The Truth About What Was The Cure For Black Death (And Why Nothing Worked)

The Truth About What Was The Cure For Black Death (And Why Nothing Worked)

If you were living in Florence or London in 1348, you weren't looking for a "wellness plan." You were looking for a way to stay alive while your neighbors turned black and blue and died within three days. People always ask: what was the cure for black death? The short, brutal answer is that there wasn't one. Not a real one. Not by modern standards. But the story of how humanity tried to fight back—using everything from ground-up emeralds to literal "pocketfuls of posies"—is a wild, terrifying look at how desperate we get when the world starts ending.

It’s hard to wrap your head around the scale of it. We’re talking about Yersinia pestis, a bacterium that wiped out somewhere between 30% and 60% of Europe's entire population in just a few years. It wasn't just a "bad flu." It was a biological wrecking ball.

The Medieval "Cures" That Likely Made Things Worse

When the plague hit, the medical "experts" of the day—guys who followed the teachings of Galen and Hippocrates—thought the body was governed by four humors. Blood, phlegm, yellow bile, and black bile. If you got sick, your humors were out of whack. So, the first thing a doctor would do to find a cure for black death was reach for a blade.

Bloodletting was the gold standard. They figured the "poison" was in the blood, so if they drained a few pints, you’d be fine. Spoiler: you wouldn't be fine. You’d just be a plague victim who was also severely anemic and lightheaded.

Then there were the "buboes." These were the swollen, painful lymph nodes in the armpits and groin that gave the Bubonic Plague its name. Some doctors thought the cure for black death was to lance these boils. They’d cut them open and apply a paste made of—and I am not making this up—human excrement, resin, and dried lilies. Think about that for a second. You have an open wound, and someone puts feces on it. Instead of curing the plague, they were essentially inviting a massive staph infection to finish the job.

Aromatherapy as a Last Resort

Ever wonder about that "Ring Around the Rosie" rhyme? "Pocket full of posies." That’s not just a cute kids' song; it’s a reference to miasma theory. People believed the plague was carried by "bad air" or foul smells.

📖 Related: How to Perform Anal Intercourse: The Real Logistics Most People Skip

To "cure" the air, people would:

  • Carry bouquets of strong-smelling flowers.
  • Burn incense like frankincense or pomanders.
  • Sit between two massive fires to "purify" the atmosphere (which, ironically, might have helped by keeping fleas away, though they didn't know it).
  • Sniff sponges soaked in vinegar.

The Strange Role of "Thierac" and Emeralds

For the rich, the cure for black death got even weirder. If you had the money, you’d go for Theriac. This was a "miracle" potion with over 60 ingredients, including bits of snake skin and opium. It took months to ferment. Did it work? No. But it probably got you high enough that you didn't care as much about the agonizing pain in your lymph nodes.

Some doctors even suggested eating crushed emeralds. Imagine being so desperate that you swallow ground-up gemstones. It sounds insane to us, but when you're watching your entire family die, you'll try anything. People even tried "Vicary’s Method," which involved plucking the feathers off a live chicken’s backside and strapping the bird to the victim's swollen buboes. The idea was that the chicken would "draw out" the poison. All it really did was stress out a lot of chickens.

What Actually Stopped the Plague?

If none of these medical "cures" worked, why did the Black Death eventually fade away? It wasn't because of a medical breakthrough. It was because of social engineering and raw biology.

The real "cure" for the Black Death wasn't a pill or a potion; it was quarantine. The word itself comes from the Italian quaranta giorni, meaning 40 days. In Venice, they started forcing incoming ships to sit at anchor for 40 days before anyone could come ashore. They realized—even without knowing about bacteria—that if you just kept sick people away from healthy people long enough, the disease would run out of hosts.

👉 See also: I'm Cranky I'm Tired: Why Your Brain Shuts Down When You're Exhausted

Social distancing isn't new. It’s a 14th-century survival tactic.

The Genetic Aftermath

There's also the grim reality of natural selection. The Black Death was so lethal that it actually changed the human genome. A study published in Nature by researchers like evolutionary geneticist Hendrik Poinar found that survivors of the Black Death often carried specific variants of a gene called ERAP2. If you had the right version of this gene, you were 40% more likely to survive.

Basically, the people who lived were the ones whose immune systems were naturally "pre-programmed" to recognize Yersinia pestis. The plague didn't go away because we beat it; it went away because it ran out of people who were easy to kill.

Why We Don't Need a "Cure" Like That Anymore

Today, we actually do have a cure for black death. It’s called antibiotics. If you caught the plague today—and yes, people still get it in places like New Mexico, Madagascar, and Mongolia—you wouldn't be reaching for a chicken or a bag of herbs. You’d be given Streptomycin or Gentamicin.

The mortality rate without treatment is around 50% to 90%. With modern antibiotics? It drops to about 10%. We went from "the wrath of God" to "a ten-day course of pills."

✨ Don't miss: Foods to Eat to Prevent Gas: What Actually Works and Why You’re Doing It Wrong

The Limits of Knowledge

It's easy to look back and laugh at the "doctors" wearing bird masks (though the famous plague doctor mask actually became popular in the 17th century, much later than the initial Black Death). But they were doing the best they could with the information they had. They were observing a terrifying phenomenon and trying to apply logic to it. Their logic was just based on a flawed understanding of how the world works.

They didn't know about the Oriental rat flea (Xenopsylla cheopis). They didn't know that the bacteria would clog the flea's digestive tract, making it starve and bite everything in sight, vomiting the bacteria into the host's bloodstream. If they had known that, the cure for black death would have been simple: kill the rats. Instead, they killed cats and dogs, thinking they were the source, which actually made the rat population explode. Talk about a backfire.

Actionable Insights for the Modern Era

While the Black Death feels like ancient history, it offers some pretty heavy lessons for how we handle health crises today. History shows us that human behavior is often the most effective "cure."

  1. Sanitation over Superstition: The ultimate decline of plague in Europe was largely due to better housing (moving from wood and mud to brick) and improved hygiene, which reduced contact with rodents. Keep your living spaces clear of pests.
  2. Early Intervention: Modern "cures" only work if they are administered fast. If you're traveling in areas where the plague is endemic (like parts of the Western US or Central Asia) and develop sudden fever or swollen glands, seek medical help immediately.
  3. Respect the Science: We moved from lancing boils with cow dung to targeted antibiotics. Trusting peer-reviewed medical data over "home remedies" is why our life expectancy isn't 35 anymore.
  4. Understand the Vector: If you're hiking in plague-prone areas, use DEET. Prevent flea bites on yourself and your pets. The "cure" is often just preventing the bite in the first place.

The Black Death wasn't defeated by a hero or a single discovery. It was weathered by a traumatized population that eventually learned—through trial, error, and a lot of death—that isolation and cleanliness were the only things that moved the needle. Today, the cure for black death is sitting in a pharmacy, a testament to how far we’ve come from the days of crushed emeralds and terrified doctors.


Source References:

  • The Black Death: A Personal History by John Hatcher.
  • Nature Journal: "Evolution of immune genes is associated with the Black Death."
  • CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) Plague Manual.
  • The Great Mortality by John Kelly.