Disney+ threw a curveball back in 2020. They dropped a movie that felt like X-Men met The Princess Diaries, and honestly, people actually liked it. We’re talking about Secret Society of Second-Born Royals. Since it hit the streaming platform, fans have been obsessing over the Secret Society 2 cast and whether we’d ever see that specific group of super-powered misfits back on screen together. It’s been a minute.
Success in the streaming world is fickle. One day you're the top-trending title in the UK and US, and the next, you're a "cult classic" waiting for a greenlight that might never come. Peyton Elizabeth Lee led the charge as Sam, the rebellious princess who discovers she has literal superpowers. She wasn't alone. The chemistry between the core five was the engine of the movie.
But here is the thing. Hollywood moves fast. The kids who played those teenagers are adults now. If a sequel ever happens—and the rumors never truly die—the Secret Society 2 cast would look a lot different than they did in that first summer of the pandemic.
Who Made Up the Original Team?
Peyton Elizabeth Lee was already a Disney darling thanks to Andi Mack. In this flick, she played Sam. She’s grumpy, she’s punk rock, and she’s got "super-senses." Think Daredevil but with a crown. Lee has stayed busy. She moved on to Doogie Kamealoha, M.D., which basically solidified her as the face of Disney’s modern era.
Then you have Niles Fitch. He played Tuma. You probably recognize him as the teenage Randall from This Is Us. Fitch made history as Disney’s first live-action Black prince, which is a pretty huge deal if you think about it. His character had the power of "mental persuasion," which is just a fancy way of saying he could make people do whatever he wanted.
Isabella Rice played Heather. She was the bubbly one, but her power was actually terrifying: she could manipulate atoms to become invisible. Rice has been working since she was a literal child, appearing in True Blood and Pretty Little Liars.
✨ Don't miss: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
Rounding out the core students were Olivia Deeble as Roxana and Faly Rakotohavana as Matteo. Deeble is an Australian actress who came over from Home and Away. Her character was an influencer who could turn invisible (social media irony, right?). Rakotohavana played the shy kid who could control insects. It sounds gross, but it was actually one of the cooler visual effects in the film.
The Mentors and Villains
You can't have a secret society without a teacher. Skylar Astin played Professor James Morrow. If you've seen Pitch Perfect or Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist, you know Astin brings a specific kind of "musical theater energy" to everything he does. In this world, he could multiply himself.
The "bad guy" was Greg Bryk as Inmate 34 (later revealed to be Sam’s uncle, Edmond). Bryk is one of those character actors who shows up in everything from The Expanse to The Handmaid’s Tale. He plays "creepy but charismatic" better than almost anyone in the business.
Why We Haven't Seen the Secret Society 2 Cast Reunited
Look. It’s been years. Usually, if a Disney+ original is getting a sequel, it’s announced within six months. The Secret Society 2 cast has basically scattered to the winds of other projects. Peyton Elizabeth Lee is a lead in major series. Niles Fitch is doing prestige dramas.
The director, Anna Mastro, has been busy directing episodes of high-profile TV like The Rookie and Gossip Girl. When a creative team finds success elsewhere, getting everyone back in the same room is a logistical nightmare. It’s not just about interest; it’s about contracts, aging, and budget.
🔗 Read more: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
There was a lot of chatter in 2021 about a script being in development. Some "insider" blogs claimed the sequel would focus on a new batch of recruits with the original cast moving into mentor roles. But Disney has been tightening its belt. They've canceled more shows than they've renewed lately. Unless there is a massive groundswell of viewership on the original movie, the likelihood of the full Secret Society 2 cast returning for a feature film gets lower every day.
What a Potential Sequel Would Actually Look Like
If Disney did pull the trigger, the story would have to jump forward. You can't pretend these actors are fifteen anymore. Sam would likely be a full-fledged agent.
- Sam (Peyton Elizabeth Lee): Likely the leader of the new tactical unit.
- Tuma (Niles Fitch): Perhaps working in diplomacy, using his persuasion for actual politics.
- Matteo (Faly Rakotohavana): Could have mastered larger-scale "beast control."
The dynamic would shift from "high school angst" to "international espionage." The first movie set up a world where every monarchy has a second-born with a superpower. That’s a massive sandbox to play in. You could introduce royals from different cultures, different power sets, and higher stakes.
Honestly, the most interesting route for a Secret Society 2 cast would be a "passing of the torch" narrative. Bring back Lee and Astin as the veterans and introduce a new group of younger actors. It’s the classic Disney reboot formula.
The Reality of Streaming Numbers
Let's be real for a second. We don't see the internal data. Netflix, Disney+, and Max keep their "minutes viewed" pretty close to the chest unless it's a massive hit like The Mandalorian. Secret Society of Second-Born Royals did well, but did it do Hocus Pocus 2 numbers? Probably not.
💡 You might also like: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
The fans who are still searching for the Secret Society 2 cast are a dedicated bunch, but Hollywood runs on mass appeal. There is also the issue of the "Disney Channel" stigma. Sometimes these movies are seen as "one-and-done" events meant to keep kids occupied for a weekend rather than the start of a massive franchise.
Final Verdict on the Cast and Future
The Secret Society 2 cast represents a specific moment in streaming history. It was a time when Disney was trying to figure out what a "Disney Plus Original Movie" actually looked like. They landed on something that was fun, diverse, and surprisingly well-acted.
While there is no official production date for a sequel, the actors haven't ruled it out. In various interviews over the years, Peyton Elizabeth Lee has expressed love for the character. Niles Fitch has joked about wanting to wear the suit again.
If you're a fan, the best thing you can do is keep the "talk" alive. Streaming services track social media sentiment. If people keep asking about the Secret Society 2 cast, the suits in Burbank might eventually take notice.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
If you want to see these actors again or keep up with the potential for a sequel, here is the move:
- Follow the cast on social media. Specifically, watch Peyton Elizabeth Lee and Niles Fitch's Instagram feeds. They are the most likely to drop a "reunion" photo or a hint about a project.
- Rewatch on Disney+. The algorithm prioritizes content with high re-watch rates. If the original movie starts trending again, the chances of a sequel increase exponentially.
- Check out the actors' other work. To see the range of the Secret Society 2 cast, watch Doogie Kamealoha, M.D. (Lee), This Is Us (Fitch), and Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist (Astin).
- Monitor trade publications. Avoid the "fan theory" blogs. Keep an eye on The Hollywood Reporter, Variety, or Deadline. If a sequel is actually happening, it will break there first.
The original film is still a solid watch for anyone who likes the "superpowers in hiding" trope. Even if we never get a second chapter, the cast has proven they are some of the most talented young actors in the industry today.