You know that feeling. You're scrolling through Instagram or TikTok and you see a photo of a group of people laughing, toasted drinks in hand, looking like the absolute definition of "squad goals." But then you remember. You know those people. You know that two of them haven't spoken in months and the one in the middle was crying in the bathroom five minutes before that shutter clicked. Pictures of fake friends are everywhere, and honestly, they’re becoming a weird currency in our digital lives.
It’s performative. That’s the word for it. We live in an era where the appearance of a social life often carries more weight than the actual quality of the connections. You’ve probably seen it at brunch or a party: a group of people who aren't even talking to each other suddenly huddle together, put on their "camera faces," and snap a dozen photos. Once the flash fades? They go right back to their phones. It's jarring. It’s also deeply confusing for anyone on the outside looking in, wondering why their own life doesn't look that polished.
But there is a real psychological toll here. We aren't just talking about "clout chasing." We are talking about a fundamental shift in how we document our existence and who we choose to include in that narrative.
Why We Post Pictures of Fake Friends Even When We Know Better
Why do we do it? It’s rarely about malice. Usually, it’s about social signaling. Research in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships suggests that people often engage in "relationship maintenance" online to convince themselves as much as others that their social circle is thriving. If you post a photo with someone you don't actually like, you’re often trying to claim a certain status or belong to a specific "vibe."
It's "faking it till you make it," but with human beings as the props.
Think about the "influencer" culture. In that world, pictures of fake friends are basically a business requirement. Collaboration is the engine of growth. You see two creators posing together, looking like besties, but it’s often a strictly transactional arrangement arranged by managers. The audience eats it up because we are hardwired to value social proof. If someone has "friends," they must be trustworthy, right? Not necessarily.
🔗 Read more: Chuck E. Cheese in Boca Raton: Why This Location Still Wins Over Parents
Sometimes, the "fake" part isn't even about the people being bad. It’s about the context. You can be "situational friends" with someone—work buddies, gym partners—and the photo makes it look like you’re soulmates. When that photo hits the feed, the nuance is lost. It’s just a flat image of a bond that doesn't exist at that depth in the real world.
The Red Flags: How to Spot a "Performative" Photo
You can usually tell when a photo feels off. There’s a certain stiffness. A "forced" quality to the joy.
- The Mid-Laugh Cliché: You know the one. Everyone is looking away from the camera, mouths wide open, pretending they just heard the funniest joke in history. If every photo of a group looks like a candid from a toothpaste commercial, it’s probably curated.
- The Tagging Game: When someone tags twenty people in a photo where you can barely see their faces, it’s often about reach, not memory-making.
- The Disappearing Act: Look at the timeline. If someone is "obsessed" with a new best friend for three weeks, posts fifty pictures of them, and then that person never appears again? That was a seasonal, or "fake," friendship.
Psychologist Dr. Sherry Turkle has written extensively about how we "edit" our lives. In her book Alone Together, she explores how digital connections can provide the illusion of companionship without the demands of friendship. A photo is the ultimate edit. It removes the arguments, the silence, and the lack of common ground. It leaves only the visual evidence of a "connection."
The Impact on Mental Health and Perception
It’s exhausting to keep up. When you’re the one taking pictures of fake friends just to stay relevant in a social circle, you’re eroding your own sense of authenticity. You start to view your life as a series of captures rather than a series of experiences.
And for the viewers? It’s worse.
💡 You might also like: The Betta Fish in Vase with Plant Setup: Why Your Fish Is Probably Miserable
We compare our "behind-the-scenes" with everyone else’s "highlight reel." This is a classic concept in sociology, but it’s been put on steroids by social media. You see a photo of your "fake" friend group and feel FOMO, even though you know for a fact that the night was actually boring or tense. Your brain struggles to reconcile the visual data with the emotional reality.
Moving Toward Authentic Documentation
So, what’s the fix? Do we stop taking photos? No. That’s unrealistic. But we can change the intent.
Authenticity isn't about having a "messy" feed. It’s about ensuring that the people in your digital space actually hold space in your physical and emotional life. If you find yourself hesitant to post a photo because you aren't sure if that person actually likes you, or if you’re only posting it to spite an ex or prove a point—stop. Just don't hit upload.
Real friendship doesn't need a PR department.
The most meaningful photos are often the ones that never make it to the grid. They are the blurry, poorly lit shots sitting in your camera roll because you were too busy actually having fun to care about the lighting or the "aesthetic." Those are the anti-fake-friend pictures.
📖 Related: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today
How to Audit Your Social Circle and Your Feed
If you’re feeling overwhelmed by the "fakeness" of your social media presence, it’s time for a bit of a purge. Not necessarily a "delete everyone" dramatic exit, but a shift in perspective.
- Check the "Energy Drain": Look at your last five group photos. When you see those faces, do you feel supported or do you feel like you have to perform? If it’s the latter, those are the people you should stop documenting so heavily.
- Stop "Proving" Your Life: Challenges like the "Photo Dump" trend were supposed to be about authenticity, but even those have become curated. Try posting a photo that means something to you, even if it doesn't "look" like a friendship advertisement.
- Value Privacy Over Publicity: Start keeping the best moments for yourself. There is a strange power in having a great time with a friend and realizing, at the end of the night, that neither of you even took your phone out. That’s a real bond.
We have to stop treating our friends like accessories. A person is not a background element for your "main character" arc. When we treat people as props for pictures of fake friends, we lose the ability to see them—and ourselves—clearly.
The Next Steps for Digital Authenticity
The shift starts with awareness. Next time you're out, pay attention to the urge to document. Is it because you want to remember the moment, or because you want people to see you having the moment?
Audit your "tagged" photos. See who is consistently using your image to boost their own social standing without actually showing up for you when the phone is away. It’s okay to untag yourself. It’s okay to set boundaries.
Prioritize "ugly" memories. Keep the photos where you look a bit disheveled but you were genuinely happy. Those are the records that will actually matter in ten years. The curated, "fake" ones will just look like a costume you used to wear.
Focus on the "off-screen" connection. Reach out to one person today with a text or a call that has nothing to do with social media. No likes, no comments, no public validation. Just a real conversation. That’s how you start replacing the "fake" with something that actually lasts.