New York doesn't need another expensive sushi counter. Seriously. We have more Michelin stars and $600 omakase menus than most people have rent money. But when word got out that Keiji Nakazawa was finally opening Sushi Sho New York, the city’s obsession shifted. This isn't just another high-end spot in a Midtown hotel. It’s a seismic event for anyone who actually cares about the history of vinegar, fish maturation, and the sheer audacity of a chef who refuses to follow the "fresh is best" mantra that dominates the West.
Nakazawa-san is a legend. That word gets thrown around a lot, but in the world of Edomae sushi, he’s basically the architect of the modern revival. Most people think sushi is about getting fish off a boat and onto a rice ball as fast as possible. Nakazawa thinks that's boring. He’s spent decades perfecting su-jime (vinegar curing), shio-jime (salt curing), and aging techniques that turn a piece of fish into something completely unrecognizable—in a good way.
What Sushi Sho New York gets right about the Edomae tradition
Traditional Edomae sushi wasn't a luxury. It was street food in old Tokyo (Edo). Because they didn't have refrigerators in the 1800s, chefs had to get creative to keep fish from rotting. They marinated it in soy sauce, simmered it, or buried it in salt and vinegar. Nakazawa-san takes these ancient survival tactics and turns them into high art. At Sushi Sho New York, located inside the Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad, you aren't just eating dinner; you're eating a history lesson that tastes like umami.
The space itself is intimate. Ten seats. That’s it. You're sitting at a counter made of ancient cypress wood, watching a master work. But here’s the thing: it’s not stiff. A lot of these high-end "temples" of sushi feel like you’re at a funeral. You’re afraid to cough. Sushi Sho New York feels more like a workshop. Nakazawa is known for his playful approach, often alternating between different types of rice—red vinegar (akazu) for richer fish and white vinegar for lighter bites. This constant shifting keeps your palate from getting bored.
The dual-rice strategy you won't find elsewhere
Most omakase spots pick a rice style and stick to it for the whole night. Not here. Nakazawa-san uses two distinct types of shari (sushi rice).
One is seasoned with a potent, dark red vinegar that has been aged for years. It’s funky. It’s bold. It stands up to the fatty tuna and the oily mackerel. Then, he’ll switch to a lighter, cleaner white vinegar rice for something delicate like squid or sea bream. It sounds like a small detail, but it changes everything. It’s the difference between a band playing one note for two hours versus a full symphony.
Why the $400+ price tag actually makes sense
Look, nobody likes spending half a paycheck on a meal. But the logistics of Sushi Sho New York are kind of insane. Nakazawa-san isn't just buying whatever is at the Fulton Fish Market. He’s sourcing specific species from Japan and then—this is the crucial part—he’s waiting.
👉 See also: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
He might age a piece of otoro (fatty tuna) for two weeks. He might cure gizzard shad (kohada) until the skin reaches a specific texture that balances the acidity of the rice. This requires a level of labor and food-cost risk that most restaurants wouldn't touch with a ten-foot pole. If you age fish incorrectly, it's garbage. You’re paying for the expertise of a man who knows exactly when a piece of fish is at its absolute peak of flavor, which is almost never when it’s "fresh."
Honestly, the "fresh" obsession is a bit of a misconception. Fresh fish often has a snappy texture but very little flavor. Aging breaks down the proteins and develops those deep, savory notes that make your eyes roll back in your head. That's what you're paying for at Sushi Sho New York.
The "Sho" Style: Small bites and big risks
If you've been to Sushi Sho in Honolulu or the original in Tokyo, you know the rhythm. It’s fast-paced. Instead of 15 large pieces of nigiri, you might get 30 or 40 small "tsumami" (appetizers) and nigiri interspersed throughout the night. It’s chaotic in the best way possible. One minute you’re eating a warm piece of monkfish liver, and the next, you’re having a tiny sliver of pickled ginger to cleanse the palate before a cold piece of marinated clam.
- The Signature Monkfish Liver: Usually served with a bit of narazuke (pickled melon), it's basically the foie gras of the sea.
- The Aged Tuna: This is Nakazawa’s calling card. It’s deep purple, incredibly soft, and tastes more like steak than fish.
- The Rice Variety: Pay attention to the temperature. He adjusts the rice temp based on the fish. It’s obsessive.
Navigating the hype and the reservation struggle
Getting a seat at Sushi Sho New York is, frankly, a nightmare. Since it opened, the reservation books have been slammed. This isn't a place where you can just walk in on a Tuesday night. You need to be on the portal the second the slots open, or you need to know someone who knows someone.
Is it worth the stress? If you’re a casual sushi fan who just wants a spicy tuna roll, absolutely not. You’ll be confused by the fermented flavors and the lack of "usual" toppings. But if you’ve ever wondered why some people treat sushi like a religious experience, this is where you go to find out. It’s the closest thing to a Tokyo high-end experience you can get without a twelve-hour flight.
There’s also the matter of the "New York" influence. While Nakazawa is a traditionalist, he isn't a statue. He’s been known to incorporate local ingredients where they make sense. But don't expect a "NoMad Roll." Everything is filtered through the lens of Edomae technique.
✨ Don't miss: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
A note on the atmosphere
The Ritz-Carlton NoMad is a fancy setting, but the restaurant itself feels tucked away, almost like a secret. The lighting is low, the service is precise but not overbearing, and the focus remains entirely on the stage—the counter. You'll see the chefs using traditional wooden boxes to store the fish, which helps regulate humidity far better than plastic containers ever could.
Actionable insights for your visit
If you manage to snag a seat, don't waste the opportunity. Here is how to actually enjoy Sushi Sho New York without feeling like a tourist:
Don't use soy sauce. The chef has already seasoned every single piece. Adding more is basically telling him he did it wrong. It ruins the balance of the salt and acid he’s spent days preparing.
Eat with your hands. While chopsticks are fine, eating nigiri with your fingers is traditional and keeps the rice from falling apart. The rice is packed loosely to allow air to circulate, making it melt in your mouth. Chopsticks can be too aggressive.
Ask about the aging. The staff and Nakazawa-san himself (if he’s behind the counter that night) love to talk about the process. Ask how long the tuna was aged or what kind of vinegar is in the rice. It changes the way you taste the food when you understand the effort behind it.
Cleanse your palate. The pickled ginger (gari) isn't a side dish; it's a tool. Use it between different types of fish to reset your taste buds so the flavors don't bleed into each other.
🔗 Read more: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
Budget for sake. The drink list is curated to match the high acidity of the rice. Let the sommelier guide you. A dry, crisp sake can cut through the richness of the aged fish in a way that water or tea just can't.
Watch the rice hand.
Notice how the chef shapes the rice. It's a movement called kotegaeshi. It looks simple, but it takes years to master the "air pocket" technique that gives the sushi its signature lightness.
Plan ahead for the bill.
Remember that the price usually doesn't include drinks or tip unless specified by the current hotel policy. Expect to spend significantly more than the base omakase price.
Respect the time. These seats are in high demand. If your reservation is at 6:00, be there at 5:50. The rhythm of the meal is timed perfectly, and being late throws off the entire flow for the other guests at the counter.
The reality of Sushi Sho New York is that it's a polarizing place. Some will find the flavors too intense or the portions too varied. But for those who want to see what happens when a master pushes the boundaries of a 200-year-old tradition, there is simply no substitute in the city. It’s a reminder that sushi isn't just about fish and rice—it's about time, patience, and the art of controlled decay.