You’ve seen the postcards. You’ve probably seen the selfie-stick crowds huddled on the pedestal. But if you look closely at the torch of Lady Liberty today, you might notice something weird. Or rather, you'll notice what you can't do. You can’t go up there. Since 1916, the torch has been off-limits to the public, and it isn't because of structural rot or modern safety codes. It’s because of an explosion so massive it felt like an earthquake in Maryland. People call it the Statue of Liberty fire event, but it was actually a terrifying act of sabotage that changed New York Harbor forever.
It was 2:08 AM on July 30, 1916.
World War I was raging in Europe, but the United States was technically neutral. "Technically" is the keyword there. In reality, Jersey City’s Black Tom terminal—a jagged little peninsula sticking out into the harbor right next to Liberty Island—was the primary shipping point for American-made munitions heading to Britain and France. On that humid July night, the pier was packed. We’re talking about two million pounds of ammunition. Shrapnel shells, TNT, and black powder were sitting in railcars and on barges, just waiting to be shipped out to the front lines.
The Night the Harbor Burned
The fire started small. Guards spotted a series of small blazes on the pier and on a barge called the Johnson 17. They tried to fight it, but honestly, they didn't stand a chance. When the first major explosion hit, it was the equivalent of a 5.5 magnitude earthquake.
Windows shattered in Manhattan. People as far away as Philadelphia were jolted out of bed, wondering if the world was ending. On Liberty Island, the Lady stood right in the crosshairs. Shrapnel—actual hot chunks of metal and debris—flew through the air like lethal hailstones. The Statue of Liberty was peppered with these fragments. The arm and the torch took the brunt of the damage.
✨ Don't miss: How Long Ago Did the Titanic Sink? The Real Timeline of History's Most Famous Shipwreck
Imagine being the night watchman on the island. One minute it’s a quiet summer night, and the next, the sky is glowing orange and your workplace is being pelted by exploding shells. It’s a miracle the whole thing didn't just topple into the water.
Why the Torch Stayed Closed
Most people think the torch is closed because it’s too narrow. While it’s true that the ladder inside the arm is incredibly cramped—basically a vertical metal pipe with rungs—the real reason for the permanent closure is the structural integrity concerns that started with that 1916 blast.
The explosion caused about $100,000 in damage to the statue at the time. In today’s money, that’s millions. The rivets were strained. The copper skin was pierced in multiple spots. While the National Park Service and various restoration projects (like the massive one in the 1980s) have reinforced the structure, the torch remains a restricted area. It’s a ghost of the Great War.
Interestingly, the torch you see today isn't even the original one. The 1916 damage, combined with decades of leaks caused by the original design's glass panes, meant the torch was basically a bucket for rainwater. During the 1986 centennial restoration, they swapped it out for a new one covered in 24k gold leaf. The original, scarred by the Black Tom explosion and weathered by a century of salt air, now sits in the museum on the island. You can stand right next to it and see the imperfections.
🔗 Read more: Why the Newport Back Bay Science Center is the Best Kept Secret in Orange County
The Sabotage Nobody Mentions
For years, people tried to blame the "Statue of Liberty fire" on accidental negligence. Maybe a guard left a pot of coal burning? Maybe it was a stray spark?
Nope.
It took decades of litigation, but it was eventually proven that German agents had sabotaged the pier. They wanted to stop the flow of weapons to their enemies. Two men, Michael Kristoff and Lothar Witzke, were the primary suspects. It was one of the first major foreign terrorist attacks on American soil, yet it’s barely a footnote in most history books. We talk about Pearl Harbor and 9/11, but the night Jersey City blew up and nearly took out the Statue of Liberty is often forgotten.
The legal battle for reparations actually lasted until 1953. Germany eventually paid out $50 million in damages, a process that took longer than the war itself.
💡 You might also like: Flights from San Diego to New Jersey: What Most People Get Wrong
Visiting Liberty Island Today: A Reality Check
If you're planning a trip to see the site of the Statue of Liberty fire, you need to manage your expectations. You can get into the pedestal. You can (if you book months in advance) get into the crown. But the torch? Forget about it.
- The Crown: It's a 354-step climb. There is no elevator to the top. If you have claustrophobia, this is your nightmare. The windows are tiny, and the space is hot.
- The Museum: This is actually where the best "Black Tom" info is. Seeing the original torch up close gives you a sense of the scale that you just don't get from the ground.
- The View from Liberty State Park: Most people take the ferry from Battery Park in Manhattan. But if you want to see where the explosion actually happened, go to Liberty State Park in New Jersey. There’s a plaque at the "Circle of Flags" that marks the site of the Black Tom explosion. It’s eerie how close it is to the statue.
What We Can Learn From the 1916 Blast
The history of the statue is usually told as a story of friendship between France and the US. But the 1916 events add a layer of grit. It reminds us that even symbols of liberty are vulnerable to the chaos of global politics.
The fact that the statue is still standing is a testament to Gustave Eiffel’s engineering. Remember, Eiffel (the guy who built the tower in Paris) designed the internal iron pylon that holds the copper skin up. His "flexible" design allowed the statue to sway in the wind—and, as it turned out, to survive the shockwaves of a massive munitions blast.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
- Skip the Manhattan Ferry: If you want shorter lines and a better view of the Black Tom site, take the ferry from the New Jersey side (Liberty State Park). It’s generally less crowded.
- Look for the Scars: When you are in the pedestal museum, look at the archival photos of the 1916 repairs. You can see the patches in the copper.
- Visit the Black Tom Memorial: Don't just stay on the island. Go to the actual site of the explosion in Jersey City. It’s a quiet, somber place that puts the scale of the "fire" into perspective.
- Book the Pedestal at Minimum: Even if you can't go to the torch, the pedestal height gives you a clear line of sight to the harbor's layout, making it easier to visualize how the explosion's pressure wave hit the statue.
The Statue of Liberty fire wasn't a singular moment of flames on the copper itself; it was a cataclysmic neighborhood event that left the most famous lady in the world with permanent scars and a permanently closed arm. Next time you see her holding that golden flame aloft, remember that it's a replacement for a torch that saw things no monument ever should.