The San Francisco 1906 earthquake: What most people get wrong about the disaster

The San Francisco 1906 earthquake: What most people get wrong about the disaster

At 5:12 a.m. on April 18, 1906, the ground beneath San Francisco didn’t just shake. It ruptured. Most people think of earthquakes as a quick rattle—a few seconds of nerves followed by a social media post. This wasn’t that. For roughly 45 to 60 seconds, the San Andreas Fault tore open, a 296-mile stretch of the earth's crust snapping like a dry twig.

It was loud. It was violent. It basically unmade the city in a minute.

But here’s the thing: the San Francisco 1906 earthquake didn't actually destroy the city. Not by itself. If you look at the old photographs, you see a lot of standing buildings that are just... hollow. That's because the fire did the real dirty work. We’re talking about a three-day inferno that consumed over 500 blocks. Honestly, if you were standing on Nob Hill that morning, you weren't just worried about the floor falling out; you were watching the very water mains you needed to save the city snap like glass under the pavement.

Why the 1906 earthquake was a geological freak show

We measure things differently now, but seismologists like those at the USGS estimate the magnitude was around 7.9. That is massive. To give you some perspective, the 1989 Loma Prieta quake that everyone remembers for collapsing the Bay Bridge? That was a 6.9. Because the Richter scale is logarithmic, the 1906 event was roughly 10 times larger in terms of amplitude and released about 32 times more energy.

The slip was horizontal. This is what geologists call a strike-slip fault. In some places near Olema in Marin County, the ground shifted a staggering 20 feet in an instant. Imagine a fence line. One second it's straight, the next, the left half is 20 feet further down the road than the right half. It's surreal to think about.

It wasn't just a local tremor. The shockwaves were felt from southern Oregon all the way down to Los Angeles, and as far inland as central Nevada.

The "Ham and Eggs" Fire and other disasters

Most people focus on the shaking, but the fire was the real killer. It started in multiple places, but one of the most famous (and preventable) was the "Ham and Eggs" fire. A survivor tried to make breakfast on a stove where the chimney had been damaged by the quake. That sparked a blaze that burned down a huge chunk of the city.

🔗 Read more: El Cristo de la Habana: Why This Giant Statue is More Than Just a Cuban Landmark

Then you had the Fire Department. Or what was left of it. The fire chief, Dennis Sullivan, was mortally injured when a chimney fell through his home during the initial tremor. Without his leadership, and with the water mains shattered, the firefighters were basically helpless. They resorted to using dynamite to create firebreaks.

It backfired.

Inexperienced troops and firefighters often ended up just blowing up buildings and creating more fuel for the fire. It was a mess. A literal, hot, smoking mess.

The human cost nobody wanted to admit

For decades, the official death toll was listed at around 475 or 500. This was a total lie. City officials and business leaders were terrified that if the "real" number got out, it would scare off investors and insurance companies. They wanted San Francisco to seem like a safe place to rebuild.

Gladys Hansen, a legendary San Francisco archivist, spent years debunking this. We now know the death toll was likely over 3,000.

Think about that.

💡 You might also like: Doylestown things to do that aren't just the Mercer Museum

Thousands of people lived in the "South of Market" area, which was built on reclaimed swamp land. When the quake hit, that soil underwent "liquefaction." It basically turned into quicksand. Whole tenement buildings sank or collapsed instantly. Many of the victims were poor immigrants whose deaths weren't recorded with the same meticulousness as the wealthy residents of Pacific Heights.

The refugee camps

Over 200,000 people—roughly half the population—were left homeless. They fled to Golden Gate Park and the Presidio. If you go to the park today, it’s hard to imagine it covered in "earthquake shacks." These were tiny, 140-square-foot wooden boxes painted "park conservative" green to blend in with the trees.

Interestingly, some of these shacks still exist. People actually bought them after the camps closed, hauled them onto lots, and turned them into real houses. You can still find a few "shack" houses in neighborhoods like Bernal Heights if you know what to look for.

Insurance drama and the "Fire vs. Earthquake" loophole

The recovery was a legal nightmare. Most homeowners had fire insurance, but almost nobody had earthquake insurance.

Because of this, there’s a dark bit of history where people actually set fire to their own partially collapsed homes just so they could claim the insurance money. If the earthquake knocked your house down, you were broke. If it burned down, you might get a check.

Insurance companies in London, like Lloyd’s, actually paid out. Cuthbert Heath, a famous underwriter, famously told his agents to "pay all our policyholders in full, irrespective of the terms of their policies." That move basically cemented Lloyd’s reputation for the next century, but it also cost them a fortune—about $50 million back then, which is billions today.

📖 Related: Deer Ridge Resort TN: Why Gatlinburg’s Best View Is Actually in Bent Creek

Lessons for the modern world

You’ve probably heard people talk about "The Big One." It’s not just a movie trope. The San Francisco 1906 earthquake taught us that the San Andreas Fault is a sleeping giant that wakes up roughly every 100 to 150 years.

We aren't waiting for if. We are waiting for when.

The 1906 disaster changed how we build. It led to the first real seismic building codes. It changed how we handle water—San Francisco eventually built the Hetch Hetchy reservoir partly to ensure they’d never run out of water to fight a fire again. It even changed the field of geology itself. Before 1906, we didn't really understand how faults worked. The "Elastic Rebound Theory" came directly out of the study of this specific quake.

What you should actually do now

If you live in or are visiting the Bay Area, don't just treat this as a history lesson. It’s a blueprint for what's coming.

  • Check the liquefaction maps. If you’re buying a house or renting an Airbnb, look at the USGS hazard maps. If the ground is "fill" (like the Marina District or SOMA), it will shake much harder than the bedrock on Twin Peaks.
  • Retrofitting is non-negotiable. If you own a "soft-story" building (those apartments with big garage openings on the first floor), it needs to be braced. Those are the first to pancake.
  • Keep 72 hours of water. In 1906, the water was gone instantly. Modern systems are better, but they aren't perfect. You need a gallon per person per day.
  • Visit the sites. Go to Dolores Park and look at the "Golden Hydrant." It’s the one hydrant that didn't fail in 1906 and is credited with saving the Mission District. Every April 18th at 5:12 a.m., people gather there to paint it gold. It’s a weird, beautiful San Francisco tradition.

The 1906 disaster was a tragedy, but it also defined the resilience of the city. San Francisco was rebuilt in record time, largely because the people refused to let the city die. They paved over the rubble—literally, much of the debris was used as fill for the Marina—and kept going. That's the real legacy of the quake. It wasn't the end; it was just a very violent, very dusty new beginning.

Actionable Next Steps:

  1. Download the MyShake App: Developed by UC Berkeley, this gives you a few seconds of warning before the shaking starts.
  2. Locate your gas shut-off valve: Knowing how to turn this off can prevent your house from becoming the next "Ham and Eggs" fire.
  3. Visit the Ferry Building: It’s one of the few major structures that survived both the 1906 and 1989 quakes. Look at the clock tower; it’s a testament to good engineering.