It’s frustrating. You’re sitting there, staring at a grid of nine squares, and you realize there is absolutely nowhere left to go. Every single path is blocked. Your friend smirks. You sigh. It’s a tic tac toe tie, otherwise known as a "Cat's Game." This happens because, frankly, the game is broken.
Tic tac toe is what mathematicians call a "zero-sum perfect information game." That sounds fancy, but it basically means that if both players know what they are doing, the outcome is predetermined. Unlike poker, there is no luck. Unlike chess, the complexity is so low that a human brain—or a basic calculator from 1985—can "solve" it completely. If you and your opponent play optimally, you will tie. Every single time.
It’s actually a bit of a tragedy for such a classic pastime.
Why the Tic Tac Toe Tie is Mathematically Inevitable
The game has 255,168 possible game tree variations. That seems like a lot until you realize that many of those are just rotations or reflections of the same board state. Once you strip away the duplicates, there are only 765 essentially different positions. Out of those, a massive chunk lead directly to a draw.
Computers figured this out decades ago. In fact, tic tac toe was one of the first games ever digitized. In 1952, Sandy Douglas wrote OXO for the EDSAC computer at the University of Cambridge. It was one of the earliest examples of artificial intelligence in gaming. The computer played perfectly. If you played it, you’d get a tic tac toe tie or you’d lose. You never won.
The game is technically "solved."
Solving a game means we know the exact outcome of every possible move from the start. In tic tac toe, the "game value" is a draw. This is different from games like Connect Four, which was solved by James Allen and Victor Allis in 1988; they proved that the first player can always win if they play perfectly. In our little 3x3 grid, though, the second player has enough defensive power to force a stalemate regardless of what the first player tries.
The Myth of the "Best" Starting Move
Most people think the center square is the holy grail. It’s not. Well, it's good, but it's not the only way to play. If you start in the center, you reduce your opponent's winning options immediately. However, seasoned players often prefer the corners.
Why the corner? Because it sets traps.
If I take the top-left corner and you don't take the center, I’ve basically already won. But if we both play the "book" moves, we’re heading straight for a tic tac toe tie. The center is the safest, but the corner is the most aggressive. If you're playing against someone who actually knows the patterns, you're just performing a choreographed dance that ends in a dead heat.
Why Do We Call It a Cat’s Game?
Nobody is 100% sure why a draw is called a "Cat’s Game." It’s one of those weird linguistic leftovers.
One popular theory is that it comes from the idea of a cat chasing its tail. No matter how much effort it puts in, it never actually catches anything. It’s a loop. Another theory suggests it relates to "cat's cradle," the string game, where everything gets tangled and stuck.
Honestly, it doesn’t really matter where the name came from. What matters is the feeling of looking at that final grid—five Xs, four Os—and seeing that "Cat" written across the side of the page. It's the ultimate symbol of a wasted five minutes.
How to Force a Tie (Or a Win Against a Novice)
If you want to avoid losing, you have to follow a specific hierarchy of moves. It’s a set of rules your brain can run like a script.
- Win: If you have two in a row, place the third.
- Block: If your opponent has two in a row, block them.
- Fork: Create a situation where you have two ways to win.
- Block an opponent’s fork: Don't let them get that double-threat.
- Center: Take the middle if it’s open.
- Opposite corner: If the opponent is in a corner, take the opposite one.
- Empty corner: Take any corner.
- Empty side: Take any middle square on the edges.
If both players follow this list, a tic tac toe tie is the only possible result. It’s why children love the game but adults find it mind-numbing after three rounds. Children are still learning the "script." Adults have it hard-coded into their skulls.
The Psychology of the Draw
There is something deeply human about the way we react to a tie. In sports like soccer, a draw can feel like a hard-fought battle. In tic tac toe, it feels like a glitch in the matrix.
Psychologists often use simple games to study "theory of mind." This is the ability to understand that another person has different knowledge and intentions than you do. A toddler doesn't understand that you are trying to block them; they only see their own path to three-in-a-row. As we age, we develop the ability to see the board through the opponent's eyes.
Once both players possess a fully developed theory of mind and understand the basic geometry of the grid, the tic tac toe tie becomes the standard. The "fun" of the game actually dies when your brain gets too good at it.
Variations That Actually Make It Interesting
If you’re sick of the constant stalemates, people have invented ways to break the game.
- Ultimate Tic Tac Toe: This is a 9x9 board made of nine smaller tic tac toe boards. To win a square on the big board, you have to win the small board. But here’s the kicker: your move determines which small board your opponent has to play in next. It’s exponentially more complex and almost never ends in a tie.
- Wild Tic Tac Toe: Players can choose to place either an X or an O on any turn. The first person to complete a line of three wins, regardless of who placed which marks.
- 3D Tic Tac Toe: Played on a 4x4x4 cube. This version is so complex that a tic tac toe tie is actually quite rare compared to the 2D version.
The End of the Line
The tic tac toe tie isn't a failure of the players; it's a testament to the game's simplicity. It is a closed system. Once you see the patterns, the magic trick is ruined. You realize that you aren't really playing a game of strategy so much as you are participating in a mathematical certainty.
If you find yourself stuck in a loop of draws, the only real move is to change the parameters. Stop playing on a 3x3 grid. Move to a larger board, or try a game like Gomoku (Five in a Row), which uses a 15x15 or 19x19 board. There, the complexity is high enough that human error remains a factor, and a tie is much harder to force.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Match:
- Always take a corner if the center is gone. It maximizes your "branching" winning paths.
- If you go second and the opponent takes a corner, you MUST take the center. Any other move is a guaranteed loss if they know the fork strategy.
- Use the "Cat's Game" as a teaching moment. It’s the easiest way to explain the concept of a "solved game" or "game theory" to kids or students.
- Recognize the trap. If your opponent takes two non-opposite corners (like top-left and bottom-right) and you have the center, don't take a corner. Take an edge. If you take a corner, you’re walking into a fork.
The grid is small, but the logic is absolute. Once you've mastered the stalemate, you've officially graduated from the game. Use that knowledge to move on to something where your brain actually has room to breathe.
✨ Don't miss: Most Valuable Charizard Card: Why the 1999 First Edition Still Rules the Market
Next Steps to Improve Your Gaming Logic:
- Study the "Fork" Strategy: Practice identifying the "L-shape" setups that force a win by creating two threats simultaneously.
- Analyze Your Losses: If you didn't get a tic tac toe tie, you made a specific, identifiable mistake in the hierarchy of moves listed above. Go back and find the exact turn where you deviated from the defensive script.
- Explore Game Theory: Look into "Minimax algorithms." This is how computers decide their moves in games like this by minimizing the possible loss for a worst-case scenario. It’s the foundation of modern AI.