Ghost stories are usually about what we can’t see, but the real punch of James Herbert’s work—specifically his 2006 novel and the subsequent BBC adaptation—is that it focuses on what we refuse to see. Most people think of The Secret of Crickley Hall as just another "creepy house with a basement" trope. It’s not. It is a grueling exploration of grief, the cyclical nature of trauma, and the very real historical horrors of how society once treated "unwanted" children.
If you’ve watched the 2012 miniseries starring Suranne Jones and Tom Ellis, you know it feels heavy. It’s supposed to. Unlike a lot of modern jump-scare horror, this story relies on an oppressive atmosphere. It’s wet. It’s gray. It’s miserable. The Caleigh family moves to the north of England to escape the crushing weight of their son Cam’s disappearance, only to find that the house they’ve rented is literally leaking the past into the present.
What Actually Happened at Crickley Hall?
The "secret" isn't a single twist. It’s a layered reveal of institutional cruelty. During World War II, Crickley Hall served as an orphanage for children evacuated from London to escape the Blitz. On the surface, it was a sanctuary. In reality, it was a nightmare run by Augustus Cribben and his sister, Magda.
Cribben wasn't just a strict disciplinarian; he was a sadist who used the "fear of God" to justify physical and psychological torture. When the local area flooded in 1943, the children didn't just drown by accident. They were trapped. They were left behind. This is where Herbert’s writing gets visceral. He doesn't let you off the hook with a "tragic accident" explanation. He forces you to confront the idea that the ghosts in the cellar are angry because they were betrayed by the very people who were supposed to keep them safe from the bombs.
Honestly, the most disturbing part of the whole narrative isn't the ghosts themselves. It’s the complicity of the town. People knew something was wrong at that house. They heard the screams. They saw the bruises. But because it was wartime and the Cribbens were "doing their bit" for the war effort, everyone looked the other way. That’s a recurring theme in British folk horror—the idea that the community is just as guilty as the monster.
💡 You might also like: Cliff Richard and The Young Ones: The Weirdest Bromance in TV History Explained
Why the 2012 Adaptation Still Holds Up
The BBC version, directed by Joe Ahearne, managed to capture that specific damp, cold feeling of the British countryside that is so central to the book. Suranne Jones gives a performance that is honestly painful to watch at times because her grief is so raw. You’ve got a mother who is literally losing her mind with hope that her missing son is still alive, and then she’s thrust into a house where dead children are crying out for help.
The production design used a lot of practical effects. When the water starts seeping through the walls, it doesn't look like CGI; it looks like a plumbing disaster. That groundedness makes the supernatural elements hit harder.
- The Sound Design: They used a lot of low-frequency hums and the sound of rushing water. It creates a physical sense of dread in the viewer.
- The Casting: Seeing a pre-Lucifer Tom Ellis play a grieving, skeptical father provides a great foil to the more emotional beats of the story.
- The Timeline Jumps: The show cuts between 1943 and the present day with a jarring rhythm that makes you feel like the two eras are bleeding into each other.
There’s a specific scene involving a cane—Cribben’s "tool"—that serves as a physical manifestation of the haunting. It’s not just a ghost holding a stick; it’s the memory of pain that has become so concentrated it has developed a physical presence. That’s a classic James Herbert move. He was a master of taking a mundane object and making it feel absolutely foul.
Addressing the Misconceptions
Some critics at the time felt The Secret of Crickley Hall was a bit too "old fashioned." They missed the point. It was a deliberate throwback to the M.R. James style of ghost story, where the haunting is a result of a specific transgression against the natural order.
📖 Related: Christopher McDonald in Lemonade Mouth: Why This Villain Still Works
A lot of people also get confused about the ending regarding Cam. In the book, the resolution is a bit more bleak than the TV show. The show gives the audience a bit more "closure," which some fans of the novel found a bit too neat. But in both versions, the core message remains: you cannot bury the past, especially when the past involves the suffering of the innocent. The water imagery is a metaphor for that—you can try to dam it up or hide it in the basement, but eventually, the pressure builds until the walls crack.
The Real-World Inspiration Behind the Horror
While Crickley Hall itself is fictional, the conditions of wartime evacuations and the "homes" for orphans were often far from the idyllic country life portrayed in propaganda films. James Herbert often pulled from the darker corners of British history.
There were documented cases of abuse in various institutions during the 1940s where oversight was non-existent because of the war. When you read the accounts of real-life evacuees, many talk about the "culture of silence." If you were a city kid sent to a remote village and your host was a monster, who were you going to tell? The local copper who had known that host for forty years? Probably not.
How to Experience the Story Today
If you want the full experience, start with the novel. It’s long, and Herbert spends a lot of time on the internal monologues of the ghosts, which is something the TV show couldn't quite replicate. Then, watch the three-part miniseries.
👉 See also: Christian Bale as Bruce Wayne: Why His Performance Still Holds Up in 2026
- Read the book first to understand the specific "rules" of the haunting. Herbert explains how the ghosts manifest in a way that makes the scares more logical.
- Watch the BBC series for the atmosphere and the acting.
- Research the history of the 1940s evacuations. It adds a layer of reality to the horror that makes the fictional elements much more poignant.
The haunting isn't about the jump scares. It’s about the fact that we, as a society, often prefer to forget the uncomfortable parts of our history. Crickley Hall won't let you forget. It forces the characters—and the audience—to stand in the basement and listen to the water rising.
Final Takeaways for Fans
If you're looking for more like this, look into the "Urban Gothic" or "Rural Noir" genres. Authors like Susan Hill (The Woman in Black) or even modern writers like Andrew Michael Hurley (The Loney) tap into that same sense of "the land remembers what we did."
To get the most out of The Secret of Crickley Hall, pay attention to the recurring symbols: the cane, the water, the cellar door, and the dog. Each represents a different stage of the family's journey through grief. The dog, in particular, is a classic trope—animals sensing the supernatural—but here it feels more like a guardian of the boundary between the living and the dead.
Don't just look for ghosts. Look for the reasons why they are still there. In the case of Crickley Hall, they aren't there to scare people; they are there because they have no place else to go. They are waiting for someone to finally acknowledge what happened in 1943. Once the truth is out, the haunting doesn't necessarily stop, but the power shift happens. The survivors get to walk away, while the monsters are finally left alone with their own shadows.