You're standing in the dealership lot, and the salesman is pointing at a shimmering SUV that looks like a literal tank. It's the Pilot. Or maybe you're eyeing the sliding doors of the Odyssey, feeling that slight pang of "suburban dad" or "soccer mom" guilt creeping in. Choosing a three row Honda isn't just about how many seats you can cram into a chassis. It’s about whether you can actually fit a human being in the back without them needing a chiropractor after twenty minutes.
Let's be real. Honda has a weirdly loyal following for a reason. They don't always have the flashiest screens or the most aggressive grills, but they tend to nail the ergonomics. When we talk about a deep dive into the three row Honda, we aren't just looking at spec sheets. We're looking at why these vehicles have become the default setting for families who actually use their cars for more than just commuting.
The Pilot vs. The World: Is the Fourth Gen Actually Better?
The current fourth-generation Honda Pilot, which dropped for the 2023 model year, was a massive shift in philosophy. The previous version looked like a minivan that had its sliding doors stolen. It was soft. Rounded. A bit "meh." The new one? It’s boxy. It looks like it wants to go camping, even if the most off-roading it ever sees is a gravel driveway in the suburbs.
But here’s the thing most reviewers gloss over: the removable middle seat. In the Touring and Elite trims, you can literally take out the center seat in the second row and stow it under the trunk floor. It’s genius. It gives you the flexibility of captain's chairs when you want the kids separated, but you keep the eight-passenger capacity for when the cousins visit. No one else is doing that right now.
The 3.5-liter V6 is a dinosaur, honestly. But it’s a reliable dinosaur. While everyone else is moving to turbocharged four-cylinders that sound like sewing machines and might blow a gasket at 80,000 miles, Honda stuck with a naturally aspirated engine. It’s smooth. It’s predictable. It gets about 19 miles per gallon in the city, which kind of sucks, but you know it’ll probably start every morning for the next fifteen years.
The Odyssey Problem (Or Why Minivans Are Actually Cool)
I know, I know. You don't want a minivan. You want to feel like an adventurer. But if you’re doing a deep dive into the three row Honda lineup and you ignore the Odyssey, you’re making a tactical error.
📖 Related: Bridal Hairstyles Long Hair: What Most People Get Wrong About Your Wedding Day Look
The Odyssey is built on the same global light truck platform as the Pilot, but it uses its space so much better. The "Magic Slide" seats are the MVP here. You can slide the second-row seats sideways. Why does this matter? Because when you have two car seats installed, you can shove them together to reach both kids from the front, or pull one away to create a wide path to the third row. Try doing that in a Pilot without breaking your back.
Low floor heights are the secret sauce. In an SUV, your kids are climbing up. In an Odyssey, they’re stepping in. It sounds like a small distinction until you’ve done it 4,000 times in a calendar year while holding three bags of groceries and a leaking juice box.
Real Talk on Interior Quality
Honda interiors are... fine. They aren't Mazda-level luxury, and they aren't as tech-heavy as a Hyundai. They use physical buttons for the climate control. Thank God. Trying to adjust the AC through a touchscreen while driving 70 mph is a recipe for a fender bender.
The "CabinWatch" camera is a bit creepy, but being able to see if the toddler in the back is actually sleeping or just plotting something is a game changer. The resolution isn't 4K, but it gets the job done.
What People Get Wrong About the Third Row
Most "three row" vehicles are actually "two-and-a-half" row vehicles. If you put a grown adult in the back of a CR-V (the overseas version that has seven seats), they will hate you forever.
👉 See also: Boynton Beach Boat Parade: What You Actually Need to Know Before You Go
In the Pilot, the third row is actually usable. You’ve got 32.5 inches of legroom back there. For context, that’s better than some "economy plus" seats on a budget airline. Is it a couch? No. But a teenager can sit there for an hour without their knees hitting their chin.
The Odyssey blows the SUV out of the water here. It offers nearly 38 inches of third-row legroom. That is massive. You can fit three adults across the back of an Odyssey, and while they won't be thrilled, they won't be calling a lawyer either.
Reliability and the "Honda Tax"
You're going to pay more for a Honda. That’s the "Honda Tax." You’ll see a Kia Telluride or a Hyundai Palisade and think, "Man, I get way more features for $5,000 less." And you’re right. You do.
But check the resale values. A five-year-old Pilot or Odyssey holds its value like a bar of gold. People buy them used with 100,000 miles on the clock because they trust the engineering. There were some issues with the 9-speed transmissions a few years back, which Honda mostly sorted out by switching to their own 10-speed unit in the newer models.
Always check the VIN. Some 2018-2019 models had flickering infotainment screens and popping noises in the speakers. It was a whole thing. Honda eventually issued a massive extended warranty for it, but it’s something to watch for if you’re shopping the used market.
✨ Don't miss: Bootcut Pants for Men: Why the 70s Silhouette is Making a Massive Comeback
The TrailSport: Marketing or Real Capability?
If you're looking at the Pilot, you've seen the TrailSport trim. It has a one-inch lift, all-terrain tires, and steel skid plates. It looks tough.
Is it a Jeep Wrangler? No. Don't try to rock crawl in it.
Is it better than the average crossover? Absolutely.
The torque-vectoring i-VTM4 AWD system is legit. It can send 70% of the power to the rear wheels and then 100% of that power to either the left or right wheel. If you’re trying to get up a snowy driveway in Vermont or a muddy path to a trailhead, the Pilot TrailSport is actually one of the best in its class. Most competitors just use the brakes to mimic torque vectoring, which overheats and fails. Honda uses actual gears and clutches. It’s a mechanical solution to a mechanical problem.
Maintenance Reality Check
- Oil Changes: The Maintenance Minder system is pretty accurate. Expect to see the light every 7,500 miles or so.
- Timing Belt: This is the big one. The J35 engine uses a belt, not a chain. You have to replace it around 100,000 miles. It’ll cost you about $1,200 to $1,500. If you don't do it and it snaps, the engine is toast.
- VCM (Variable Cylinder Management): The engine shuts off cylinders to save gas. Some owners hate the slight vibration it causes. There are "muzzler" kits online to disable it, but honestly, in the newer models, you barely notice it.
The Practical Verdict
Choosing between the two main three row Honda options comes down to your ego. If you can handle the "van life" stigma, the Odyssey is the superior tool for moving people and gear. It has more volume, better access, and better fuel economy on the highway.
If you need to tow (up to 5,000 lbs) or you live somewhere with heavy snow, the Pilot is the move. It’s more capable, it looks better in a parking lot, and the AWD system is genuinely sophisticated.
The biggest mistake people make? Buying the top-tier "Black Edition" or "Elite" and thinking it’s a luxury car. It’s not. It’s a very high-quality tool. The leather is durable, not buttery. The plastics are hard where they need to be. It’s built to survive kids, dogs, and spills.
Actionable Steps for Your Search
- Test the "Stowable" Seat: If you’re looking at a Pilot Touring or Elite, ask the dealer to show you exactly how to remove and store that middle seat. It’s heavier than it looks. Make sure you can do it without throwing out your back.
- Check the Slide: In the Odyssey, try sliding the Magic Seats with a car seat (or a heavy box) strapped in. See if the passthrough to the back is wide enough for your specific needs.
- Verify the Transmission: If buying used (2018-2020), confirm if it has the 9-speed ZF transmission or the Honda 10-speed. The 10-speed is generally preferred for smoothness.
- Measure Your Garage: The Pilot is surprisingly wide. The Odyssey is long. If you have a tight suburban garage, bring a tape measure before you sign the papers.
- Compare the TrailSport: If you don't actually go off-pavement, skip the TrailSport. The all-terrain tires are noisier on the highway and will slightly drop your fuel economy compared to the EX-L or Touring trims.
The three row Honda market is crowded, but staying focused on how you actually live—rather than how the commercials say you should live—will save you thousands. Focus on the seating flexibility and the long-term reliability of that V6, and you'll likely be happy with the purchase for a decade.