You’ve probably never heard someone bring up the Treaty of Washington 1871 at a dinner party. It sounds like something meant for a dusty basement in a DC archives building. But honestly? If this piece of paper hadn’t been signed, the map of North America might look completely different today. We might have had a third war between the United States and Great Britain. Seriously.
It was 1871. The American Civil War had been over for six years, but the vibes were still incredibly tense. The U.S. was furious. Britain had basically helped the Confederacy by building them warships, specifically the CSS Alabama. This ship spent years sinking Union merchant vessels. After the North won, they wanted their money back. Some people in Congress, like Senator Charles Sumner, were so mad they suggested Britain should just hand over Canada as "payment."
That’s the kind of high-stakes drama we’re talking about. The Treaty of Washington 1871 wasn’t just a handshake; it was a massive legal experiment that changed how countries settle beef without shooting at each other.
What Really Happened With the Alabama Claims?
The biggest hurdle was something called the Alabama Claims. During the Civil War, the British claimed they were neutral. But they also liked that Southern cotton. So, they let Confederate agents buy ships in Liverpool. The most famous was the Alabama. It never actually docked in a Confederate port; it just sailed around the world torching Union ships.
By 1869, the U.S. government was tallying up the bill. They weren't just looking for the cost of the ships. They wanted "indirect damages." The argument was that British help prolonged the war by two years. The bill? Roughly $2 billion. In 1870s money. That’s an insane amount of cash—basically enough to buy a continent.
Britain, obviously, said no way.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
Hamilton Fish, the U.S. Secretary of State, was the real hero here. He was a chill guy in a room full of hotheads. He knew that if the U.S. pushed too hard for Canada, Britain would fight. And Britain had the world’s biggest navy. Fish worked behind the scenes with Sir John Rose, a Canadian businessman, to get people talking. They eventually set up a High Joint Commission. Ten guys—five British, five American—sat down in Washington to hash it out.
The Meeting That Saved Peace
They met at the State Department. It wasn't all stuffy meetings, though. They went to dinners. They drank together. They basically used "soft diplomacy" before that was even a term. The result was the Treaty of Washington 1871, signed on May 8th.
It did something revolutionary. Instead of a king or a general deciding who won the argument, they handed it over to an international tribunal in Geneva, Switzerland. This was the first major use of international arbitration. They had judges from Italy, Brazil, and Switzerland look at the evidence.
The tribunal eventually ruled that Britain had to pay the U.S. $15.5 million in gold. It was a fraction of what Sumner wanted, but it was enough to satisfy the public and stop a war. Britain apologized—sort of. They expressed "regret," which is the 19th-century version of a corporate "we’re sorry if you were offended" statement. But they paid.
It Wasn't Just About the Ships
While the Alabama got all the headlines, the Treaty of Washington 1871 dealt with a bunch of other messy leftovers.
✨ Don't miss: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
Take the fisheries. New England fishermen and Canadian fishermen had been fighting over mackerel and cod for decades. The treaty basically traded fishing rights for cash and better trade access. It wasn't perfect, and people in Newfoundland were pretty annoyed, but it kept the peace.
Then there was the San Juan Islands dispute—the "Pig War."
If you haven't heard of this, it’s wild. In 1859, an American farmer on San Juan Island (near Seattle/Vancouver) shot a British pig. This almost started a war. Both sides sent troops. They sat there staring at each other for 12 years. The 1871 treaty finally said, "Okay, let’s let the German Emperor, Wilhelm I, decide where the border goes." He picked the Haro Strait, which meant the U.S. got the islands.
Why This Still Matters to You
You might think, "Cool history lesson, but so what?"
The Treaty of Washington 1871 created the "Special Relationship" between the U.S. and the UK. Before this, they were rivals. After this, they realized they could solve problems through law rather than lead. It also stabilized Canada. At the time, Canada had only been a Confederation for four years. The treaty forced the U.S. to basically admit that Canada was a real thing and not just a territory waiting to be annexed.
🔗 Read more: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
It also set the stage for the League of Nations and the United Nations. The idea that a neutral third party can judge a dispute between superpowers started right here.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs and Policy Wonks
If you’re researching this or just curious about how diplomacy works, here is the takeaway from 1871:
- Look for the "Hamilton Fish" in any conflict. Every big dispute needs a moderate who is willing to ignore the loud voices in their own party to get a deal done.
- Arbitration is a tool of power, not weakness. Britain didn't lose face by paying the $15.5 million; they actually gained security by making sure the U.S. wouldn't support rebels in Ireland or elsewhere later on.
- The "Indirect Damages" lesson. In law and diplomacy, asking for too much (like the $2 billion claim) can actually stall progress. The U.S. had to drop the "indirect" charges to get the real money.
- Check the San Juan Islands. If you ever visit the San Juan Islands in Washington State, go to the English Camp and the American Camp. They are National Historical Parks now. You can see exactly where the soldiers lived while they waited for the 1871 treaty to settle their border.
To really understand the Treaty of Washington 1871, you have to see it as a pivot point. It was the moment the United States stopped being a "junior" power and started acting like a global player that could hold its own at a table with the British Empire.
Next time you're looking at a map of the Pacific Northwest or wondering why the U.S. and Canada are so tight, remember those ten guys in a humid DC room in 1871. They chose a boring treaty over a bloody war, and honestly, we're all better off for it.