The laundry room is still white. The soda is still dirty. But the drama? It’s getting a massive upgrade. After the whirlwind success of the first season, Hulu wasted almost zero time pulling the trigger on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2. Honestly, if you watched the first eight episodes, you saw this coming from a mile away. You just can't leave a group of "soft-swinging" influencers at a crossroads like that and not expect the cameras to keep rolling.
Taylor Frankie Paul, the woman who basically set the Utah influencer scene on fire with a single TikTok live, is back. But this time, the stakes feel heavier. It’s not just about who slept with whom anymore. It’s about whether this group of women can actually survive the fame they chased so hard.
When is The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2 actually happening?
Hulu officially greenlit 20 additional episodes. That is a massive order. Usually, streamers hedge their bets with a standard eight or ten, but the metrics for Momtok were clearly through the roof. 2025 is the target. While we don't have a specific day circled on the calendar yet, production schedules for reality TV in this vein suggest a mid-to-late 2025 release. They want to strike while the iron is hot.
The first season dropped in September 2024. If they follow that cycle, we’re looking at about a year of filming and editing.
The "Sinners and Saints" vibe is the show's bread and butter. It’s that weird, fascinating intersection of high-stakes religion and modern-day influencer culture. You have women who are terrified of their bishops but also terrified of their engagement rates dropping. It’s a tension that feels uniquely 2020s.
Who is staying and who is walking away?
Cast shakeups are the lifeblood of reality TV. We know the core is returning. Taylor is the Sun that all these planets orbit, so she's a lock. Mayci Neeley, the supposed voice of reason who often found herself in the middle of every fire, is also coming back.
📖 Related: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
But then there's Whitney Leavitt.
Whitney is the "villain" everyone loves to dissect. Her move to Hawaii and her exit from the group chat at the end of Season 1 was the cliffhanger to end all cliffhangers. Rumors are swirling about how much she'll actually be involved. Does she stay in Hawaii? Does she come crawling back to Draper? The dynamic between Whitney and Demi Engemann was so fractured by the finale that seeing them in a room together again is going to be the main event of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2.
Layla Taylor and Mikayla Matthews are also expected to return, though fans are hoping for a bit more screen time for them. Jen Affleck, whose marriage to Zac became one of the most discussed—and criticized—parts of the show, has a lot of explaining to do. People were genuinely worried about her. Watching how that marriage evolved after the show aired and the public reacted is going to be a very meta experience in the new episodes.
The Zac Affleck controversy and the fallout
Let's talk about Zac. The internet had a collective meltdown over his behavior during the Vegas trip. The gambling, the texts to Jen, the ultimatum—it was a lot. In The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2, we are going to see the direct aftermath of that public backlash.
Zac is finishing medical school. That was his "out" for a lot of his behavior—the stress, the pressure. But viewers didn't buy it. Jen has defended him on social media since the show aired, claiming that editing made things look worse than they were. We've heard that one before. It’ll be interesting to see if he tries to do a "redemption arc" or if he leans further into the "traditional patriarch" role that caused so much friction.
👉 See also: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
New faces and the "Momtok" expansion
You can't have 20 episodes without some fresh blood. The Mormon influencer circle in Utah is surprisingly small but also incredibly dense. There are dozens of women who were peripheral to the "Swinging Scandal" who are likely dying for a chance to hold a heavy-duty Stanley cup on camera.
Expect "friends of" the cast to be upgraded to full-time members. The show needs people who aren't exhausted by the first season's trauma to stir the pot.
Why this show actually matters (beyond the gossip)
It’s easy to dismiss this as trashy TV. It kinda is. But it’s also a weirdly profound look at women trying to navigate autonomy in a patriarchal structure. These women are the primary breadwinners. They make more money than their husbands by filming themselves dancing in kitchens. That flips the traditional LDS power dynamic on its head.
In The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2, expect more conversations about "The Church." The first season touched on it, but the ladies were often vague. Now that they've seen how the audience responded to their honesty, they might peel back more layers of the onion. How do you stay a "good Mormon" when you’re the face of a show called The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives? You don't. Or you redefine what that means.
What fans are actually asking for
The Reddit threads and TikTok comments are loud. People want less staged "confrontations" and more of the actual day-to-day tension of living in a community where everyone knows your business. They want to see the fallout with the families. We saw a bit of Taylor’s mom, but what about the others?
✨ Don't miss: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
The scandal that started it all—the "soft swinging" at the 2022 party—is old news now. The show needs a new engine. Whether that's a new legal drama, a divorce, or a massive betrayal within the group, the producers are likely working overtime to ensure the "secret lives" aren't just limited to what happened three years ago.
Real-world impact on the LDS community
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints hasn't issued a formal "don't watch this" decree, but the cultural impact in Utah is undeniable. Local businesses featured on the show saw spikes in traffic. The "Dirty Soda" craze went global.
But there’s a darker side. Some of the women have talked about being ostracized in their local wards. In the upcoming season, seeing that social isolation play out in real-time will be fascinating. It’s one thing to be TikTok famous; it’s another to have your neighbors refuse to sit next to you at Sunday service.
Actionable insights for fans following the story
If you're looking to stay ahead of the curve before the new episodes drop, here is how you can track the real-time drama that will inevitably end up on screen:
- Watch the TikTok bios: In the world of Momtok, a deleted name or a changed bio is a legal document. When Whitney removed "Momtok" from her bio, it was the first sign of the Season 1 fracture. Keep an eye on Taylor and Mayci's following lists.
- Monitor the podcasts: The cast has been doing a "world tour" of podcasts like The Viall Files and Call Her Daddy. These interviews often contain "spillover" information that doesn't make the final edit of the show but provides context for the feuds in Season 2.
- Check the filming locations: If you’re in the Salt Lake City or Draper area, filming usually happens in public spaces like Swig or local boutiques. Social media tags at these locations often leak plot points months in advance.
- Follow the "husbands" of Momtok: While the women are the stars, the husbands often let things slip on their IG stories. Dakota (Taylor's partner) and Zac Affleck are particularly prone to posting things that hint at the current temperature of the group.
The reality is that The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2 isn't just a sequel; it’s the beginning of a brand-new era for the "Mormon-ish" subgenre of reality TV. The mask is off, the secrets are mostly out, and now we get to see what happens when the dust actually settles. Or, more likely, when they kick up a whole new cloud of it.