When the first notes of "Red Right Hand" kicked in for the second time back in 2014, nobody really knew how much the world of Small Heath was about to explode. Season 1 was a tight, localized gritty drama. But the season 2 cast Peaky Blinders ensemble turned it into a sprawling, multi-city war that essentially redefined British television.
Honestly, looking back at that roster is like seeing a "before they were famous" gallery mixed with some of the heaviest hitters in cinema. You've got Cillian Murphy firmly in his stride, but then the producers decided to drop a literal acting nuke into the mix with Tom Hardy.
It changed the energy. It wasn't just about a small-time Birmingham gang anymore. It was about London, the Italians, and the deep, dark secrets of the Shelby bloodline.
The Big Three: Tommy, Arthur, and Polly
We can't talk about the new faces without acknowledging the foundation. Cillian Murphy as Tommy Shelby is the obvious anchor. By season 2, he’s no longer just a shell-shocked veteran; he’s a man with a map of London and a very dangerous ambition.
Then there's Paul Anderson as Arthur Shelby. Man, he’s heartbreaking this season. You see the "Tokyo" induced PTSD really starting to shred his psyche. Watching him try to find peace through cocaine and boxing, only to fail miserably, is a masterclass in acting.
And of course, Helen McCrory as Aunt Polly. Rest in peace to a legend. In season 2, she gets one of the most intense arcs in the show's history—searching for her lost children. It’s raw. It’s uncomfortable. It’s why we loved her.
💡 You might also like: Actor Most Academy Awards: The Record Nobody Is Breaking Anytime Soon
Tom Hardy and the Alfie Solomons Phenomenon
Let's be real: most people searching for the season 2 cast Peaky Blinders are actually just looking for Tom Hardy.
His debut as Alfie Solomons in Episode 2 is the stuff of legend. Alfie is a Jewish gang leader based in Camden Town, and he is... well, he’s a lot. He’s eccentric, he’s violent, and he talks in these rambling, poetic circles that make you forget he’s holding a pistol under the table.
Hardy brought this weird, unpredictable levity to a show that was otherwise very "stone-faced." His chemistry with Murphy is electric because they don't just act at each other—they seem to be trying to out-weird each other. It’s brilliant.
The London Rivals: Noah Taylor as Darby Sabini
While Alfie was the wildcard, Darby Sabini was the true shark in the water. Played by Noah Taylor, Sabini represented the established Italian mob in London.
He was nasty. Remember that scene in the club where he basically tries to perform amateur dental surgery on Tommy? That’s Darby Sabini. Taylor played him with this high-pitched, neurotic energy that made him feel genuinely dangerous. He wasn't a physical powerhouse like Arthur, but he had the reach and the coldness to dismantle the Shelbys from a distance.
📖 Related: Ace of Base All That She Wants: Why This Dark Reggae-Pop Hit Still Haunts Us
The New Generation: Finn Cole as Michael Gray
Season 2 also introduced the "next era" of the family. Finn Cole joined the cast as Michael Gray, Polly’s long-lost son who was taken by the authorities years prior.
Michael starts out as this clean-cut boy from the countryside. He’s the "innocent" one. But as the season progresses, you see that Shelby blood start to boil. Cole plays the transition perfectly—from a curious outsider to someone who realizes he actually likes the smell of gunpowder. It set the stage for everything that happened in the later seasons (and we know how that ended).
The Women Who Complicated Everything
Tommy’s love life in season 2 was a total mess, but it made for great TV. Annabelle Wallis returned as Grace Burgess, but the real standout newcomer was Charlotte Riley as May Carleton.
Riley (who is actually married to Tom Hardy in real life) played a wealthy horse trainer. She represented a life Tommy could have had—one of legitimacy, estates, and quiet mornings.
- May Carleton: The posh, lonely widow who understood Tommy’s horses but maybe not his soul.
- Grace Burgess: The ghost of the past who shows up just when Tommy thinks he’s moved on.
- Lizzie Stark: Played by Natasha O’Keeffe, she moves from a guest role to a series regular this season, becoming Tommy’s secretary and a vital part of the business.
Supporting Players You Might Have Forgotten
The world-building in this season was dense. We had Sam Neill returning as the obsessed Major Chester Campbell. Honestly, he’s even more loathsome here than in season 1. His vendetta against Tommy becomes personal, creepy, and eventually his downfall.
👉 See also: '03 Bonnie and Clyde: What Most People Get Wrong About Jay-Z and Beyoncé
We also saw:
- Jordan Bolger as Isiah Jesus (the son of Jeremiah the preacher).
- Harry Kirton taking over as a slightly older Finn Shelby.
- Ned Dennehy as the eternally reliable (and creepy) Charlie Strong.
- Packy Lee as Johnny Dogs—the best friend everyone needs.
Why This Specific Cast Worked
The reason the season 2 cast Peaky Blinders felt so special is that it didn't feel like a sequel. It felt like an expansion.
Usually, when a show adds a "big movie star" like Tom Hardy, it breaks the immersion. But Hardy disappeared into Alfie. The addition of Michael Gray added a ticking time bomb to the family dynamic. And the Sabini/Solomons rivalry gave the show a larger political context that it desperately needed to move past the foggy streets of Birmingham.
Basically, if you're looking to jump back into the series or you're a newcomer, season 2 is where the show finds its "final form." It’s the perfect blend of historical drama and rock-and-roll gangster epic.
To get the most out of your rewatch, pay close attention to the background characters in the Eden Club scenes. Many of the extras were local Birmingham and London locals who brought a level of authenticity to the "roaring twenties" vibe that high-budget Hollywood productions often miss. You can also track the subtle shift in Michael Gray's wardrobe; as he gets closer to Tommy, his clothes get darker and sharper, signaling his loss of innocence long before he ever picks up a gun.