Let’s be real for a second. If you mention The Sound of Music Live to a theater nerd, they’ll probably either sigh deeply or go on a twenty-minute rant about "stunt casting." It has been over a decade since that December night in 2013 when NBC decided to broadcast a three-hour, high-stakes musical experiment into nearly 19 million homes. At the center of the storm was Carrie Underwood, a woman who can out-sing almost anyone on the planet but had never actually, well, acted.
It was a massive gamble.
The hills weren't just alive; they were under a microscope. NBC spent roughly $9 million to turn an aircraft hangar-sized soundstage into the Austrian Alps. No safety net. No "let’s do that take again." Just a country superstar in a dirndl, some very expensive sets, and the ghost of Julie Andrews looming over everything like a mountain peak.
Why the Critics Went for the Jugular
The morning after the broadcast, the reviews were... harsh. That’s putting it lightly. While the ratings were "stratospheric"—NBC's best non-sports Thursday in years—the critical reception felt like a cold splash of water. Most critics, like those at USA Today and The Washington Post, basically said the same thing: Carrie Underwood can sing the paint off a barn, but her acting was "wooden."
There was this "deer in headlights" quality that people couldn't stop talking about.
🔗 Read more: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
Honestly, it’s a bit of a weird situation to put someone in. You’re asking a singer used to connecting with an audience through a microphone to suddenly inhabit a character who has to fall in love with a stern Captain (played by True Blood's Stephen Moyer) in front of a dozen cameras. The chemistry? People said it was non-existent. Some viewers on Twitter even joked that the Von Trapp kids had more romantic tension with their governess than the Captain did.
It Wasn't the Movie You Remember
One thing most people got wrong back then—and still get wrong today—is that this wasn't a remake of the 1965 movie. It was a live production of the 1859 Broadway stage play.
This matters. A lot.
If you were waiting for Maria to spin around in a meadow during the title song, you were disappointed because, in the play, that song happens in the Abbey. There were "new" songs like "How Can Love Survive?" and "No Way to Stop It" that featured Elsa (the fabulous Laura Benanti) and Max (Christian Borle). These tracks bring a cynical, political edge to the story that the Julie Andrews movie totally stripped away.
💡 You might also like: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
The Vocal Powerhouse Factor
While the acting was a sticking point, nobody could touch the vocals.
- Audra McDonald: Her "Climb Ev'ry Mountain" basically saved the broadcast. When a five-time (at the time) Tony winner opens her mouth, you listen.
- The Kids: They were surprisingly sharp, especially considering they had to navigate a massive set with "hot" mics that picked up every sniffle and shuffle.
- Carrie's Voice: Even her detractors admitted she handled the technical shift from country-pop to musical theater with serious grit. She didn't "twang" her way through Rodgers and Hammerstein. She studied. She worked.
The Technical Nightmare Behind the Scenes
Watching it now, you notice things you might have missed in the 2013 Twitter frenzy. There was a persistent hum in the audio. That wasn't your TV. Because they used air mics (lavaliers hidden in hair or clothing) rather than close-mics, the sensitivity had to be cranked up. You could hear the air conditioning. You could hear the actors' feet hitting the floor.
Carrie actually tweeted before the show about some "self-inflicted" injuries, including hitting herself in the head with a guitar and a leapfrog accident. It sounds like a comedy of errors, but the reality of live TV is brutal.
"Mean People Need Jesus"
The fallout got personal. After the "onslaught of negative feedback," as some outlets called it, Carrie didn't just stay quiet. She hopped on Twitter and posted a now-famous response: "Plain and simple: Mean people need Jesus." She cited 1 Peter 2:1-25.
📖 Related: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
It was a quintessential Carrie move—leaning into her faith while essentially telling the "haters" to back off. And honestly? She had a point. The vitriol coming from some corners of the Broadway community felt less like constructive criticism and more like gatekeeping.
Was it a Failure?
Hardly. Look at what happened next:
- Peter Pan Live! (NBC)
- Grease: Live (FOX)
- The Wiz Live! (NBC)
- Rent: Live (FOX)
Without Carrie Underwood and the massive 18.6 million people who tuned in to see if she'd mess up, the modern era of "Event TV" musicals wouldn't exist. She proved that there was a massive, hungry audience for theater in the living room.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Critics
If you're going back to re-watch The Sound of Music Live, or if you're just curious about why it still pops up in your feed, keep these things in mind:
- Listen to the Cast Recording: Separated from the "stiff" acting, the soundtrack is actually quite beautiful. Carrie’s "The Sound of Music" is a masterclass in vocal control.
- Watch for Elsa and Max: Benanti and Borle are the secret weapons of this production. Their scenes give the show a "grown-up" vibe that the movie lacks.
- Check the Credits: Notice the names. This wasn't some cheap production; it was helmed by Craig Zadan and Neil Meron, the powerhouses behind the Chicago movie.
The legacy of this performance isn't just about whether Carrie could act. It’s about the fact that she was brave enough to try something that could have career-endingly failed on national television. She didn't fail. She just wasn't Julie Andrews. And maybe, in 2026, we can finally admit that's okay.
To truly appreciate the nuance of this version, try watching the 1965 film and the 2013 live version back-to-back. Pay attention specifically to the political subplots involving Elsa Schraeder; you'll realize the live version is actually much more faithful to the original, darker stage script than the "sweet" movie ever was.