People still freak out about it. Honestly, if you play Guns N' Roses I Used To Love Her at a party today, someone is bound to give you a side-eye or start a lecture about misogyny in 80s rock. It sounds like a confession. It’s got that breezy, acoustic, almost campfire-style shuffle that makes the lyrics hit like a cold bucket of water. Axl Rose sings about burying a woman six feet under because she complained too much. It's dark. It's jarring.
But here’s the thing: it was a joke.
Really.
The track appeared on the 1988 EP G N' R Lies, sandwiched between the high-octane sleaze of the Live ?!@ Like a Suicide* era and the acoustic ballads that defined their softer side. While "Patience" was topping charts and making everyone buy bandanas, "I Used to Love Her" was causing a quiet stir in living rooms across America. The band has spent decades explaining that this isn't a song about domestic violence or a secret murder confession. It's a parody of the "ballad" trope, born out of a specific kind of 1980s bratty cynicism.
Why Guns N' Roses I Used To Love Her was a total prank
The late 80s were saturated with power ballads. Every hair metal band was crying about a "girl who got away." Slash and Izzy Stradlin weren't interested in that. According to Slash’s own autobiography, the song was written as a joke after they heard a particularly sappy song on the radio. They thought it would be hilarious to write a song that started off sounding like a sweet love story and then took a sharp, violent left turn into absurdity.
It was a skit.
Think about the lyrics. He says he had to kill her because she "drove me nuts" and "she bitched so much." In the context of the Sunset Strip in 1987, this was the band leaning into their "Most Dangerous Band in the World" persona by being as offensive as possible for a laugh. It’s a "snuff" song played as a pop-country ditty. If you listen closely to the studio version, you can hear the band laughing in the background. They weren't hiding the fact that they were taking the piss out of the entire recording industry.
💡 You might also like: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
The dog, the girlfriend, and the urban legends
Fans love a good conspiracy. For years, rumors swirled that Axl Rose wrote Guns N' Roses I Used To Love Her about a dog he had to put down. It’s a nice thought, right? It makes the "six feet under" line feel more like a tragic pet owner story than a horror movie script.
Unfortunately, that’s mostly a myth.
While the "dog theory" is the most popular way for fans to defend the song, Izzy Stradlin—who actually wrote most of the lyrics—has been pretty consistent in interviews. He’s stated it was just a joke about a nagging girlfriend or a general "annoying person" trope. There was no actual body. There was no actual shovel. There wasn't even an actual dog, according to the primary songwriters. It was purely about the shock value.
Does the joke hold up in 2026?
Context is everything. In 1988, GNR was the antithesis of "corporate" rock. They were the guys who lived in a literal "Hell House" surrounded by filth and chaos. Writing a song about killing a girlfriend was, in their minds, just another way to middle-finger the PMRC (Parents Music Resource Center), which was already busy censoring everyone from Prince to Dee Snider.
Today, it’s a bit harder to swallow. We live in an era where we look at art through a much more critical lens regarding violence against women. But looking at it as a historical artifact, the song represents a specific moment in rock history where "bad taste" was a badge of honor. It’s the musical equivalent of a dark comedy movie like Heathers or The War of the Roses.
The musicality: Why it still gets stuck in your head
Strip away the lyrics for a second. The song is actually a masterclass in acoustic arrangement. Izzy Stradlin’s rhythm work is impeccable. It’s a simple three-chord progression—D, A, and G—but it swings.
📖 Related: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
Slash’s lead work on the track is surprisingly melodic and bluesy. He isn't shredding at 100 miles per hour; he’s playing for the song. This contrast is exactly why Guns N' Roses I Used To Love Her works so well. The music says "summer afternoon at the park," while the lyrics say "crime scene investigation."
- The Tempo: It’s mid-tempo, which makes it incredibly catchy.
- The Vocals: Axl stays in a lower, grittier register compared to his "Welcome to the Jungle" scream.
- The Production: Mike Clink kept it raw. You can hear the pick hitting the strings.
If the song had been a heavy, distorted metal track, it would have been forgotten as just another edgy "shock rock" attempt. By making it sound like a folk song, GNR ensured it would be uncomfortable forever.
The fallout and the legacy of Lies
When G N' R Lies dropped, "I Used to Love Her" wasn't even the most controversial song on the record. That "honor" went to "One in a Million," which featured a litany of slurs that Axl Rose would spend the next thirty years trying to explain away.
Because "One in a Million" was so overtly offensive, Guns N' Roses I Used To Love Her kind of got a pass. It was seen as the "lighthearted" offensive song. It’s been covered by dozens of bands, ranging from punk acts to country singers who lean into the "outlaw" vibe.
It also served as a precursor to the Use Your Illusion era. It showed that the band could step away from the Marshall stacks and still command an audience. They weren't just a loud band; they were a band with a very specific, very dark sense of humor.
How to approach the song today
If you're a new fan discovering the band's catalog, you have to look at Lies as a time capsule. It was an era of "Anything Goes" (literally, a song title on their first album). To understand Guns N' Roses I Used To Love Her, you have to understand the environment of the late 80s Los Angeles scene. It was a place of extreme excess, extreme cynicism, and a desperate desire to be the most "real" band in a sea of fake, hair-sprayed clones.
👉 See also: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
Is it a masterpiece? Probably not. Is it an essential part of the GNR mythos? Absolutely. It captures the band at their most flippant, before the massive stadiums and the world tours made everything "serious."
Actionable insights for GNR fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific era of the band or handle the "problematic" nature of the track, here’s how to navigate it.
1. Listen to the 1986 Sound City Session versions
Before Lies, the band recorded several demos. Hearing the evolution of their acoustic style helps you see that these songs weren't just thrown together. They were deliberate stylistic choices.
2. Check out Izzy Stradlin’s solo work
If you like the "rolling" feel of this song, Izzy’s solo albums like 117° or Izzy Stradlin and the Ju Ju Hounds carry that same rootsy, "not-too-serious" rock 'n' roll vibe without the controversial lyrics.
3. Separate the art from the "prank"
Recognize that the band was intentionally playing characters. In the same way you don't think an actor who plays a villain is actually a bad person, the GNR guys were playing the "bad boys" of rock to an extreme degree.
4. Explore the "Lies" liner notes
The original artwork for the Lies EP was designed like a tabloid newspaper. It included headlines like "Wife-beating has been around for 10,000 years." This shows the band was intentionally leaning into a "trashy tabloid" aesthetic for the entire project.
Understanding the history of Guns N' Roses I Used To Love Her doesn't mean you have to love the lyrics, but it does help you see that the band wasn't actually confessing to a crime—they were just trying to see how much they could get away with.