Most people remember the bright, bubbly 90s sitcom where Melissa Joan Hart’s biggest problem was her talking cat and a math test. But honestly? That’s not where the live-action story actually started. Before the laugh tracks and the neon-colored 90s wardrobe of the ABC show became a staple of our childhoods, there was a weirdly moody, low-budget television film that basically served as the blueprint. It’s a strange little relic from 1996 that most fans have completely wiped from their memory.
You probably didn't know that Sabrina’s last name wasn’t even Spellman in the original movie.
The Sabrina the Teenage Witch Movie: A Forgotten Riverdale Crossover
The 1996 Sabrina the Teenage Witch movie premiered on Showtime, not ABC, and it feels fundamentally different from the series that followed just months later. For one thing, it’s set in Riverdale. Yeah, that Riverdale. Long before KJ Apa was brooding in a leather jacket, this movie explicitly placed Sabrina Sawyer—not Spellman—in the Archie Comics universe's most famous town.
It’s kind of wild to look back on now. The film was shot in British Columbia, Canada, and it has that distinct, rainy, Pacific Northwest grey sky that would eventually become the hallmark of the gritty Chilling Adventures of Sabrina decades later. But back in '96, it was just a cheap way to film a TV pilot.
👉 See also: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
If you watch it today, the biggest "wait, what?" moment is seeing a 19-year-old Ryan Reynolds. He plays Seth, the high school hunk who is, frankly, kind of a jerk. Sabrina spends most of the movie pining over him while ignoring the actual nice guy, Harvey Kinkle.
Why the Cast Was Almost Entirely Swapped
If you’re a die-hard fan of Aunt Hilda and Aunt Zelda, watching the movie is going to be a jarring experience. Caroline Rhea and Beth Broderick are nowhere to be found. Instead, we get Sherry Miller and Charlene Fernetz. They’re fine, but they don't have that iconic "bickering sister" energy that made the sitcom work.
- Sabrina’s Parents: In the movie, both of her parents are actually witches. This is a massive departure from the show, where her mother is a mortal and her father is the warlock.
- The Best Friend: Michelle Beaudoin is the only actor besides Melissa Joan Hart to make the jump from the movie to the series. But even she got a reboot. In the movie, her name is Marnie; in the show, she’s Jenny.
- The Mean Girl: There is no Libby Chessler here. Instead, we have Katie La More, a blonde cheerleader who is more "generic 90s bully" than the legendary "Freakazoid"-shouting Libby.
The tone is just... off. It’s less of a sitcom and more of a "teen drama with magic." There’s a scene where Sabrina literally chases Ryan Reynolds’ car down and makes out with him after a dance. Melissa Joan Hart has actually gone on record in recent years saying she and Ryan had a "thing" during filming. She even mentioned that he gave her a watch on the last day of shooting. It’s the kind of behind-the-scenes trivia that makes the movie way more interesting than the actual plot.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
Why the Movie Canon Doesn't Make Sense
If you try to fit the Sabrina the Teenage Witch movie into the show’s timeline, your brain will start to hurt. It’s basically an alternate dimension. In the movie, Sabrina finds out she’s a witch in the middle of the night after she has already turned 16. In the show, it happens on her 16th birthday morning.
Also, Salem is a whole different beast. He still talks, but he’s not the world-dominating warlock voiced by Nick Bakay. His backstory is also different; in the film, he was turned into a cat for kissing someone who didn't love him back. It's much softer—and honestly, less funny—than the "tried to take over the world" motive we got later.
The movie ends with Sabrina and Harvey together, but Harvey is played by Tobias Mehler, not Nate Richert. He’s portrayed as a bit of a nerd who fixes cars. When the show was greenlit, the producers clearly realized they needed more "Golden Retriever energy," which is how we got the Nate Richert version of Harvey we all know and love.
🔗 Read more: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
How to Watch It Today
Finding this movie isn't as easy as hitting play on Disney+ or Netflix. It often floats around on Tubi or Prime Video depending on licensing, but it’s frequently labeled as a "Pilot Movie." It’s a fascinating time capsule of mid-90s fashion and pre-superstar Ryan Reynolds.
If you’re planning a rewatch, keep these things in mind:
- Ignore the Last Names: Just accept that she's Sabrina Sawyer for 90 minutes.
- Look for the Cameos: Since it was filmed in Vancouver, you’ll see a lot of faces that popped up in The X-Files and other Canadian-produced shows of that era.
- The Wardrobe: It is peak 1996. Think velvet, chokers, and way too much hair gel on the guys.
The Sabrina the Teenage Witch movie serves as a reminder of how much a show can change between the pilot phase and the actual series. Without the feedback from this film, we might never have gotten the snappy dialogue, the iconic aunts, or the Salem we spent seven seasons laughing with. It’s the "rough draft" of a cultural phenomenon.
To truly understand the evolution of the character, you really have to see where the live-action version started. It's not "good" in a traditional sense, but as a piece of pop culture history? It's essential. Check the listings on free ad-supported streaming services like Pluto TV or Tubi, as they often carry these "forgotten" TV movies.