Winning in the American League East is basically a gauntlet. You’ve got the Yankees spending like crazy, the Orioles sitting on a goldmine of young talent, and the Rays somehow turning random guys off the street into Cy Young contenders. In the middle of all that, the Toronto Blue Jays rotation stands as the most expensive and most scrutinized unit in the franchise's recent history. Honestly, it’s a group that looks like a video game roster on paper, but on the field? It’s a rollercoaster.
Look at the names. Kevin Gausman. Jose Berrios. Chris Bassitt. These aren't just depth pieces; they are proven workhorses with heavy contracts. But as we saw throughout the 2024 season and heading into 2025, the margin for error has basically vanished. If Gausman’s splitter isn't diving or if Berrios hits one of those weird cold streaks where he can’t find the strike zone, the whole house of cards starts to wobble. It’s stressful.
The Gausman Factor and the Split-Finger Dilemma
Kevin Gausman is the undisputed anchor. When his splitter is "on," he’s arguably the most unhittable pitcher in baseball. He misses bats at a rate that makes Statcast data look broken. However, 2024 showed us what happens when that pitch loses just a tiny bit of its vertical drop. He becomes mortal. Extremely mortal.
Earlier in his career, Gausman struggled to find his identity. Since arriving in Toronto, he’s found it, but the heavy reliance on essentially two pitches—the high four-seam fastball and that devastating splitter—means he’s always walking a tightrope. If a team like the Red Sox or Astros decides they just aren’t going to swing at anything low, Gausman has to adjust on the fly. Sometimes he does. Sometimes he gets tagged for six runs in the third inning. It’s that volatility that keeps Jays fans up at night.
You also have to consider his age. Pitchers in their mid-30s who rely on high-velocity splitters are a rare breed. The physical toll on the elbow is real. While the training staff at Rogers Centre is top-tier, you can't help but wonder when the "stuff" starts to dip.
Why Jose Berrios is the Most Misunderstood Arm in Canada
People love to complain about Jose Berrios. They look at the contract—that massive seven-year extension—and they expect a 2.50 ERA every single season. That's just not who he is. Berrios is a "volume" guy. He’s going to take the ball every fifth day, he’s going to give you 180 to 190 innings, and he’s going to look like an Ace for 70% of those starts.
The other 30%? Well, that’s where the frustration comes in.
📖 Related: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
The Toronto Blue Jays rotation needs Berrios to be the stabilizing force, not necessarily the strikeout king. His curveball—often called "La Makina"—is his bread and butter. When he’s tunneling that pitch effectively with his sinker, he induces weak contact. In 2024, we saw him lean more into his veteran savvy rather than pure power. He’s learned to pitch to contact when he doesn't have his best stuff, which is a sign of maturity that often goes unnoticed by casual fans who just want to see triple digits on the radar gun.
The Chris Bassitt Experience: Chaos Theory in Action
If Gausman is the power and Berrios is the rhythm, Chris Bassitt is the pure, unadulterated chaos. Watching a Bassitt start is like watching a chef try to cook sixteen different meals at once. He throws what, eight different pitches? Nine? Depending on the day, he might lead with a slow curve or a biting cutter. He messes with hitters' timing, uses the PitchCom like a weapon, and generally makes everyone in the batter's box feel uncomfortable.
But here’s the catch.
Bassitt is a high-variance pitcher. Because he relies so much on "tricking" hitters and nibbling at the edges of the zone, he can run into high pitch counts early. It’s not uncommon to see him at 80 pitches by the end of the fourth inning. For a bullpen that has struggled with depth, this is a nightmare. The Jays need him to go deep into games, but his style often dictates a shorter outing. It's a trade-off. You get the veteran leadership and the "dog" mentality, but you also get the stress of a tightrope walk every Tuesday night.
The Problem With Starting Depth
Behind the big three, things get... murky. Bowden Francis emerged as a legitimate savior in late 2024, showing flashes of being a true mid-rotation starter. His four-seam fastball has surprising life, and his poise under pressure was one of the few bright spots in a season that felt like a bit of a letdown.
But can you trust him for 30 starts?
👉 See also: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
History says be cautious. We’ve seen "flash in the pan" starters before. Think back to guys like Ricky Romero—huge potential, one All-Star year, then the wheels fell off. Now, Francis isn't Romero, but the Toronto Blue Jays rotation is dangerously thin if he regresses.
Then there’s the Yariel Rodriguez experiment. Coming over from NPB in Japan, the transition to a MLB schedule is brutal. The five-day rotation is different than the once-a-week Japanese schedule. Rodriguez has the raw stuff—high spin rates, a nasty slider—but his stamina is a massive question mark. Is he a starter? Is he an opener? The Jays seem to want him to be a starter, but the results have been mixed.
The Alek Manoah Elephant in the Room
We have to talk about Alek Manoah. You can't analyze the Blue Jays pitching staff without mentioning the guy who was a Cy Young finalist just a couple of years ago. His fall from grace was staggering. From the opening day starter to being sent down to the Florida Complex League? That’s the stuff of sports movies, and not the happy kind.
Manoah’s journey back has been plagued by injuries and, frankly, a crisis of confidence. When he’s right, he’s a bully on the mound. He uses his size and his sweeping slider to intimidate. When he’s wrong, he’s walking the lead-off hitter and getting frustrated with the umpire. With his recent UCL surgery, the timeline for his return is hazy. The Jays cannot, under any circumstances, count on him to be a savior in the short term. Anything they get from Manoah at this point should be treated as a "found money" bonus.
Strategic Shift: The Move Away From Extreme Velocity
One thing people get wrong about the Jays' philosophy is that they are obsessed with "gas." They aren't. Pete Walker, the long-time pitching coach, has actually leaned into a "movement and location" strategy. Look at the acquisition of guys like Bassitt or the way they’ve helped Berrios refine his sinker.
The Rogers Centre plays small. It’s a hitter's park, especially with the new dimensions and the way the turf carries the ball. If you are a fly-ball pitcher who misses middle-in, you’re going to give up home runs. Lots of them. The rotation has had to adapt by focusing on ground ball rates.
✨ Don't miss: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
- Kevin Gausman: Focuses on the "shadow zone" at the bottom of the plate.
- Chris Bassitt: Uses the sinker to jam right-handed hitters.
- Bowden Francis: Relies on late life to get pop-ups rather than line drives.
This shift is necessary because the AL East is filled with ballparks that punish mistakes. Yankee Stadium’s short porch and Fenway’s Green Monster don't care about your 98-mph fastball if it has no movement.
Realities of the 2025 Outlook
The window for this core is closing. That’s not being dramatic; it’s just looking at the contracts. Vlad Jr. and Bo Bichette are getting more expensive. The pitching staff is aging. If the Toronto Blue Jays rotation doesn't finish in the top five in the American League for ERA, this team isn't making the playoffs. The offense is too inconsistent to carry a struggling staff.
What most fans overlook is the impact of the "pitch clock" on this specific group. Bassitt and Gausman are both "feel" pitchers. They like to control the tempo. The 2024 season was a massive adjustment period for them. By now, they should have the rhythm down, but any rule changes regarding the clock or the size of the bases continue to disproportionately affect veteran pitchers who have a decade of muscle memory to unlearn.
Actionable Insights for Following the Jays Rotation
If you're trying to figure out if the Jays are going to win on any given night, stop looking at the overall ERA. That’s a "lazy" stat. Instead, look at these specific indicators:
- Gausman’s Splitter Usage: If he’s throwing it more than 35% of the time, he’s feeling confident. If he drops below 20%, it means he can't find the grip, and he’s going to get hurt.
- First-Pitch Strikes: This is huge for Berrios. When he falls behind 1-0, his opponent's OPS skyrockets. He’s a "front-runner" pitcher—he needs to be ahead to use his sweepy breaking ball.
- The "Third Time Through" Penalty: Watch the sixth inning. The Jays' front office is notoriously quick to pull starters. If the manager is leaving Gausman or Bassitt in for the third time through the order, it means the bullpen is gassed, which usually signals trouble for the rest of the series.
- Infield Defense Alignment: The Jays rotation relies on the defense. If Isiah Kiner-Falefa or the revolving door at second base is having an "off" day, the pitchers suffer more than most because they are contact-oriented.
The Blue Jays don't need a miracle; they need health. It sounds like a cliché, but when you have three guys over the age of 32 in your top three spots, the training table is just as important as the bullpen.
Keep an eye on the waiver wire and the trade deadline. The Jays are almost certainly going to look for a "swingman"—someone like a Ross Stripling type—who can jump into the rotation if Rodriguez or Francis hits a wall. Without that insurance policy, one oblique strain could end the season by July.
To really understand where this team is going, you have to look past the box score. Watch the body language of the starters in the dugout. Watch how they interact with Pete Walker. This is a veteran group that knows the pressure is on. There are no more "rebuilding" years left for this iteration of the Blue Jays. It’s either a deep October run or a massive teardown.
The talent is there. The money has been spent. Now, the arms just have to hold up.