Walk into any old-school bodybuilding gym and you’ll hear the same sermon. If you aren’t pressing a heavy barbell over your head while standing, you aren’t really training. It's a classic "hardcore" sentiment. But honestly? For most people—and even for most high-level athletes—the seated overhead press machine is often the smarter choice.
It isn't "cheating."
When you sit down in that padded chair and grab the handles, you’re stripping away the fluff. You don't have to worry about your lower back arching like a banana. You don't have to worry about your knees wobbling or your core giving out before your deltoids do. You're just moving weight. Pure, unadulterated tension on the shoulders.
The Stability Paradox: Why Machines Build More Muscle
Most people think stability is a crutch. They've been told that "functional training" requires you to balance on one leg while juggling kettlebells. That's fine if you're training for the circus. But if you want big, capped shoulders, you need stability.
Science backs this up. The more stable your body is, the more force your brain allows your muscles to produce.
When you use a seated overhead press machine, your nervous system stops panicking about you falling over. It basically says, "Okay, we’re safe, let's fire all the fibers." This is why you can often handle more significant mechanical tension on a machine than with dumbbells. Dumbbells are great, sure. But your smaller stabilizer muscles—the rotator cuff and serratus anterior—often fatigue long before the medial and anterior delts.
If your goal is hypertrophy, the machine is king. You can push to absolute failure without the risk of dropping a 60-pound weight on your skull.
Finding the Right Line of Force
Not all machines are built the same. You’ve probably seen some that feel like they're trying to rip your rotator cuffs out of their sockets.
Ideally, you want a machine with a converging path. This means the handles move slightly closer together as you reach the top of the movement. Why? Because that's how your body actually moves. Your arms don't just go straight up in a vacuum; they naturally want to follow the scapular plane.
The Scapular Plane Secret
If the machine forces your elbows straight out to the sides (the "goalpost" position), be careful. This puts a lot of stress on the subacromial space. Basically, you’re pinching stuff in your shoulder that shouldn't be pinched.
👉 See also: Why the Nautilus Lower Back Machine is Still the Gold Standard for Spine Health
The best way to use the seated overhead press machine is to tuck your elbows in slightly—about 30 to 45 degrees forward. This aligns the movement with your shoulder blades. It feels "greased." It feels natural. If the machine handles are wide and fixed, you might need to adjust your seat height to find a "sweet spot" where your joints aren't screaming.
Plate-Loaded vs. Selectorized
You have two main choices here.
The selectorized machines—the ones with the pin and the weight stack—are incredible for drop sets. You hit 10 reps, pull the pin, move it up, and go again. No rest. The tension is constant because of the cable pulley system.
Then you have plate-loaded machines, like the ones from Hammer Strength. These usually have a more "raw" feel. Because they use a physical pivot point, the strength curve often changes throughout the rep. Usually, it gets easier at the very top. This is actually pretty helpful because it matches our natural strength curve; we are strongest at the end of the press.
Common Blunders (And How to Fix Them)
The Ego Seat Height: Most people sit too low. If the handles are starting behind your ears, you’re in a biomechanical nightmare. Raise the seat. The handles should start right around chin or collarbone level.
The "Ass-Slide": As the weight gets heavy, you’ll want to slide your butt forward on the seat. Don't. This turns the shoulder press into a weird, incline bench press. You end up using your upper chest instead of your shoulders. Keep your spine glued to the back pad.
Death Gripping: You don't need to squeeze the life out of the handles. A firm grip is good, but over-gripping can lead to forearm fatigue or even elbow tendonitis over time.
📖 Related: When Do Babies Have Growth Spurts: The Real Timeline for Exhausted Parents
Flaring the Ribs: Even though you’re seated, your core matters. If you arch your back excessively to get the weight up, you're just begging for a disc issue. Brace your abs like someone is about to punch you.
Programming for Real Progress
How should you actually fit the seated overhead press machine into your routine?
It shouldn't necessarily be your first lift every time. If you’re doing a "Push" day or a shoulder-specific day, you might want to start with a heavy compound movement like a barbell press or a heavy incline. Use the machine as your second "big" lift.
Think in the 8 to 12 rep range.
This is the "sweet spot" for muscle growth. Since the machine handles the stability for you, you can really focus on the eccentric—the lowering phase. Take three seconds to lower the weight. Feel the stretch in the bottom position. Then, explode up.
If you're an advanced lifter, try "rest-pause" sets.
Go to failure.
Breathe for 15 seconds.
Go to failure again with the same weight.
It’s brutal, but it works.
Myths About "Functional" Strength
Let's address the elephant in the room: the idea that machines don't build "real" strength.
If you can press 200 pounds on a machine, you are objectively strong. Will it perfectly transfer to a standing overhead press? Not 1:1. You’ll still need to learn how to stabilize your core for the standing version. But your muscles will have the raw horsepower to move the weight.
Professional athletes use machines all the time. Why? Because they can't afford to get injured. A machine provides a controlled environment to build power without the high-risk profile of a barbell. For someone over 40, or someone with a history of lower back tweaks, the seated overhead press machine isn't just an option—it’s often the best tool in the shed.
✨ Don't miss: Why The Salmonella Egg Recall Keeps Happening and How to Actually Stay Safe
The Verdict on Variety
Should you exclusively use the machine?
Probably not.
The human body thrives on variety. But don't let anyone tell you that you're less of a lifter because you prefer the machine. Use it for what it's for: isolated, high-intensity hypertrophy. Save the "functional" stuff for your accessory work or your sports-specific drills.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Workout
To get the most out of your next session, follow this checklist:
- Adjust the seat first. Ensure the handles are level with your upper chest/chin at the start.
- Check your elbow angle. If the machine allows, keep your elbows tucked slightly inward rather than flared out wide.
- Feet flat, back flat. Plant your heels. If your feet are dancing around, you’re losing power.
- Control the negative. Don't let the weight stack slam. Fight the resistance on the way down for a full two-count.
- Focus on the squeeze. At the top of the rep, don't just lock out your elbows; think about pushing your biceps toward your ears to fully engage the deltoid.
If you find that your shoulders are feeling "clicky" or irritated, try decreasing the range of motion slightly. You don't always have to go all the way down to the stops if your anatomy doesn't like it. Listen to your joints; they're smarter than your ego.