You’ve seen the memes. You’ve probably had the argument at a dinner party or while staying at a picky relative's house. It’s the kind of low-stakes domestic dispute that defines marriages. Does the paper hang over the top, or does it tuck under against the wall? Honestly, people get surprisingly heated about it. But there is an objective, documented answer sitting in the archives of the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
Seth Wheeler. That’s the name you need to know.
Back in 1891, Wheeler—who lived in Albany, New York, and ran the Albany Perforated Wrapping Paper Company—patented a "Wrapping or toilet paper roll." This wasn't some abstract concept. It was a practical solution to a messy problem. Before Wheeler’s innovations, people were basically using catalogs, old newspapers, or loose sheets. It was chaotic.
What the 1891 Toilet Paper Roll Patent Actually Shows
If you look at the original diagrams for US Patent No. 459,516, the answer is staring you in the face. The illustration clearly depicts the paper hanging over the roll.
There's no ambiguity here. Wheeler’s drawing shows the leading edge of the perforated sheet draped over the front, away from the wall. Why? Because it’s functional. The whole point of his design was to make it easy to tear off exactly what you needed without the rest of the roll unspooling onto the floor.
It’s about friction. When the paper hangs over, it's easier to grab. You aren't hunting for the edge against a cold, tiled bathroom wall. You aren't accidentally dragging your knuckles across the drywall. It’s right there. Accessible. Ready.
Wheeler was a bit of a visionary in the world of paper products. He didn't just invent the roll; he pioneered the perforation. Before his work, toilet paper was often sold in flat bundles of sheets. In 1871, he patented the idea of perforated wrapping paper, and by the 1880s, he was applying that logic to the bathroom. His 1891 patent was the refinement of an idea he'd been tinkering with for twenty years. He wanted to reduce waste. He literally wrote in his patent application that his goal was to prevent "wasteful use" of paper.
📖 Related: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
The Under Argument and Why It Failed the Patent Test
Now, some people swear by the "under" method. They usually cite two main reasons: pets and aesthetics. If you have a cat that likes to bat at the roll, an "over" orientation means the cat will eventually unroll the entire thing into a mountain of white fluff. If it’s "under," the cat just spins the roll endlessly without actually dispensing paper. Valid? Sure. From a feline-management perspective.
But from a design perspective, "under" is a failure.
When the paper is tucked against the wall, it's harder to find the seam. In a dark bathroom or for someone with limited mobility, that extra second of searching is a design flaw. Furthermore, Wheeler’s specific perforation tech relied on the tension created by pulling the paper away from the roll. The "over" position provides the most natural angle for that snap.
The Albany Perforated Wrapping Paper Company
Seth Wheeler wasn't just a tinkerer; he was a businessman. The Albany Perforated Wrapping Paper Company was a powerhouse of 19th-century hygiene. At the time, "sanitary" paper was a relatively new luxury. You have to remember that for most of human history, we used whatever was lying around—leaves, corn cobs, wool, or the infamous "xylospongium" (a sponge on a stick) used by the Romans.
By the late 1800s, the Victorian obsession with cleanliness and plumbing was peaking. Wheeler’s patent wasn’t just about the roll; it was about the commercialization of privacy. He saw that people would pay for convenience.
His patents covered everything from the machinery to make the paper to the specific ways the rolls were wound. He even held patents for ornamental patterns on the paper. He understood that the bathroom was becoming a place of personal expression, even back then.
👉 See also: 100 Biggest Cities in the US: Why the Map You Know is Wrong
Why Do We Still Care About a Century-Old Patent?
It's a weirdly persistent bit of trivia. I think it's because it offers a "gotcha" moment in a world where everything feels subjective. We live in an era of "your truth" and "my truth," but the toilet paper roll patent is a hard, physical receipt. It’s a blueprint. It’s one of the few things where we can point to a piece of paper from 1891 and say, "See? This is how it was intended."
It also speaks to the nature of "invisible" design. We use this product every single day. Most of us don't think about the engineering behind the perforation or the tensile strength of the two-ply. We only notice it when it breaks or when the roll is empty. Wheeler’s patent is a reminder that even the most mundane objects in our lives were once revolutionary ideas that someone had to fight for.
Beyond the Over/Under: Other Insights from the Patent
Wheeler’s work wasn't just about the direction of the hang. He was obsessed with the "attachment" of the sheets. In his patent, he describes how the sheets are held together by "small points" of unperforated paper.
This was a massive leap forward.
Before this, you either had to cut the paper or tear it clumsily. Wheeler’s "points" allowed for a clean break. If you’ve ever tried to tear a cheap roll of paper and ended up with a long, jagged spiral instead of a square, you’ve experienced the failure of Wheeler’s original vision. Quality control matters.
He also experimented with different types of cores. Early rolls didn't always have the cardboard tube we’re used to. Some were solid; some were designed to fit on specific, proprietary spindles that his company also sold. It was an early version of the "razor and blade" business model—sell the dispenser, and you’ve got a customer for the paper for life.
✨ Don't miss: Cooper City FL Zip Codes: What Moving Here Is Actually Like
The Great Hygiene Shift
We should also talk about the health aspect. In the late 19th century, there was a lot of misinformation about what caused illnesses. Some companies marketed their "medicated" paper as a cure for various ailments. Wheeler’s company mostly focused on the mechanical benefits, but the rise of his patent coincided with a broader cultural shift toward germ theory.
The idea that you could have a clean, untouched roll of paper in your home was a major selling point. It was viewed as more "civilized" than the alternative. This is likely why the "over" position became the default for high-end hotels. It displays the paper prominently, showing the guest that it's fresh, clean, and hasn't been handled. The "hospitality fold"—where the first sheet is folded into a triangle—is only possible if the paper is in the "over" position.
Technical Reality vs. Personal Habit
Despite the patent, habit usually wins. If you grew up in a house that did it one way, you’re probably going to do it that way for the rest of your life.
But if you’re looking for the "correct" way to do it—the way the inventor, the patent office, and the laws of physics intended—it’s over. Always over.
- Friction and Tension: Pulling from the top allows the perforation to catch correctly against the weight of the roll.
- Hygiene: "Over" prevents the paper from brushing against potentially dirty walls or cabinets.
- Visibility: You can easily see the end of the roll, which is helpful in low-light situations.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Home
If you want to live your life according to the 1891 standard of excellence, here is how you optimize your bathroom setup:
- Check the Hang: Ensure your rolls are placed in the "over" position to honor Seth Wheeler’s original patent diagram.
- Inspect the Perforation: If your paper is tearing poorly, it’s likely a manufacturing defect where the "attachment points" described in the patent are too strong or too weak.
- Consider the Dispenser: Wheeler’s patent worked best with a spindle that allowed for slight resistance. If your roll spins too freely, you’ll end up with the waste he was trying to prevent.
- Educate the Household: The next time someone flips the roll, you don't have to be "annoying." You’re just being a "historical preservationist."
Seth Wheeler’s patent is more than just a piece of trivia. It’s a testament to the fact that even the smallest details of our daily lives have a history, an inventor, and a "right" way to function. Whether you choose to follow it is up to you, but at least now you know the truth.