You’re wandering through the shivering, jagged aisles of the Shivering Isles, and you hear about it. A spell. Not just some generic fireball or a basic frost cloak, but something with a name that sounds like it was ripped from an epic poem: the Cold Flame of Agnon. It sounds legendary. It sounds like something that should break the game or at least turn every Grummite you encounter into a pile of frozen ash. But honestly? Getting your hands on it is less about luck and more about making a specific, irreversible choice during one of the best expansions in RPG history.
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion is famous for its weirdness. The Shivering Isles takes that weirdness and cranks it to eleven. This particular spell is a reward for a quest called "The Cold Flame of Agnon," which is the heart of the main questline for the Isles. It’s the quest where you have to light the Great Torch in New Sheoth to signal the beginning of a new era. Or at least, to make Sheogorath happy for five minutes.
Why the Cold Flame of Agnon Still Bothers People
It's about the choice. Most players go into the quest thinking they’re just following a linear path. You go to Cylarne, a ruin that’s basically a battleground between the Golden Saints and the Dark Seducers. These two groups hate each other. Like, really hate each other. And you’re stuck in the middle.
The spell itself isn’t just a random loot drop. You can’t find it in a chest or buy it from a vendor in Crucible. You earn it by literally becoming the flame. To light the torch, you have to jump into the Fire of Agnon at Cylarne. This gives you a permanent addition to your spellbook, but what that spell actually is depends entirely on which faction you sided with during the battle for the ruins.
If you side with the Golden Saints (the Aureals), you get a version of the spell that reflects their affinity for the light and the sun. Side with the Dark Seducers (the Mazken), and you get something that feels a bit more "moonlight and shadow."
The Real Stats (No Fluff)
Here is what you are actually getting. The Cold Flame of Agnon is technically a "Greater Power," meaning you can only cast it once per day. This is the part that usually disappoints people who were hoping for a spammable destruction spell.
🔗 Read more: Among Us Spider-Man: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With These Mods
- Golden Saint Version: Usually involves a Fire Shield effect and a boost to your personality or intelligence. It’s defensive. It’s bright.
- Dark Seducer Version: Generally offers a Frost Shield and a boost to strength or endurance. It’s for the brawlers.
Wait. Let’s be real for a second. In a game where you can literally create your own spells at the Arcane University, a once-a-day power feels... okay. It’s cool for the flavor. It’s fantastic for roleplaying. But if you’re looking for raw DPS, you’ve probably already built a "Weakness to Magic 100% + Fire Damage 100" custom spell that deletes everything anyway.
The Cylarne Strategy: How to Actually Get It
The quest is messy. You arrive at Cylarne and meet Mirel, a Golden Saint who is basically the commander. She’ll tell you that the Dark Seducers have the "Altar of Despair" and they’re holding the fire. You have two real options here, and a secret third one that most people miss because they’re in a hurry.
- The Direct Approach: You talk to the Saints, agree to lead them in a frontal assault, and just murder every Seducer in sight. It’s loud. It’s bloody.
- The Backdoor Approach: You talk to the Seducer commander, Vika. She’ll ask you to lure the Saints into a trap. This is the "deceptive" route.
- The "I’m the Champion" Approach: You can actually convince the Saints to go through the side passage while you take the main door, or vice-versa.
The most important thing to remember? The Cold Flame of Agnon doesn't care how many people you killed. It only cares whose side won the battle. Once the enemies are cleared out, you step into the fire. Your character will literally catch on fire. You won't take damage (usually), but you’ll carry that flame all the way back to New Sheoth.
Common Misconceptions
People often think you can get both versions of the spell. You can’t. Not without console commands, anyway. Once you step into the fire for one side, the quest flag is set.
Another big one: "The spell scales with your level."
Sorta. Oblivion’s leveling system is notoriously "crunchy." While many quest rewards in the Shivering Isles are leveled (meaning they are stronger if you get them at level 30 vs level 5), the Cold Flame of Agnon power is relatively static in its utility. It’s a utility buff.
💡 You might also like: Why the Among the Sleep Mom is Still Gaming's Most Uncomfortable Horror Twist
Is it even worth the inventory space?
Well, it doesn't take up inventory space, since it’s a spell. But in terms of your "favorites" menu? It depends on your build. If you are playing a heavy armor character, the Dark Seducer version's Frost Shield is actually a decent emergency button. If you’re a mage who messed up their leveling and has low health, the Golden Saint version might save you from a stray arrow.
Honestly, the best part of the whole ordeal isn't the spell. It's the "Flame Agnon" title you carry while walking to the city. NPCs will comment on it. Guards will react. It’s one of those immersive moments Bethesda used to be so good at—making the world acknowledge that you’re doing something insane.
Technical Glitches to Watch Out For
Let's talk bugs. Oblivion is held together by duct tape and dreams. Sometimes, when you jump into the fire at Cylarne, the "Flame Carrier" script doesn't trigger. You’ll just stand there, not on fire, looking like an idiot.
If this happens:
- Reload a save from before you started the battle.
- Make sure you’ve spoken to the commander of the winning side after the last enemy is dead.
- Don't fast travel immediately. Sometimes the game needs a second to register that you are the human torch.
There’s also a weird interaction with 100% Spell Reflection. If you have gear that reflects magic, sometimes the "blessing" of the fire can be reflected. This shouldn't happen with this specific script, but with Oblivion, never say never.
📖 Related: Appropriate for All Gamers NYT: The Real Story Behind the Most Famous Crossword Clue
Actionable Steps for Your Next Playthrough
If you’re sitting at your desk right now wondering which side to pick, stop overthinking.
First, look at your character sheet. Are you dying too fast to physical attacks? Pick the Dark Seducers for that Frost Shield and physical boost. Are you trying to pass speech checks or need more magicka? Go Golden Saint.
Second, if you’re a completionist, save your game before the battle at Cylarne. Play out both scenarios. See which commander you dislike less. The Golden Saints are incredibly arrogant; the Dark Seducers are perpetually depressed and paranoid. It’s a classic "pick your poison" scenario.
Finally, once you have the spell, remember to actually use it. It’s a "Greater Power." You have to manually select it in your magic menu. Most players get it, light the torch in New Sheoth, and then completely forget they have a unique, lore-heavy spell sitting in their menu for the rest of the game. Don't be that player. Use the flame.
Check your active effects menu after the quest. You might find that the "Cold Flame" has some hidden benefits you didn't notice during the chaos of the quest. It’s a piece of Shivering Isles history, and even if it isn't the strongest spell in your arsenal, it's one of the coolest stories your character can tell.