You know the vibe. It’s that specific brand of cozy comfort that only a Hallmark Channel original can truly nail. When people start searching for the cast of The Star and the Cowboy, they usually aren’t just looking for a list of names they can find on IMDb. They’re trying to figure out why the chemistry between the lead actors feels so familiar or where they’ve seen that rugged ranch hand before.
It’s about the tropes. We love them.
The movie, which hit the Hallmark lineup as part of their massive slate of seasonal romances, follows a predictable but undeniably charming blueprint: a high-profile Hollywood actress finds herself stranded or seeking refuge in a small town, only to clash—and eventually swoon—over a salt-of-the-earth cowboy. It is a tale as old as time, or at least as old as City Slickers, but it works because of the people on screen.
Meet the Leads: Kim Matula and Kevin McGarry
The heavy lifting in the cast of The Star and the Cowboy falls on the shoulders of Kim Matula and Kevin McGarry.
Kim Matula plays the "Star." You might recognize her from her long stint as Hope Logan on The Bold and the Beautiful, a role that earned her a Daytime Emmy nomination. She has this specific ability to play "LA polished" without being unlikable. In this film, her character isn't just a diva; she's a woman looking for something real.
Then there’s Kevin McGarry. Honestly, if you watch Hallmark, you know Kevin. He’s basically the king of the network right now, thanks largely to his role as Nathan Grant on When Calls the Heart.
McGarry plays the "Cowboy." He brings that quiet, stoic energy that the script demands. It’s not just about the hat or the way he leans against a fence post—though he does that well—it’s the way he plays the skeptic. His character doesn't care about her IMDB credits or her follower count. He cares if she can pull her weight.
✨ Don't miss: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
Why Their Chemistry Matters
Chemistry is hard to fake. In many TV movies, you can see the actors waiting for their cues. Here, Matula and McGarry have a rhythmic back-and-forth. It’s fast. It’s snappy. It feels like two people who are genuinely annoyed by each other before they fall in love.
That "enemies-to-lovers" pipeline is the backbone of the movie.
The Supporting Players: Who Else Is in the Cast?
While the leads get the posters, the supporting cast of The Star and the Cowboy fills out the world. A small town doesn't feel like a small town without a busybody neighbor or a wise mentor figure.
- The Family Connection: Often in these films, the cowboy has a younger sibling or a daughter who acts as the bridge between the two worlds. These roles provide the "soften the blow" moments where the actress shows she’s actually great with kids or animals.
- The Agent: Back in Hollywood, there's always the frantic agent or manager. This character serves as the ticking clock, constantly calling to remind our lead that her "real life" is waiting.
The casting directors for Hallmark projects usually pull from a reliable stable of Canadian and American talent. You’ll notice a lot of these faces pop up in Evergreen or Christmas in July specials. It’s a literal ecosystem of actors who know exactly how to deliver a heartfelt monologue while holding a mug of cocoa or a lasso.
Realism vs. Romance: The Cowboy Trope
Let’s be real for a second. The way the cast of The Star and the Cowboy portrays ranch life is... polished.
Real ranching involves a lot more mud, sweat, and financial stress than you see on the screen. But that’s not why we watch. We watch for the aesthetic. We want the sunsets over the mountains. We want the flannel shirts that look brand new even after a day of "work."
🔗 Read more: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Kevin McGarry’s performance anchors the fantasy. He makes the cowboy life look aspirational rather than exhausting.
Production Facts and Trivia
The movie was filmed primarily in British Columbia, Canada. This is standard for the genre. The landscape provides that sweeping, majestic backdrop that makes the Hollywood actress’s fish-out-of-water story feel visually grounded.
Interestingly, many fans of the cast of The Star and the Cowboy followed the production through social media teasers. McGarry and Matula both shared glimpses of the set, which, in the world of Hallmark fandom, is basically gold.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Cast
People often dismiss these actors as "just" TV movie stars. That’s a mistake.
The workload on a film like this is intense. We’re talking about shooting an entire feature-length movie in 15 to 20 days. That requires the cast to be incredibly prepared. There is no time for "finding the character" on set. You show up, you know your lines, and you hit your marks.
Kim Matula’s background in soap operas is the perfect training for this. Soaps are the ultimate grind. They teach you how to deliver emotion on demand. When you see her character having a breakthrough moment in the barn, that’s years of technical skill at work.
💡 You might also like: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
The Lasting Appeal of The Star and the Cowboy
Why does this specific configuration of the cast of The Star and the Cowboy resonate?
It's the contrast. You have the modern, fast-paced world crashing into the traditional, slow-paced world. It’s a "grass is greener" story.
Most viewers are sitting in their suburban homes or city apartments, overwhelmed by emails and notifications. Seeing a cast portray a life where the biggest problem is a broken fence or a misunderstood heart is a form of digital detox.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you enjoyed the performances in this film, here is how you can dive deeper into the work of this specific cast:
- Follow the Hallmark Cycle: Both Matula and McGarry are frequently cycled into new projects. Check the "Movies & Mysteries" schedule, as they often transition into more dramatic or mystery-based roles there.
- Explore Their Roots: Watch Matula’s early work in The Bold and the Beautiful to see her range. Similarly, McGarry’s work in Heartland offers a more rugged, long-form look at the cowboy archetype he plays here.
- Check Social Media for BTS: Hallmark actors are notoriously interactive with their fans. They often host "Live" sessions during the premiere of their movies, giving context on what it was like to film specific scenes.
- Look for Crossovers: Don't be surprised if you see these two paired again. Hallmark loves "re-teaming" successful couples because they know the chemistry is already proven.
The cast of The Star and the Cowboy succeeds because it doesn't try to be something it's not. It’s a well-acted, beautifully shot piece of escapism. It reminds us that sometimes, the best way to find yourself is to get lost in the middle of nowhere with someone who doesn't know your name but knows your heart.
To stay updated on future projects from these actors, keep an eye on official network press releases. These performers are prolific, and they usually have two or three projects in the pipeline at any given time. Watching their evolution from soap stars and procedural actors into the faces of modern romance is a journey in itself.
Next time you see Kevin McGarry in a Stetson, you’ll know exactly why he’s there. He’s the anchor of the fantasy, and Kim Matula is the perfect audience surrogate, discovering that maybe, just maybe, the simple life isn't so simple after all.
Enjoy the reruns. They’re usually on every few months.