It was a massive gamble. In December 2013, NBC decided to do something that hadn't been a regular part of the network landscape for over half a century: broadcast a full-scale Broadway musical live. People thought it would be a train wreck. Social media was already sharpening its knives before the first note of "The Sound of Music" even played. But then, Carrie Underwood stepped onto that mountain set, and suddenly, 18.6 million viewers were hooked.
The Sound of Music Live TV show wasn't just a one-off holiday special. It was the start of a weird, wonderful, and occasionally cringey era of "event television" that tried to save network TV from the looming shadow of Netflix.
The Night Everything Changed for NBC
You have to remember what TV looked like back then. Most shows were losing audiences to DVR and early streaming. Advertisers were panicked because nobody was watching commercials anymore. Then, Craig Zadan and Neil Meron—the producers who basically resurrected the movie musical with Chicago—pitched the idea of a live Sound of Music. They didn't want to remake the Julie Andrews movie. They wanted to go back to the original 1959 Rodgers and Hammerstein stage play.
That distinction is important.
Fans of the 1965 film were confused. Where was "I Have Confidence"? Why was "The Lonely Goatherd" in a different place? Honestly, the backlash started almost immediately because people didn't realize they were watching the stage version, not a shot-for-shot remake of the movie they grew up with. Despite the confusion, the numbers were staggering. It was NBC's highest-rated non-sports Thursday night since the ER finale in 2009.
Carrie Underwood and the Casting Controversy
Let's talk about Carrie. She was at the height of her country music powers. She could hit the notes. She looked the part. But she wasn't an actress, and she certainly wasn't Julie Andrews. The internet was brutal. Critics pointed out her stiff delivery, especially in the dialogue-heavy scenes between Maria and the Mother Abbess.
But here’s the thing: she carried that three-hour broadcast on her shoulders.
Supporting her was a powerhouse of actual Broadway royalty. Audra McDonald—the woman has six Tony Awards, for crying out loud—played the Mother Abbess. When she sang "Climb Ev'ry Mountain," it didn't matter if the sets looked a bit like plastic or if the lighting was a little flat. She brought the house down. You also had Stephen Moyer, fresh off True Blood, playing Captain von Trapp, and Christian Borle and Laura Benanti stealing every scene they were in as Max and Elsa.
Benanti and Borle were the secret weapons. They brought a sophisticated, cynical energy that balanced out the sugary sweetness of the children. Their performances reminded everyone that the stage play is actually a bit more political than the movie usually gets credit for.
Why the Live Format is a Technical Nightmare
Doing a live musical isn't like filming a sitcom. It’s a logistical heart attack. For The Sound of Music Live!, they used a massive soundstage at Grumman Studios in Bethpage, New York. There were no retakes. If a child actor tripped, or a mic went out, or a costume change failed, millions of people would see it in real-time.
There were 12 cameras. Think about that.
The directors, Beth McCarthy-Miller and Rob Ashford, had to choreograph not just the actors, but the camera operators and the stagehands moving massive set pieces in total silence. It’s basically a high-stakes sport. One of the most fascinating things about the Sound of Music Live TV show was the "hate-watching" phenomenon. Twitter (now X) was a wildfire of memes. People were waiting for something to go wrong. When it didn't—when the show actually functioned as a professional piece of theater—the narrative shifted from "this is going to be a disaster" to "wow, they actually pulled it off."
The Stage Version vs. The Movie Version
If you only know the movie, the live TV show felt "wrong." But it was actually more "right" to the source material. In the stage musical, Elsa Schraeder and Max Detweiler have two songs that were cut from the film: "How Can Love Survive?" and "No Way to Stop It."
These songs are essential.
✨ Don't miss: Hacks Season 4 Episode 7: Is the Deborah and Ava Partnership Finally Reaching a Breaking Point?
They show that Elsa and Max are willing to compromise with the Nazis to keep their lifestyle. It makes the Captain’s stand much more lonely and heroic. By including these, the live TV show actually offered a deeper look at the pre-war tension in Austria than the movie ever did. It wasn't just about a nun and some kids; it was about the encroaching darkness of the Anschluss.
The Ripple Effect: What Came After
Because The Sound of Music Live! was such a monster hit, every other network tried to catch lightning in a bottle. We got Peter Pan Live! (the one with Allison Williams and a very confused Christopher Walken), The Wiz Live!, Grease: Live, and Hairspray Live!.
Some were better. Grease: Live on Fox actually used a live audience and moved between different stages on golf carts, which added an energy that the NBC Sound of Music lacked. But without Carrie Underwood taking that first leap, none of those shows would have been greenlit. It proved that people would still sit down at a specific time to watch the same thing together.
The Lasting Legacy of the Von Trapps on TV
People still debate Underwood’s performance. They still argue about whether live TV musicals are a "valid" art form. But you can't argue with the impact. This broadcast brought Broadway-caliber talent like Audra McDonald and Christian Borle into living rooms that might never get to see a show in New York.
👉 See also: The Last Dragon: Why Bruce Leroy and the Glow Still Matter Today
It also reminded us that Rodgers and Hammerstein were geniuses. Even with the occasionally stiff acting or the weirdly bright "outdoor" sets, the music is bulletproof. "Edelweiss" still makes people cry. "Do-Re-Mi" is still the most effective music lesson ever written.
How to Revisit the Experience
If you're looking to dive back into this specific piece of TV history, don't just look for clips on YouTube. The full production was released on DVD and is often available on BroadwayHD or Peacock.
Actionable Steps for the Musical Enthusiast:
- Compare the Scripts: If you're a theater nerd, find a copy of the 1959 script. Notice how the TV show followed it almost to the letter, unlike the 1965 film.
- Listen to the Soundtrack: The cast recording for the live show is actually excellent. Carrie Underwood’s vocals are technically flawless, and Audra McDonald’s "Climb Ev'ry Mountain" is arguably the best version recorded in the last twenty years.
- Watch the "Making Of" Features: There is a documentary called The Making of The Sound of Music Live! that shows the insane hustle behind the scenes. It’ll make you appreciate the lack of mistakes even more.
- Host a Comparison Night: Watch the first 30 minutes of the Julie Andrews movie and the first 30 minutes of the live special. It’s a masterclass in how different directors interpret the same story.
The Sound of Music Live TV show wasn't perfect, but it was brave. It took a dusty, beloved classic and put it under the most intense spotlight possible. It paved the way for a decade of theater-on-TV and proved that, even in an age of digital everything, there is still something magical about the words "Going live in 5, 4, 3, 2..."