob.

Then came the second committee in 1780. They brought in professional artists. They tried out a shield with thirteen diagonal stripes. They added a soldier and a lady representing Liberty. Still didn't stick. It wasn't until 1782 that Charles Thomson simplified everything. He moved the eagle to the center. He put the bundle of 13 arrows in the left talon and the olive branch in the right.

Look at the eagle’s head. It’s always turned toward the olive branch. That’s a signal. It means the United States prefers peace but is always ready for war. During the Truman administration, there was actually a minor "fix" to the presidential seal because, in some versions, the eagle had been facing the arrows. Truman wanted it clear: peace comes first.

The Reverse Side: Pyramids and Conspiracy Theories

We can't talk about the US coat of arms without talking about the "creepy" side. The reverse of the Great Seal is the unfinished pyramid with the eye floating over it. You’ve seen the memes. You’ve seen the movies. No, it’s not a secret Illuminati handshake.

The pyramid represents "strength and duration." It’s unfinished because the American project is never done. The Eye of Providence (the eye in the triangle) was a very common 18th-century symbol for God. It wasn't sinister back then. It was just a way of saying, "Hey, we hope the Creator is watching over this experiment."

The Latin phrases are where people get tripped up. Annuit Coeptis means "He favors our undertakings." Novus Ordo Seclorum translates to "A New Order of the Ages." It wasn't a "New World Order" in the sense of a global shadow government; it was a way of saying that 1776 marked the beginning of a new era in human history, moving away from the age of kings.

You can't just slap the US coat of arms on a t-shirt and sell it. Well, you can, but the government has some very specific rules about it. Under 18 U.S.C. § 713, it is actually a federal crime to use the Great Seal or the Presidential Seal in a way that suggests government sponsorship or endorsement when there isn't any.

  • Federal Buildings: You'll see it in bronze or stone over the entrances of embassies and courthouses.
  • Military Uniforms: It appears on buttons and certain rank insignia.
  • Currency: It’s the most common place civilians interact with it.
  • Diplomatic Documents: When a treaty is signed, this seal makes it "real."

If you’re a historian, you know that the actual physical "die" (the metal stamp) of the Great Seal is kept at the State Department. It’s only used about 2,000 to 3,000 times a year now. Back in the day, it was used for everything. Now, it’s reserved for things like the commissions of cabinet officers and ambassadors, or for ratifying treaties.

Common Misconceptions

People think the eagle is holding a "peace pipe" or something. No. It's an olive branch. Specifically, an olive branch with 13 leaves and 13 olives.

Another big one: the shield. People often think the shield is a version of the American flag. It’s not. If you look at the flag, there are stars in the blue section (the canton). In the US coat of arms, the blue section (the chief) is solid. There are no stars on the shield. This is a very specific heraldic rule that the founders followed to keep the design "clean."

Also, the eagle on the seal is a Bald Eagle. It’s unique to North America. That was a huge point of pride. They wanted a bird that didn't exist in Europe. It was a way of saying, "We are something entirely different."

How to use this knowledge

Understanding the US coat of arms is basically a cheat code for understanding American political philosophy. It’s about balance. The balance between the states and the federal government. The balance between peace and war. The balance between the "glory" of the ideal and the "unfinished" work of the pyramid.

If you are a teacher, a history buff, or just someone who wants to win a bar trivia night, keep these points in mind:

  1. Check the talons. If the eagle is facing the arrows, it’s an old or unofficial design. The head should always face the olive branch.
  2. Count the 13s. There are 13 stars, 13 arrows, 13 leaves, 13 olives, 13 stripes on the shield, and even 13 letters in "E Pluribus Unum."
  3. Look for the "Eye." Remind people that it’s not a conspiracy; it’s an 18th-century symbol for divine watchfulness.
  4. Note the shield. Notice the lack of stars on the chest shield. That is the quickest way to spot a high-quality, historically accurate reproduction versus a cheap knock-off.

The seal isn't just a logo. It’s a 250-year-old time capsule. Every time you pull a dollar bill out of your pocket, you’re looking at a design that was argued over by the same men who wrote the Declaration of Independence. They wanted to make sure that even the money in your pocket reminded you that this country was built to last, but also built to be finished by the people who came after them.

To see the real thing in person, you have to go to the Harry S. Truman Building in Washington, D.C. The Department of State keeps the Great Seal on display in an exhibit hall. It’s a massive piece of equipment, and seeing the actual copper die makes you realize how much weight—literally and figuratively—this symbol carries. Check the State Department's official website for tour hours before you go, as security in D.C. can be tight and schedules change. If you're looking for high-resolution files for educational projects, the National Archives has digitized versions of the original 1782 drawings.