James Wan didn’t just make a movie in 2013; he basically revived the entire concept of the "haunted house" genre for a new generation. But if you think the story of The Conjuring starts and ends with Vera Farmiga’s stylish coats or Patrick Wilson’s sideburns, you’re missing the actual, much grittier history. The Perron family didn’t live in a polished Hollywood set. They lived in a farmhouse in Harrisville, Rhode Island, that was honestly more of a nightmare than a movie could ever fully capture.
People love the "based on a true story" tag. It sells tickets. But the real story of The Conjuring is a messy, decades-long saga involving a desperate family, two world-famous demonologists, and a local history that reads like a funeral dirge.
The Farmhouse and the Perrons: 1971
Roger and Carolyn Perron bought the Arnold Estate in January 1971. They had five daughters. Andrea, Nancy, Christine, Cindy, and April. It was supposed to be a fresh start—a beautiful 200-acre property with a house dating back to the 1700s. You know how these stories go. They moved in, and almost immediately, things felt... off. It wasn’t just "creaky floorboards" off. It was "somebody is in the room with me" off.
Andrea Perron, the eldest daughter, has spent most of her adult life talking about this. She wrote a massive trilogy of books called House of Darkness House of Light. She doesn't call it a haunting; she calls it a "collision of dimensions." According to her, the spirits didn't wait for an invitation.
Some were harmless. There was a ghost who smelled like flowers and another who supposedly tucked the girls in at night. But then there was the other side of the coin. The side that involved the smell of rotting flesh, beds shaking violently, and physical attacks. Carolyn Perron seemed to be the primary target. This wasn't some slow-burn mystery; it was an all-out psychological assault that lasted for nearly a decade.
Who Was Bathsheba Sherman?
In the movie, Bathsheba is a terrifying, witch-like entity that hangs from trees and crawls on wardrobes. The real story of The Conjuring regarding Bathsheba is a bit more complicated. Bathsheba Sherman was a real person. She lived in the 1800s. She died in 1885.
Local legend claimed she was a practitioner of the dark arts. There was a story about her killing an infant with a knitting needle as a sacrifice, but she was never convicted. In fact, she was buried in consecrated ground at the Harrisville Cemetery. If she were a confirmed witch who sacrificed babies, the church likely wouldn't have allowed that.
Ed and Lorraine Warren, the famous paranormal investigators, were the ones who "identified" Bathsheba as the source of the evil. They claimed she had cursed the land. Whether Bathsheba was actually a demonic entity or just a woman who became the victim of local gossip is a point of massive contention among historians and skeptics. But for the Perrons, the name Bathsheba became synonymous with the terror they felt in that house.
✨ Don't miss: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Ed and Lorraine Warren: Fact vs. Hollywood
The Warrens are the heartbeat of the film franchise. In the story of The Conjuring on screen, they are the heroes who ride in and save the day with a dramatic exorcism.
The reality? The Perrons have a complicated relationship with the Warrens' legacy.
Ed and Lorraine arrived at the house in 1973. They weren't invited by the church; they were contacted by a local group. Lorraine, a self-proclaimed clairvoyant, immediately felt a "dark presence." Ed, the demonologist, began documenting the claims. They didn't charge for their services, which is a point their supporters always bring up to prove their sincerity.
However, the "exorcism" you see in the movie never happened. Not like that.
There was a séance. In 1974, the Warrens brought a medium to the farmhouse. Carolyn Perron was seated in a chair. According to Andrea, who was watching from a hiding spot, her mother became possessed. She didn't just speak in tongues; she supposedly levitated and was thrown across the room. Roger Perron was so terrified and angry that he eventually kicked the Warrens out of the house. He thought they were making things worse.
The Warrens left, but the Perrons stayed. They couldn't afford to move. Think about that for a second. You're living in a house where you think your wife is being possessed by a 19th-century witch, but your bank account says you're staying put. That is the real horror.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Timeline
The movie condenses everything into a few weeks. The real story of The Conjuring took ten years. The Perrons didn't leave until 1980.
🔗 Read more: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
For nearly ten years, they coexisted with whatever was in that house. They learned which rooms to avoid. They learned which "spirits" were okay and which ones meant trouble. It wasn't a constant jump-scare fest. It was a slow, grinding war of attrition.
- 1971: Move-in and initial activity.
- 1973: The Warrens arrive and start their investigation.
- 1974: The disastrous séance that led to the Warrens being kicked out.
- 1974-1980: The family continues to live in the house, dealing with sporadic activity.
- 1980: They finally sell the property and move to Georgia.
When they moved, the activity supposedly stopped for them. But the house remained.
The New Owners and the "Conjuring" Tourism
If you go to Harrisville today, the house is still there. It’s been owned by several people since the Perrons left. Most of them reported nothing. One couple lived there for decades and said the most "paranormal" thing that happened was a door closing once.
Then came the "Conjuring" boom.
In 2019, Cory and Jennifer Heinzen bought the house. They were paranormal investigators. They claimed the activity was very real. They started livestreaming from the house. In 2022, it was sold again for over $1.5 million to a developer who turned it into a full-blown "paranormal destination." You can actually book a stay there now.
Is it still haunted? Or is the story of The Conjuring now a lucrative business model?
Skeptics like Joe Nickell have pointed out that many of the "deaths" associated with the house—suicides, drownings, murders—don't actually show up in the historical records of that specific property. Some happened in the town, but not on the land. Does that matter? To a believer, the energy of a town can infect a house. To a skeptic, it’s a classic case of legend tripping.
💡 You might also like: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
The Psychological Toll
We talk a lot about ghosts, but we don't talk about what this does to a family. The Perron girls grew up in an environment where they couldn't trust their own bedrooms. Carolyn Perron reportedly suffered a nervous breakdown during their time in Rhode Island.
When you strip away the Hollywood jump scares, the story of The Conjuring is actually about a family trapped by poverty and fear. They were stuck in a house they believed was trying to kill them because they had nowhere else to go. That’s more frightening than a doll in a glass case.
Why the Story Still Matters
Why are we still obsessed with this specific case?
It's the "ordinariness" of it. It’s not a gothic castle in Transylvania. It’s a farmhouse. It’s a basement. It’s the laundry room. It taps into the primal fear that our "safe space" isn't actually safe.
Also, the Warrens were masters of PR. They kept meticulous records, took photos, and recorded audio. Even if you don't believe a word they said, they created a "file" that is incredibly compelling for storytellers. They turned ghost hunting into a procedural drama.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Researchers
If you're looking to dive deeper into the real history, don't just re-watch the movie. Here is how to actually explore the story of The Conjuring:
- Read the Source Material: Check out Andrea Perron’s House of Darkness House of Light. It’s long, and it’s dense, but it gives you the "internal" family perspective that the movie ignores.
- Check the Property Records: If you're a history buff, look into the Arnold family tree in Rhode Island. You'll find that the "witch" narrative is much harder to prove than the movie suggests.
- Visit (If You Dare): The Old Arnold Estate is open for tours and overnight stays. Just be aware that it’s a private business now, so the experience is curated for "ghost hunters."
- Listen to the Skeptics: Look up the work of the New England Skeptical Society regarding the Warrens. It’s important to see the "probative" side of the evidence—or lack thereof—to get a balanced view.
The story of The Conjuring is a blend of 18th-century folklore, 1970s paranormal fever, and 21st-century blockbuster filmmaking. Whether the Perrons were haunted by demons or by the stress of their circumstances, the impact on their lives was undeniably real. They survived the house, but the house, in many ways, has never let go of them.