He was the man who saw soldiers falling into his camp like grasshoppers from the sky. Tatanka Iyotake, known to the world as Sitting Bull, wasn't just a Hunkpapa Lakota holy man; he was the ultimate symbol of resistance against an expanding United States. But even in death, he couldn't find a moment of peace.
If you're looking for the Sitting Bull burial site, you're going to have to make a choice. You can head to Fort Yates, North Dakota, or you can drive down to Mobridge, South Dakota.
Both places claim him. Both have monuments. And honestly, the story of how he ended up in two places at once is a messy, controversial saga of grave robbing, midnight heists, and deep-seated cultural tension that still simmers today. It's not just about a grave. It's about who owns history.
The Cold Morning at Grand River
To understand the grave, you have to understand the death. It was December 15, 1890. The Ghost Dance movement was sweeping through the plains, making the U.S. government incredibly twitchy. They feared Sitting Bull would join the movement and spark an uprising.
Indian police, acting on orders from Agent James McLaughlin, burst into Sitting Bull’s cabin on the Grand River. A scuffle broke out. Shots were fired. By the time the smoke cleared, Sitting Bull was dead, shot in the head and chest.
His body was taken to Fort Yates.
The military didn't want his grave to become a shrine for the Lakota. They didn't want a place where people could gather and remember his defiance. So, they did something pretty cold. They put his body in a pine box, filled it with quicklime to accelerate decomposition (and discourage souvenir hunters), and buried him in the corner of the military cemetery.
No ceremony. No honors. Just a hole in the ground.
💡 You might also like: Flights to Chicago O'Hare: What Most People Get Wrong
The 1953 Midnight Heist
For over sixty years, the Sitting Bull burial site stayed in North Dakota. But his family wasn't happy about it. They felt the site was neglected, overgrown, and—most importantly—not where he wanted to be. Sitting Bull had expressed a desire to be buried in his birthplace near the Grand River, which sits just across the border in South Dakota.
Enter Grey Eagle.
In 1953, Clarence Grey Eagle, a descendant of the leader, decided he’d had enough of North Dakota’s red tape. He formed a group, secured what they claimed was permission from the surviving granddaughters, and headed to Fort Yates under the cover of a cold April night.
They didn't ask the state of North Dakota for permission. They just started digging.
By the time the sun came up, they had exhumed what remained of the bones—which, thanks to the quicklime and the passage of time, wasn't a whole lot—and rushed them across the state line to Mobridge, South Dakota. They quickly reburied the remains and poured a massive slab of concrete over the top to make sure nobody could steal him back.
North Dakota was furious. They called it grave robbing. South Dakota called it a homecoming.
Two Sites, One Spirit
So, where is he actually?
📖 Related: Something is wrong with my world map: Why the Earth looks so weird on paper
If you visit the Sitting Bull burial site in Fort Yates today, you'll see a modest stone marker surrounded by a tall chain-link fence. It’s quiet. Some people believe that because the quicklime had done its work, the South Dakota team only grabbed a few fragments, and the "true" essence of the leader remains in North Dakota soil.
Then there’s the Mobridge site.
Perched on a high bluff overlooking the Missouri River, this site is much more "monumental." There’s a massive bust of Sitting Bull sculpted by Korczak Ziolkowski, the same man who started the Crazy Horse Memorial. The view is staggering. You can see for miles across the plains he once roamed.
- Fort Yates (North Dakota): The original location. It feels more somber, perhaps more authentic to the tragedy of his end.
- Mobridge (South Dakota): The family’s choice. It’s grander and offers a sense of vindication for those who felt he was a prisoner of war even in his first grave.
The reality is likely somewhere in the middle. Archaeologists and historians have debated for decades whether the 1953 party actually got all the remains or if they missed the primary burial spot entirely in the dark.
Why the Controversy Still Matters
You might think this is just a dispute over old bones. It isn't.
For the Lakota people, the Sitting Bull burial site represents the struggle for sovereignty. When North Dakota refused to move the body for decades, it was seen as a final act of colonial control. When the family took the body back, it was an act of reclamation.
But even the Mobridge site has faced issues. Over the years, it has been vandalized. People have chipped away at the monument. There have been ongoing discussions about moving the remains yet again—this time to a more private, secure location on tribal land where tourists can't poke and prod at the site.
👉 See also: Pic of Spain Flag: Why You Probably Have the Wrong One and What the Symbols Actually Mean
Ladonna Brave Bull Allard, a noted Lakota historian, often spoke about the complexity of these sites. It’s not just a tourist stop. It’s a place of immense spiritual weight. When you stand at either site, you aren't just looking at a grave; you're looking at the scars of the American Indian Wars.
What to Know Before You Visit
If you’re planning a trip to see the Sitting Bull burial site, you need to be respectful. These aren't just "attractions."
- Check the weather. Both sites are in the heart of the Dakotas. Wind speeds on those bluffs near Mobridge can be brutal, and winter travel in this region is no joke.
- Understand the geography. The two sites are about an hour and a half apart. You can easily see both in a single day if you’re doing a road trip through the Standing Rock Reservation.
- Respect the offerings. You will likely see tobacco ties (small bundles of cloth), sage, or coins left at the graves. Do not touch these. They are sacred offerings left by people coming to pay their respects or seek healing.
- The Mobridge Monument. To get to the South Dakota site, you’ll head off Highway 12. It’s a bit of a drive up the hill, but the road is generally well-maintained.
- The Fort Yates Marker. This is located within the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe’s jurisdiction. It’s much more understated. If you blink, you might miss the turn-off.
The Actionable Bottom Line
Don't just go to see a monument. Use the visit to understand the history of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe.
Start your journey at the Standing Rock Institute of Natural History in Fort Yates. It gives you the necessary context of the Hunkpapa Lakota people before you stand at the grave of their greatest leader.
If you want the full experience, drive the Native American Scenic Byway. This route connects both burial sites and takes you through the heart of the lands Sitting Bull fought to protect. It’s one thing to read about "The West" in a textbook; it’s another thing entirely to see the Missouri River carving through the breaks while you stand at the spot where a legend was laid to rest—twice.
Verify the current status of the sites before heading out. Occasionally, tribal land access can change due to local events or road maintenance. Bring a physical map, as cell service on the reservation can be spotty at best. Stand in the wind, look at the river, and think about the man who refused to sell his soul to a government that didn't understand the value of the grass beneath his feet.