It was 1964. Smokey Robinson was sitting at a piano, probably fiddling with a melody that felt a bit lighter than the heavy soul stompers coming out of Detroit at the time. He had this group, The Temptations, who were—honestly—struggling. They were known around the Hitsville U.S.A. offices as the "hitless Temptations." Hard to imagine now, right? But before The Temptations The Way You Do the Things You Do hit the airwaves, they had a string of singles that just didn't go anywhere. They had the moves. They had the style. They just didn't have the song.
Then Smokey stepped in.
Most people think Motown was this instant hit machine where Berry Gordy just pressed a button and "My Girl" popped out. It wasn't like that. It was trial and error. It was late nights. It was Eddie Kendricks pushing his falsetto until it felt like silk. When they finally recorded this track in January 1964, nobody knew it would become the blueprint for the "Motown Sound." It’s a song built on a foundation of "what ifs" and "maybe this works."
And boy, did it work.
The Smokey Robinson Magic Touch
Smokey Robinson wasn’t just a songwriter; he was a poet who happened to understand the teenage heart better than almost anyone in history. He wrote lyrics that were basically a series of clever, almost sugary compliments. You’ve got the "candle" and the "handle," the "school" and the "rule." It sounds simple, maybe even a little corny if you read it on paper without the music. But when you layer those harmonies over that bouncing rhythm, it becomes something else entirely.
The song was a sharp pivot.
Earlier Temptations tracks like "The Further You Look, the Less You See" were fine, but they lacked that infectious, rhythmic "snap" that defined the mid-60s. Smokey saw something in Eddie Kendricks' voice. He knew Eddie could carry a lead that felt vulnerable yet cool. It’s that specific contrast—the high, sweet tenor against the driving, sophisticated arrangement—that made the song a breakthrough.
Why the Groove Matters More Than the Lyrics
If you break down the musicology of The Temptations The Way You Do the Things You Do, you start to see why it stuck. It’s not just a pop song. It’s a rhythmic masterclass. The Funk Brothers, Motown’s legendary (and often uncredited) house band, brought a swing to this track that was different from the bluesier R&B of the 50s.
👉 See also: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
Listen to the snare.
It’s crisp. It’s right on the beat, but it has this tiny bit of "air" around it. James Jamerson’s bassline isn't doing anything overly complex here—he’d get much wilder later on "What’s Going On"—but his pocket is deep. He provides the floor for the group to dance on. And The Temptations did dance. Their choreography, led largely by Cholly Atkins, was built to match this specific tempo. You can’t do a "Temptation Walk" to a song that doesn't have this exact BPM.
Breaking the "Hitless" Curse
The pressure was on. By the time 1964 rolled around, the group had been at it for a few years with very little to show for it in terms of chart positions. David Ruffin hadn't even taken a lead vocal yet; he was still the new guy, having joined just before this session to replace Elbridge Bryant.
The lineup was finally set:
- Eddie Kendricks (The high flying falsetto)
- Paul Williams (The soul and the grit)
- Melvin Franklin (The basement-deep bass)
- Otis Williams (The glue/founder)
- David Ruffin (The future superstar)
When the song hit #11 on the Billboard Hot 100 and #1 on the R&B charts, everything changed. It wasn't just a win for the guys; it was a proof of concept for Motown. It proved that Smokey could produce groups other than The Miracles and get them into the Top 20. It proved that a vocal group could be sophisticated and "pop" without losing their soul credentials.
The Anatomy of a Classic
The song starts with that iconic horn riff. It’s an invitation.
"You got a smile so bright..."
✨ Don't miss: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
Eddie’s delivery is effortless. There’s no strain. One of the most common mistakes modern singers make when covering this song is trying to "over-sing" it. They add too many runs or try to make it too powerful. But the original works because it’s conversational. It’s a guy talking to a girl, using these silly, charming metaphors to make her laugh.
The backing vocals are just as important. Paul, Melvin, Otis, and David aren't just "ooh-ing" in the background. They are providing a percussive texture. When they hit those "shoo-be-doo-wops," they are acting like an extension of the drum kit. It’s a tight, cohesive unit. You can hear the years of singing on Detroit street corners in that blend.
A Legacy of Covers and Reimagining
You can tell a song is a foundational text of American music by who tries to sing it after the original. Everyone from Rita Coolidge to Hall & Oates has taken a crack at it. Even The Grateful Dead played it live. Why? Because the structure is bulletproof.
- The 1985 Version: Daryl Hall and John Oates performed it at the Apollo with David Ruffin and Eddie Kendricks. It was a massive moment that introduced the song to a whole new generation of MTV viewers.
- The UB40 Version: They took it to the Top 10 again in 1990 with a reggae-lite swing. It worked because the melody is so strong it can survive almost any genre shift.
But nothing touches the 1964 original. There is a "warmth" in the analog recording at Hitsville—the "Snake Pit" studio—that can't be replicated. The room was tiny. The ceiling was low. The musicians were cramped. That physical closeness translated into the sound. You can hear the room. You can hear the energy.
What Most People Get Wrong
People often lump all Temptations hits together into one big "Greatest Hits" blur. They think "My Girl" was the start. It wasn't. Without the success of The Temptations The Way You Do the Things You Do, the group might have been dropped. Motown was a business, and Berry Gordy didn't keep acts around forever if they didn't sell records.
This song gave them the leverage to experiment. It gave Smokey the "green light" to keep writing for them. It also established Eddie Kendricks as a premier lead singer, which created a fascinating internal dynamic once David Ruffin started taking leads a year later.
The song also isn't just "cute." Underneath the lyrics about "being a book," there’s a sophisticated harmonic progression. It’s jazz-influenced pop. The bridge doesn't just go where you expect it to; it lifts the energy right before dropping back into that infectious chorus. It's songwriting at its most efficient. No fat. No wasted notes. Just two minutes and forty seconds of perfection.
🔗 Read more: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
Actionable Insights for Music Lovers and Creators
If you’re a songwriter, a singer, or just someone who wants to appreciate the craft more, there’s a lot to learn from this specific moment in Motown history.
Study the "Less is More" Approach
Eddie Kendricks doesn't yell. He doesn't growl. He stays in his pocket and lets the melody do the heavy lifting. If you’re performing or creating, remember that clarity often beats power.
Focus on the "Hook" Early
That opening horn line and the first lyric happen within seconds. In the streaming age, this is more relevant than ever. You have to grab the listener immediately. The Temptations knew this sixty years ago.
The Power of Collaboration
This song was the result of the perfect storm: Smokey’s writing, the Funk Brothers' playing, and the group’s chemistry. Don't try to do everything yourself. Find the "Smokey" to your "Temptations."
Respect the Rhythm
The song works because you can't help but tap your foot. If the groove isn't right, the best lyrics in the world won't save the track. Build your foundation first.
Embrace the Simplicity of Language
You don't need "big" words to express big feelings. Using everyday objects (candles, brooms, books) as metaphors makes the song relatable to everyone. It’s universal because it’s simple.
The next time this song comes on the radio or pops up on a shuffle, don't just treat it as "oldies" background noise. Listen to the way the bass interacts with the vocals. Notice how the harmonies swell in the second verse. It’s a masterclass in production that still holds up under the microscope of 2026 audio standards. It’s the sound of a group finding their voice and a label finding its soul.