You’re sitting there with your third LaCroix of the afternoon. Or maybe it’s a Topo Chico. You love the bubbles, the crisp bite, and the fact that it isn’t a sugary soda. But then a thought creeps in. You’ve heard the rumors. Someone’s aunt’s cousin once said that all those bubbles are basically just a fast track to passing a jagged mineral deposit through your urinary tract. It’s a terrifying thought. The idea of carbonated water kidney stones is one of those health myths—or maybe half-truths—that just won’t die.
Honestly, it’s understandable why people worry. We’ve spent decades being told that soda is bad for our bones and our kidneys. It feels like anything that fizzes must have a catch. But the science on carbonation is actually a lot more nuanced than the "bubbles equals stones" narrative suggests.
Why People Link Carbonated Water and Kidney Stones
The fear usually starts with phosphoric acid. If you look at the back of a classic dark cola, you'll see it listed right there. Phosphoric acid is a known troublemaker. It can lead to urinary changes that promote stone formation. But here is the thing: plain carbonated water doesn’t have it.
Carbonation is just carbon dioxide gas dissolved in water under pressure. When you crack that tab, the pressure drops, and the $CO_2$ escapes as bubbles. This creates carbonic acid, which is a very weak acid. It’s not the same thing as the phosphoric acid found in Pepsi or Coke.
Dr. Gary Curhan, a physician at Brigham and Women’s Hospital who has spent years studying kidney stone epidemiology, has looked extensively at beverage intake. His research generally suggests that while sugar-sweetened sodas are a massive risk factor, plain water—even the fizzy kind—is a different story entirely.
But wait. There’s a "but."
Not all sparkling waters are created equal. You’ve got club soda, seltzer, and mineral water. Club soda often has added sodium. Mineral waters like San Pellegrino or Gerolsteiner have naturally occurring minerals like calcium and magnesium. Sodium is a big deal for stone formers. If you’re chugging club soda with high sodium content, you might actually be increasing the amount of calcium your kidneys dump into your urine. That’s a recipe for disaster.
✨ Don't miss: National Breast Cancer Awareness Month and the Dates That Actually Matter
The Role of Calcium and Oxalate
Most kidney stones are calcium oxalate stones. Most people think that to avoid them, they need to stop eating calcium. That’s actually backwards. You need calcium. If you don't have enough calcium in your gut, oxalate (found in spinach, beets, and nuts) has nothing to bind to. So, the oxalate travels to your kidneys alone, finds some calcium there, and—boom—you have a stone.
So, where does carbonated water kidney stones risk fit in?
Some mineral waters are actually rich in calcium and bicarbonate. Bicarbonate can be a secret weapon. It helps alkalinize the urine. For people prone to uric acid stones or certain types of calcium stones, a slightly more alkaline environment is a good thing. It can keep the minerals dissolved rather than letting them crystallize.
A study published in Urological Research actually found that certain mineral waters could potentially reduce the risk of stone formation because of this bicarbonate effect. It’s counter-intuitive. You’re drinking "mineral" water, but it’s actually helping prevent mineral buildup.
The Sodium Trap
If you’re grabbing a bottle of "sparkling water" and the label says it has 75mg of sodium per serving, and you drink six of those a day, you’re adding significant salt to your diet. High sodium intake is a primary driver of kidney stones. It forces your kidneys to excrete more calcium.
If you have a history of stones, you’ve got to be a label reader. Seltzer is usually just water and bubbles. Club soda is water, bubbles, and mineral salts (sodium). Mineral water is whatever came out of the ground.
🔗 Read more: Mayo Clinic: What Most People Get Wrong About the Best Hospital in the World
What About the "Flavor" Problem?
We can’t talk about carbonated water without talking about the "natural flavors" or the citrus additives. Many people squeeze a lemon or lime into their sparkling water. This is actually a brilliant move.
Citrate is a powerful inhibitor of kidney stones. It sticks to calcium and prevents it from pairing up with oxalate. Many urologists, including experts at the Mayo Clinic, actively encourage patients to increase their citrate intake. If your sparkling water habit involves a lot of fresh lemon juice, you might actually be doing your kidneys a massive favor.
However, be wary of the "pre-flavored" cans that use certain artificial sweeteners or high concentrations of sodium to mimic fruit flavors. While the data on sucralose or aspartame directly causing stones is thin, some studies suggest they might alter metabolic processes in ways we don't fully understand yet.
The Hydration Factor
The number one cause of kidney stones? Dehydration. Pure and simple.
If your urine is dark yellow, you’re basically a walking stone factory. The minerals in your urine become concentrated. It’s like a science fair project where you grow sugar crystals in a jar—the more concentrated the solution, the faster the crystals grow.
If drinking carbonated water means you drink 60 ounces of fluid a day instead of the 20 ounces of flat water you’d drink otherwise, the carbonation is a net positive. The sheer volume of fluid dilutes the stone-forming salts.
💡 You might also like: Jackson General Hospital of Jackson TN: The Truth About Navigating West Tennessee’s Medical Hub
Most urologists will tell you that the best water is the water you will actually drink. If bubbles make it palatable, keep bubbling.
A Quick Reality Check on Bone Health
While we’re talking about kidneys, we should mention the bone health myth. People often lump kidneys and bones together when talking about carbonation. The "Framingham Osteoporosis Study" looked at this and found that while cola consumption was associated with lower bone mineral density in women, other carbonated beverages were not. The kidneys handle the acid-base balance of the body remarkably well. The carbonic acid in your Perrier isn't leaching calcium from your skeleton or overloading your renal system.
Practical Steps for Seltzer Lovers
If you are worried about carbonated water kidney stones, you don't have to go cold turkey on the bubbles. You just have to be smart about it.
- Check the Sodium: Flip the bottle. If it has "sodium bicarbonate" or "sodium citrate," check the milligrams. If you’re a stone former, aim for seltzers with 0mg of sodium.
- Add Citrate: Squeeze a real lemon or lime into your glass. The extra citrate is like an insurance policy for your kidneys.
- Watch the "Sparkling Lemonades": These often have high sugar or high-fructose corn syrup. Sugar increases calcium excretion. Stick to plain seltzer with a splash of real fruit.
- Balance with Flat Water: It’s not a bad idea to mix it up. Drink a glass of plain tap water for every can of sparkling water.
- Know Your Stone Type: If you’ve had a stone, get it analyzed. If you have uric acid stones, the bicarbonate in some mineral waters might actually be a medical benefit. If you have calcium phosphate stones, your needs might be different.
The Bottom Line
Carbonated water does not cause kidney stones. In fact, for some people, the right kind of mineral-rich carbonated water might actually help prevent them. The real villains are the phosphoric acid in colas, high sodium levels in processed sparkling drinks, and, most importantly, chronic dehydration.
If you enjoy your bubbly water, you don’t need to stop. Just keep an eye on the sodium label and keep the fresh lemons handy. Your kidneys are much more concerned with the total volume of water you drink than whether or not that water has some $CO_2$ dancing around in it.
The biggest risk isn't the bubbles; it's the stuff companies sometimes add to the bubbles. Stick to the pure stuff, stay hydrated, and your urinary tract should stay clear.