People don't talk about the "modern western" enough without bringing up the same three or four movies. You know the ones. But honestly, The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada is the one that actually sticks to your ribs. It’s a 2005 film that feels like it was dragged through the Texas dirt and washed in tequila. Directed by Tommy Lee Jones—his first big feature behind the camera—and written by Guillermo Arriaga, it’s a weird, beautiful, and sometimes gross meditation on what it means to keep a promise.
Most people see a "border movie" and expect a political lecture. This isn't that. It’s a odyssey. It’s basically about a ranch foreman named Pete Perkins (Jones) who discovers his best friend, a Mexican vaquero named Melquiades, has been killed and dumped in a shallow grave. When the law refuses to care, Pete takes matters into his own hands. He kidnaps the guy who did it—a jumpy Border Patrol agent—and forces him to dig up the body. Then they ride.
The Real Story Behind the Film
You might not know this, but the movie wasn't just dreamed up over a whiskey at a Hollywood bar. It was actually inspired by a real-life tragedy from 1997. An 18-year-old high school student named Esequiel Hernández Jr. was herding goats in Redford, Texas. He was carrying a .22 rifle to ward off coyotes. A team of camouflaged U.S. Marines, who were out on a secret anti-drug mission, saw him. They tracked him for twenty minutes. Then they shot him dead.
The military claimed self-defense, but the local community was devastated and furious. No one was ever charged. Tommy Lee Jones, who actually lives in the region and runs a ranch, was deeply affected by this. He didn't want to make a documentary, though he later narrated one called The Ballad of Esequiel Hernández. Instead, he used that sense of injustice to fuel the narrative of Melquiades Estrada. It gives the film a weight that you just can't fake with a green screen.
✨ Don't miss: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the Non-Linear Structure Actually Works
Guillermo Arriaga is the king of the "shuffled deck" screenplay. He did Amores Perros, 21 Grams, and Babel. If you've seen those, you know he loves to jump around in time. In this film, the "three burials" aren't just a sequence; they're a way of peeling back the layers of who Melquiades was.
- The First Burial: A quick, dirty hole in the ground by the killer, Mike Norton (Barry Pepper). It’s an act of cowardice.
- The Second Burial: A sterile, nameless pauper's grave in a local cemetery. It’s an act of indifference by the state.
- The Third Burial: The goal. The promised land.
The way the film cuts back and forth between Pete and Mel’s friendship and the grim reality of the present makes you feel the loss more acutely. You aren't just told they were friends; you see the quiet moments on the ranch. It makes the subsequent kidnapping of the Border Patrol agent feel less like a crime and more like a necessary ritual.
The Aesthetic of the Border
Let’s talk about how this movie looks. It was shot by Chris Menges, a legendary cinematographer who won Oscars for The Killing Fields and The Mission. He didn't go for the "postcard" version of the West. No orange-filtered sunsets here. Instead, he captures the "fierce beauty" of the Chihuahua Desert. It’s dry. It’s dusty. You can almost feel the grit in your teeth while watching.
🔗 Read more: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
There’s a specific scene where they’re traveling with the body. Because it’s hot, the corpse is... well, it’s decomposing. Pete tries to preserve it with antifreeze. It’s a macabre, grotesque detail that feels totally real for a guy like Pete. He isn't a saint; he's a rancher who understands biology. The film treats the decaying body not as a horror prop, but as a passenger. It’s a physical manifestation of a debt that needs to be paid.
Key Cast and Their Impact
The performances are what keep this from becoming a weird B-movie.
- Tommy Lee Jones (Pete Perkins): He won Best Actor at Cannes for this, and it’s arguably his best work. He’s craggy and stubborn, but there’s a strange tenderness there.
- Barry Pepper (Mike Norton): He plays the "villain," but the movie doesn't make him a cartoon. He’s a bored, insecure guy who made a horrific mistake and is now being forced into a brutal education on human empathy.
- Melissa Leo (Rachel): She plays a waitress at the local diner. Her role shows the loneliness of the border towns—the boredom that drives people to do things just to feel alive.
- Julio César Cedillo (Melquiades): Even though he spends much of the movie as a corpse, his presence in the flashbacks is the soul of the film.
What People Get Wrong About the Ending
Some critics at the time complained the ending was too "mystical" or "cloudy." Honestly, I think they missed the point. The film isn't about the destination—a place called Jimenez that might not even exist the way Melquiades described it. It’s about the transformation of the killer.
💡 You might also like: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
By the time they reach the end of their journey, Mike Norton is a broken man. But in that brokenness, he finally sees the humanity of the person he killed. It’s a redemption story, but it’s a "hard-earned" one. No one gets off easy. Pete doesn't get his friend back. Mike doesn't get to go back to his old life.
Actionable Insights for Cinephiles
If you haven't seen it, or if it's been twenty years since you did, here is how to approach it for the best experience:
- Watch the Cinematography: Pay attention to how Menges uses wide shots to make the characters look tiny against the landscape. It emphasizes that the land doesn't care about their laws or their borders.
- Compare to Lonesome Dove: There are huge parallels here. Tommy Lee Jones played Woodrow Call in the Lonesome Dove miniseries, a man who also took a long journey to bury a friend. This film is like a darker, modern "spiritual sequel" to that character's journey.
- Look for the Symbolism: Notice the use of the Polaroid. It represents the "idealized" version of life that Melquiades wanted Pete to believe in.
- Check the Awards: Remember that this swept at Cannes in 2005 (Best Actor and Best Screenplay). It’s a rare example of an American Western being fully embraced by the high-brow European film community.
The film is currently available on various streaming platforms like Amazon Prime and Apple TV for rent or purchase. If you’re a fan of No Country for Old Men or Hell or High Water, this is the essential "third pillar" of that modern Texan trilogy you need to finish. It’s a story that proves a man's word still carries weight, even when the world around him has stopped caring.
To dive deeper into the themes of this film, your next step should be to look up the 2008 documentary The Ballad of Esequiel Hernández. It provides the factual foundation for the "senseless violence" depicted in the movie and will give you a much darker perspective on the "mistake" made by the Border Patrol agent in the film.