Drinking your dinner sounds like something reserved for hospital stays or aggressive weight-loss cleanses. But in the zero-carb community, the total carnivore steak shake has become a legitimate tool for people who can't seem to stomach another solid ribeye or those trying to hit massive caloric goals without the jaw ache. It sounds gross. Honestly, the first time you hear about blending a cooked steak with water and ice, your stomach probably does a little flip. Mine did. But if you look at the metabolic science and the practical reality of high-fat dieting, this "meat smoothie" starts to make a weird kind of sense.
Let’s be real. Eating two pounds of steak a day is a chore.
📖 Related: Can olive oil cause breakouts? What your skin isn't telling you
Chewing is the enemy of high-volume carnivores. When you're transitioning into a ketogenic or carnivorous state, your hunger signals are often all over the place. Some days you're a ravenous wolf; other days, the smell of searing suet makes you want to bolt for the door. The total carnivore steak shake solves a very specific problem: nutrient density without the mechanical effort. It’s the ultimate "fast food" for people who have ditched plants entirely, provided you can get past the mental hurdle of savory liquids.
What Is This Thing, Anyway?
Stripped down to the basics, we’re talking about cooked meat, added fats, and liquid. That’s it. You aren't adding strawberries. You aren't adding kale. You are taking a protein source—usually a fatty cut like ribeye or chuck roast—and pulverizing it into a suspension.
Dr. Shawn Baker, a leading figure in the carnivore movement and author of The Carnivore Diet, has often discussed the necessity of finding ways to maintain caloric intake when appetite suppression kicks in. For athletes or those with high metabolic demands, the sheer volume of chewing required to hit 4,000 calories of beef is exhausting. The shake is a shortcut. It’s a way to bypass the satiety signals triggered by the act of mastication.
Usually, the process involves cooking a steak—mostly on the rarer side to preserve moisture and certain heat-sensitive nutrients—and then tossing it into a high-powered blender like a Vitamix or Blendtec. If you use a cheap blender, you’re going to have a bad time. You’ll end up with "meat grit." Nobody wants meat grit. A high-end motor shears the muscle fibers into a smooth, creamy consistency that, if you close your eyes, almost mimics a thick gravy or a savory bisque.
The Recipe That Doesn't Taste Like Regret
If you just throw cold steak and water into a blender, it will be wretched. You've been warned. The "pro" version of the total carnivore steak shake relies on temperature and emulsification.
Most veterans of this diet use bone broth as the base. It adds collagen, glycine, and a deeper salt profile. You want the liquid to be warm, not boiling—if it's boiling, you'll create a pressure explosion in your blender; if it's cold, the fat will congeal into wax-like pellets on the roof of your mouth. Think about the fat on a cold piece of brisket. Now imagine drinking it. Yeah, stick to warm liquids.
The fat source is the next pillar. High-quality butter, suet, or tallow are the standard go-tos. When you blend warm fat with protein and water at high speeds, you create an emulsion. It’s the same principle as making a Hollandaise sauce or a latte. The fat breaks down into tiny droplets that stay suspended, creating a mouthfeel that is surprisingly velvety. Some people add a couple of raw egg yolks for extra choline and a "custard" texture, though you’ve got to be comfortable with the salmonella risk-to-reward ratio there.
Why Would Anyone Do This?
It isn't just about being "hardcore." There are three main reasons this has gained traction in the health community.
- Digestive Rest: Some people come to carnivore because their guts are absolutely wrecked. They have Crohn’s, UC, or severe IBS. For these individuals, even the fiber-free nature of meat can be tough if they aren't producing enough stomach acid or enzymes to break down dense muscle meat. Blending acts as "mechanical predigestion." It increases the surface area of the protein, making it easier for pepsin and HCl to do their jobs.
- The "Satiety Wall": Fat is incredibly satiating. Sometimes, too satiating. If you're a 200-pound athlete trying to maintain muscle mass, you might find yourself full after only 1,200 calories. By drinking a total carnivore steak shake, you can consume a 1,000-calorie "meal" in about three minutes. It’s an efficiency play.
- Dental or Jaw Issues: It sounds niche, but for people with TMJ or those recovering from dental surgery who want to stay meat-based, this is a lifesaver.
Is it natural? Probably not. Our ancestors weren't roaming the savannas with Ninja blenders strapped to their backs. They were chewing. Chewing is actually good for jaw development and dental health. But we live in a modern world where we optimize. We hack. The steak shake is a hack for the modern carnivore who needs to get the job done.
The Psychological Barrier
Kinda weird, right? We’re conditioned to think of shakes as sweet. Vanilla, chocolate, maybe a green smoothie if you're feeling "healthy." The idea of a warm, salty, beefy shake messes with the brain’s reward centers.
✨ Don't miss: Is Coconut Oil for Personal Lube Actually Safe? What Nobody Tells You
I've talked to people who say the first sip is the hardest. Your brain screams this is wrong. But by the third sip, if you’ve salted it correctly, it just tastes like a very rich soup. If you can drink a bowl of Pho or a cup of beef bouillon, you can drink a steak shake. The difference is just the thickness.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Don't use gristle. If you blend a piece of meat with a lot of unrendered silver skin or heavy connective tissue, your blender won't be able to liquefy it. You'll end up with long, stringy fibers that get stuck in your throat. It's a choking hazard and, frankly, it's disgusting. Stick to clean muscle meat or very well-rendered fats.
Also, watch the salt. Because you're consuming the meat so much faster than you would if you were chewing, the salt hit can be intense. Start with less than you think you need. You can always add more, but you can’t un-salt a blended ribeye.
Practical Implementation
If you’re ready to try this, don't go all-in on your best wagyu. Start small.
🔗 Read more: Oral-B Floss Action Explained: Why Your Gums Might Actually Thank You
Step-by-Step "Beginner" Method:
- Cook a 8oz burger patty or small steak (medium-rare).
- Let it rest for a minute so the juices stay in the meat.
- Put it in the blender with 1 cup of warm (not hot) beef broth.
- Add 1 tablespoon of salted butter.
- Blend on high for at least 60 seconds.
Check the consistency. If it looks like a thick latte, you've done it right. If it looks like wet cat food, keep blending or add a splash more liquid.
Moving Forward with the Carnivore Lifestyle
The total carnivore steak shake is a tool, not a requirement. Most people on a meat-based diet will never need to drink their steak. They’ll be perfectly happy with a cast-iron seared New York Strip and a side of eggs. But for the outliers—the hard-gainers, the digestive-compromised, and the ultra-busy—this weird concoction is a game changer.
If you’re struggling to meet your fat macros or you’re tired of the "meat sweats" from constant chewing, try blending your next meal. It might just be the most efficient thing you do for your health this week. Just don't tell your "normal" friends what's in the thermos. They won't understand.
Next Steps for Implementation:
- Audit your current intake: If you are consistently falling short of your caloric needs or feeling fatigued on carnivore, identify if "chewing fatigue" is the bottleneck.
- Invest in equipment: Ensure you have a blender with at least 1,200 watts of power. Lower-powered units will leave the texture unpalatable.
- Temperature Control: Experiment with liquid temperatures between 100°F and 120°F to find the sweet spot for fat emulsification without cooking the "shake" into a solid mass.
- Source Quality: Use grass-fed tallow or high-quality butter to ensure the lipid profile of your shake supports your inflammatory markers rather than hindering them.