You’re driving down Ocean Parkway. The salt air is hitting your face, and you see that iconic GEICO Skytyper overhead. You want to pull into Tobay Beach. But if you don't have the right sticker on your windshield, that's where the dream hits a literal roadblock. Honestly, Tobay Beach Oyster Bay is one of the most gatekept stretches of sand on Long Island, and for good reason. It’s pristine. It’s quiet. And it’s strictly for Town of Oyster Bay residents during the peak season.
Most people don't realize that "Tobay" is actually an acronym. It stands for Town of Bay Atlantic Yards. Clever, right? It sits right in the middle of Jones Beach Island, sandwiched between West Gilgo and Jones Beach State Park. It feels worlds away from the chaotic crowds at Central Mall or the needle-strewn reputations of lesser-managed spots. Here, the dunes are high, the sand is fine, and the rules are incredibly specific.
Why the Tobay Beach Oyster Bay Residency Rule is So Strict
If you aren't a resident, don't even try it between Memorial Day and Labor Day. You'll get turned away at the booth. I’ve seen it happen a hundred times—angry drivers trying to argue with a teenager in a Town of Oyster Bay polo. It doesn’t work. The town uses a "Resident Only" policy to prevent the massive overcrowding that plagues state-run parks.
This creates a weirdly peaceful vibe. You aren't fighting for a square inch of sand. You aren't listening to five different Bluetooth speakers playing different genres of music. Because it’s limited to town residents who pay local taxes for its upkeep, there’s a sense of collective ownership. People actually pick up their trash.
What about non-residents? You can technically get in after 4:00 PM on weekdays for a fee, but even that changes based on seasonal staffing and town board decisions. If you’re coming from the city or out of state, your best bet is to find a friend who lives in Massapequa, Syosset, or Hicksville and carpool. Otherwise, stick to the State Park down the road.
✨ Don't miss: What Time in South Korea: Why the Peninsula Stays Nine Hours Ahead
The Secret Side: Why the Bay Side is Actually Better
Most people head straight for the Atlantic side. Big waves, surfing, the whole "Ocean" experience. But the real pros—especially families with toddlers—know the Bay side is the MVP of Tobay Beach Oyster Bay.
The bay side faces the Great South Bay. The water is still. It’s shallow. It’s warm. It’s basically a giant, salty bathtub. There’s a spray park there that is legendary among local moms. If you have kids who are terrified of a four-foot shorebreak, the bay side is a literal lifesaver. Plus, the sunset views over the water are objectively better than the ocean side.
- The Marina: There’s a full-service marina with over 150 transient slips. Boaters come from all over the Great South Bay to dock here for the day.
- Dining: You have the Boat Basin Cafe. It’s not five-star dining, but eating a lobster roll while looking at the masts of multimillion-dollar yachts makes it taste better.
- The Tunnel: There is a literal tunnel under Ocean Parkway that connects the bay side to the ocean side. It's a bit of a trek, but it means you can park once and experience two completely different ecosystems.
The JFK Memorial and Wildlife
Right near the entrance, there’s a memorial for John F. Kennedy. It’s a bit of a somber, quiet spot amidst the beach towels and coolers. It was dedicated shortly after his assassination, and it serves as a reminder of the history embedded in these dunes.
Beyond the history, Tobay is part of a delicate migratory bird path. You’ll see areas cordoned off with string and little signs. Those are for the Piping Plovers. They are tiny, endangered, and the Town of Oyster Bay takes their protection very seriously. If you let your dog run through those dunes, expect a hefty fine. Actually, don't bring your dog at all. Pets are a big "no" during the season.
🔗 Read more: Where to Stay in Seoul: What Most People Get Wrong
Parking, Permits, and the Fine Print
Let's talk logistics because this is where people mess up. To get a seasonal pass, you need your vehicle registration and a utility bill showing your Town of Oyster Bay address. You can get these at the beach office or at town halls in Oyster Bay or Massapequa.
The sand at Tobay is different. It’s lighter. It stays cooler. But the walk from the parking lot can be brutal if you’re carrying a heavy cooler and three umbrellas.
- Arrive early. Even with residency restrictions, the lot fills up by 11:00 AM on a Saturday in July.
- Check the tide. At high tide, the beach gets narrow. If you arrive late, you’ll be pushed right up against the dunes.
- Bring cash. Sometimes the machines for the snack bar or the parking attendants (during off-peak non-resident hours) can be finicky with cards.
The snack bar isn't just "beach food." They’ve stepped it up recently. We’re talking decent salads and actual seafood options, though you’ll pay "Long Island prices" for it.
Survival Tips for Your Visit
If you’re heading to Tobay Beach Oyster Bay, you need to understand the wind. Because it’s a barrier island, the wind can whip up out of nowhere. If you don't have sand anchors for your umbrella, your umbrella becomes a javelin. I have seen many "beach day disasters" involve a runaway umbrella hitting a family three rows down. Don't be that person.
💡 You might also like: Red Bank Battlefield Park: Why This Small Jersey Bluff Actually Changed the Revolution
Also, watch out for the flies. When the wind blows from the North (off the bay), the "black flies" come out. They bite. They are relentless. If the wind is coming from the North, maybe stay home or stay in the water. No amount of DEET seems to stop them.
Final Logistics to Remember
Check the Town of Oyster Bay official website before you go. They post updates on water quality and closures. Sometimes after a heavy rain, the bay side might close for swimming due to runoff concerns, even if the ocean side stays open.
What you need to do next:
- Verify your residency status: Double-check that your specific hamlet falls within Town of Oyster Bay limits (some parts of Glen Cove or nearby areas are excluded).
- Get your sticker early: Don't wait until the first 90-degree day in June to stand in line at the beach office; get it in May.
- Pack a "Bay to Ocean" bag: Bring sneakers for the tunnel walk, as the pavement gets hot enough to melt flip-flops.
- Plan your exit: Leaving at exactly 5:00 PM means you'll be stuck in a bottleneck on Ocean Parkway. Leave at 4:00 PM or stay for dinner at the Boat Basin to let the traffic clear.