If you grew up in the late 90s, you probably remember the "TGIF" era on ABC. It was a time of baggy jeans, questionable bowl cuts, and a certain blonde witch who lived with her aunts and a talking cat. But honestly, when most people think of Sabrina Spellman, they picture Melissa Joan Hart in a velvet choker. They forget that for a massive chunk of our childhoods, Sabrina wasn't just a sitcom star—she was a Saturday morning cartoon staple that basically rewrote its own history every few years.
Actually, calling it "the" Sabrina the Teenage Witch cartoon is a bit of a misnomer. There wasn't just one. Depending on how old you are, you’re either thinking of the groovy 1970s version, the irreverent 90s prequel, or the CGI-heavy 2013 reboot.
It’s kinda wild how much people get wrong about these shows. Most fans think the cartoon was just a direct spin-off of the live-action hit. That’s not quite right. In reality, the animated world of Sabrina is a messy, colorful, and surprisingly deep rabbit hole of "alternate continuities" that often fought with the very show it was supposed to support.
The 1999 Prequel That Wasn't Really a Prequel
The big one—the one most of us remember—is Sabrina: The Animated Series from 1999. It was produced by DIC Entertainment and Savage Steve Holland, the guy behind Eek! The Cat. You can feel his weird energy in every frame.
The marketing pitched it as a "prequel" to the Melissa Joan Hart show. It even featured Melissa's younger sister, Emily Hart, as the voice of 12-year-old Sabrina. Melissa herself voiced the aunts, Hilda and Zelda. But if you actually sit down and watch it, the "prequel" logic falls apart faster than a cheap magic trick.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
- The Power Problem: In the live-action show, Sabrina doesn't get her powers until she's 16. In the cartoon? She’s 12 and already zapping things left and right.
- The "Spooky Jar": This was a weird addition. Since she wasn't supposed to have full powers yet, she "borrowed" spells from a genie-like being in a cookie jar. It was basically a loophole for the writers.
- Uncle Quigley: Who is this guy? He was the "adult" of the house because the cartoon versions of Hilda and Zelda were transformed into teenagers as punishment for abusing magic.
Basically, the 1999 show was an alternate universe where everything was zanier. It didn't care about the sitcom's canon. It cared about being funny, and honestly, it was. The humor was fast, meta, and didn't talk down to kids.
Why the Animation Style Kept Changing
By the time we got to 2003, things got weird. DIC lost their partnership with Disney, and the show shifted into Sabrina's Secret Life. This is where a lot of fans checked out.
The vibe changed completely. Sabrina was now 14 and going to high school. Her best friend Chloe was gone, replaced by Maritza (who, if we're being honest, was just Chloe with a different name). The animation felt a bit cheaper, the colors were "shinier" but less detailed, and the voice cast was almost entirely replaced.
Then, out of nowhere, 2013 happened. Sabrina: Secrets of a Teenage Witch landed on the Hub Network with Ashley Tisdale voicing the lead. It was full CGI. It felt more like a "magical girl" anime than a classic Archie comic. It’s the version that most older fans ignore, but it actually tried to do some interesting world-building with "Witch World" and a more serious tone.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
The Voice of Salem: The Only Constant
If there is one thing that holds the Sabrina the Teenage Witch cartoon universe together, it’s the cat. Nick Bakay, the voice of Salem Saberhagen in the live-action show, was the only person who stayed for the 1999 animated series.
Salem is the secret sauce. Without his dry, ego-maniacal wit, the cartoon would have just been another generic kids' show. He was the one who kept the edge. In the 1999 series, Salem was given way more to do because, well, he was a drawing. He could turn into a mouse, fly, and have elaborate dream sequences that a puppet simply couldn't handle.
Later, in Secret Life, Maurice LaMarche took over the role. He’s a legend (The Brain from Pinky and the Brain), but for many, it just wasn't the same. It’s a testament to Bakay’s performance that a talking cat became a feminist icon's most beloved sidekick.
Key Eras of Sabrina's Animated History
| Era | Title | Voice of Sabrina | The "Vibe" |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1970–1974 | The Sabrina the Teenage Witch Show | Jane Webb | Classic Filmation, laugh tracks, very 70s. |
| 1999–2000 | Sabrina: The Animated Series | Emily Hart | Wacky, fast-paced, "prequel" energy. |
| 2003–2004 | Sabrina's Secret Life | Britt McKillip | More serious, high school drama, new cast. |
| 2013–2014 | Sabrina: Secrets of a Teenage Witch | Ashley Tisdale | 3D CGI, magical girl style, very modern. |
What Users Actually Want to Know
People often search for whether these shows are "canon." The short answer? No. The Archie Comics universe is a multiverse. The cartoons, the 90s sitcom, and the dark Chilling Adventures of Sabrina on Netflix are all separate branches of the same tree.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Another common question: "Why did the aunts look like teenagers?" In the 1999 show, this was a creative choice to make them more relatable to the target audience (and to let Melissa Joan Hart play them). It was explained away as a "punishment" from the High Council, which is a classic trope for the Spellman family.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're looking to revisit the Sabrina the Teenage Witch cartoon, don't go in expecting a cohesive story. Treat each series as its own thing.
- Watch the 1999 series if you want 90s nostalgia and genuine laughs. It holds up surprisingly well because of the writing staff’s pedigree.
- Skip Secret Life unless you’re a completionist. The "Chuck Cunningham Syndrome" is strong here—characters disappear without explanation and the tone is a bit inconsistent.
- Check out the 1970s Filmation episodes if you want to see where the "Riverdale" connection started. You'll see Sabrina hanging out with Archie and the gang much more frequently there.
The best way to enjoy these is to embrace the chaos. Sabrina has always been a character about navigating two worlds, and her animated history is a perfect, messy reflection of that. Whether she's 12, 14, or 16, and whether she's voiced by a Hart or a Tisdale, the core remains: magic is a metaphor for the messiness of growing up.
To start your rewatch journey, most of the 1999 series is currently available on various streaming platforms like Pluto TV or Paramount+, depending on your region. Start with "Most Dangerous Witch"—it’s the perfect introduction to why this version of Greendale was so special.